M12.2: select and qualify exact cellular local cohorts
Foundation / checks (deploy) (push) Successful in 5s
Foundation / checks (ecs) (push) Successful in 2m19s
Foundation / postgres-tools (push) Canceled after 0s
Foundation / server-image (push) Canceled after 0s
Foundation / image (push) Canceled after 0s
Foundation / checks (tsan) (push) Canceled after 6m24s
Foundation / checks (network) (push) Canceled after 6m33s
Foundation / checks (postgres) (push) Canceled after 6m34s
Foundation / checks (checks) (push) Canceled after 6m44s
Foundation / checks (client) (push) Canceled after 6m44s

This commit is contained in:
dingo
2026-10-17 12:04:39 -04:00
parent bee57e5829
commit 2b074b9ae1
17 changed files with 762 additions and 149 deletions
+12
View File
@@ -1,5 +1,17 @@
# Project status and next steps
## M12.2d exact cellular cohorts - 2026-10-17
Under the maintainer's delegated M12.2 authority, ADR-0139 selects exact local
cohorts retaining every member. Regional approximation stays disabled. The
[qualification](engineering/M12_EXACT_CELLULAR_COHORTS.md) matches complete
canonical biology over 196,608 paired ticks per compiler, including thousands
of conversion oscillations. Local active fallback samples reach the existing
256-life ceiling with admission backpressure. Release CTest passes 72/72;
clang-format/tidy 19 and ASan/UBSan checks pass. No compression or production
capacity is claimed. Target-host costs and fuller interaction coverage remain
open. Exact-owner durable transitions may proceed without live enablement.
## M12.2c current cellular reference - 2026-10-17
The [rules-8 headless reference](engineering/M12_CELLULAR_REFERENCE.md) passes
@@ -0,0 +1,63 @@
# ADR-0139: Exact retained-member cellular local cohorts
## Status
Accepted for the bounded M12 cellular population implementation, 2026-10-17.
The maintainer delegates M12.2 decisions to the implementing agent, subject to
later revision. This decision does not enable a production selector, increase
capacity, qualify approximate aggregation or authorize deployment.
## Decision
Replace the rejected M4 averaged model with an exact local model for rules 8.
A cohort groups wildlife of one genome in one region, retaining every member's
identity, position, birth tick, growth, damage, reserves, reproduction state and
ancestry. There are no bins, fractional members, random materialization samples,
mean reserves or statistical parentage. The residual is identically zero.
`CellularPopulation` exclusively owns one `CellularLives` store. Sorted membership
tags partition that store into active individuals and cohort members; they are
not a second inventory. The read-only biological view conveys no spending rights.
All actions execute through the population owner. Controlled cells, including
offline/suspended cells, never collapse. Collapse/materialize operates on the
entire eligible wildlife genome group, never a caller-picked healthy subset.
New offspring initially have individual representation. Dead membership is
removed after the successful atomic biological step.
The same bounded wildlife controller and complete shared interaction kernel run
at the existing 50 ms quantum, in the existing life-ID order. Cohort membership
cannot affect intake contention, movement, hunting, budding, mutation, death,
inventory or ancestry. The host submits only controlled intentions; it cannot
supply a different controller for cohorts. No autonomous mutation is introduced.
Biological rules, existing codec versions and old goldens are unchanged.
Keep regional approximation disabled. Do not silently substitute the old M4
model under overload. Retain the existing hard limit of 256 living cells per
region; new admissions backpressure rather than deleting incumbents. This is a
structural ceiling, not a measured service capacity. The operational target is
completion within the 50 ms tick, with measured tail latency and headroom on the
actual deployment host required before enabling a production selector. An
overrun must leave admitted ticks pending, not skip ecology.
Qualification is declared before results: reference seeds 0/1, held-out 2/3,
rich/scarce finite food, conversion oscillation every 1/16/64 ticks, paired full
canonical biology equality every tick. Zero demographic, biomass, diversity,
ancestry or inventory discrepancy is allowed, including false local extinctions.
Report conversion coverage and full owner costs, including active fallbacks at
16/64/128/256 lives. Bin sensitivity is inapplicable: no state is binned. Do not
infer unobserved predation, twins or long-term stability from passing cases.
## Consequences and limits
This resolves the unsafe averaging conflict for an exact local implementation
and permits work on its durable representation. It deliberately trades memory
and computation for fidelity. Cohorts currently provide ownership organization,
not population compression or a demonstrated speedup. The M12.2 target-host cost
gate and scalable approximate model remain open; do not mark the whole gate
passed solely on this decision. Production enabling and higher capacity require
new measured evidence. Future approximation requires a separate version/ADR and
paired evidence; it must not reinterpret these exact members.
The module lives in portable `evo::lifecycle`, independent of renderer, network,
database and clocks. The foundation proof and legacy ecology experiments retain
their existing boundaries. No arbitrary third-party dependency is added.
+2
View File
@@ -155,3 +155,5 @@ design. No unadopted candidate is a link dependency of the proof.
- [ADR-0087: Dev session route](0087-dev-session-route.md) - evolution-dev only: void.aeternalisgames.com:7400 via a dedicated internal MetalLB VIP to the region pod, TLS end to end, CIDR-limited, operator-opened windows enforced by evo-server; committed disabled with fail-closed policy tests.
- [ADR-0086: Windows client package](0086-windows-client-package.md) - static-runtime Windows x64 ZIP with explicit allowlist, licence texts, build identity, SHA256 manifest, credential guards and deterministic layout; local packaging until a Windows runner exists.
- [ADR-0085: Rebindable engineering controls](0085-rebindable-engineering-controls.md) - SDL-free action/HID-key bindings, conflict validation, versioned all-or-nothing controls file, binding capture before toolkit/world.
- [ADR-0139: Exact cellular local cohorts](0139-exact-cellular-local-cohorts.md)
+32
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,32 @@
# Exact cellular local population
[ADR-0139](../adr/0139-exact-cellular-local-cohorts.md) defines the first rules-8
population owner. It owns one biological store and an exclusive representation
tag per cohort member; cohort inventory must never be added to `current_total`
again. Untagged living cells are individuals. Views are read-only.
`create` accepts a non-null rules-8 owner. `collapse(genome)` tags every eligible
zero-account member of that genome, excluding controlled cells. An absent
wildlife group or an ineligible wildlife presence rejects the conversion.
Repeating collapse returns zero without duplicating anything. `materialize`
removes all tags for that genome; an absent cohort is refused. Neither operation
changes the biological snapshot, identities, locations, ages or balances.
`advance_tick` takes exactly the sorted controlled set and optional controlled
mutation selections. It obtains every wildlife intention from the existing
controller, merges in life-ID order and uses the same atomic cellular kernel.
Failed input validation changes neither biology nor membership. Successful death
removes stale ownership tags; funded births begin as individuals. Suspension
continues to freeze controlled biology regardless of representation elsewhere.
The model retains exact members and makes no aggregation speedup claim. There is
no regional population approximation, process migration, production selector or
new persisted format in this segment. The existing 256-life ceiling remains;
target-host service capacity is a separate qualification.
Run `evo-cellular-cohorts --verify` for the CTest matrix or omit the option for
8192 ticks per case. The executable compares complete canonical state every tick,
not just conserved totals. It reports observed conversion/member-tick coverage,
events, costs and 16/64/128/256-life active fallback observations. Shared fixture
setup is identical to the unchanged rules-8 reference; no alternate test biology
or altered golden is used.
+6
View File
@@ -1,5 +1,11 @@
# Ecology and simulation fidelity
M12.2d selects [exact retained-member local cohorts](CELLULAR_POPULATION.md)
under [ADR-0139](../adr/0139-exact-cellular-local-cohorts.md). Paired rules-8
fidelity passes the declared matrix; regional approximation and production
selector enabling remain disabled pending operational qualification. Historical
statements below about no accepted model refer to the earlier M4/M12 baseline.
M12.2c's [current cellular reference](../engineering/M12_CELLULAR_REFERENCE.md)
uses implemented rules 8 and validates exact encoded replay/offline closure. It
is the active control for future cohort comparisons, not a qualified approximate
+11 -3
View File
@@ -9,8 +9,8 @@ Commit and push each validated scoped segment separately.
| Subset | State | Evidence or condition for completion |
|---|---|---|
| 12.1 | Engineering evidence policy and explicit deferrals documented | ADR-0133, identity/time contract and worked histories; no new game rules or runtime versions. |
| 12.2 | Baseline reproduction (12.2a), exact-strata instrument (12.2b) and rules-8 cellular reference (12.2c) complete; cohort qualification open | The old widths remain rejected. Synthetic exact-state and current cellular controls pass; an actual paired cellular/cohort model and target-host fallback budgets remain required. |
| 12.3 | Blocked on 12.2 | No accepted population model, deterministic durable conversion sample or profile integrating cellular/cohort state. |
| 12.2 | Exact local model selected and paired qualification implemented (12.2d); production cost gate open | ADR-0139, exact canonical equality across 196,608 paired ticks per platform. Regional approximation disabled; no compression claim. Deployment-host capacity and fuller interaction coverage remain open. |
| 12.3 | Exact-owner durable implementation authorized; production enabling depends on qualification | ADR-0139 resolves the averaging conflict for retained members. Durable conversion closure/publication remains to implement. |
| 12.4 | Blocked on 12.2-12.3 | Existing cellular worker pauses without sessions/lingering players; bounded unattended recovery and biological migration escrow remain unimplemented. |
| 12.5 | Blocked on 12.2-12.4 | Finite M6 process fixtures do not qualify coupled persistent cellular/cohort atmosphere/water budgets. |
@@ -42,7 +42,15 @@ non-timing outputs agree; native Release CTest passes 71/71. This is an exact
reference control; the paired cellular/cohort model, fuller predation/capacity
matrix and target-host budgets remain open. No automatic tier selector is enabled.
## Architectural conflict and resolution
## Architectural conflict and resolution (updated 2026-10-17)
The maintainer delegates M12.2 decisions, subject to later revision. ADR-0139
selects exact retained-member local cohorts instead of the failed average model.
[Paired results](M12_EXACT_CELLULAR_COHORTS.md) validate biological equality with
conversion oscillation and local fallback samples up to the existing 256-cell
ceiling. This permits implementing durable exact ownership without enabling a
production selector. Target-host/scaling gates remain explicit; the historical
conflict below still prohibits deploying approximate aggregation.
Automatic transitions or regional aggregation now would conflict with ADR-0041
and ECOLOGY_MODEL: the measured model can erase viable populations while exactly
@@ -0,0 +1,57 @@
# M12.2d exact cellular cohort qualification
Decision: [ADR-0139](../adr/0139-exact-cellular-local-cohorts.md), accepted under
the maintainer's delegated M12.2 decision authority. The rules-8 model retains
every member exactly. Regional approximation remains disabled. No compression,
speedup, deployment or production capacity is claimed.
## Executed evidence, 2026-10-17
Full Release runs on MSVC 19.44 and GCC 14.2 use the current reference's four
seeds (0/1 development, 2/3 held out), rich/scarce finite deposits and conversion
oscillation widths 1/16/64. Each of 24 cases compares complete canonical
biological snapshots at every one of 8192 ticks: **196,608 paired ticks** per
platform, with zero state error. All non-timing paired JSON fields agree across
compilers. The original reference's setup, rules and goldens are unchanged.
Across these repetitions: **2354 collapsed members, 2354 materialized members,
6380 cohort member-ticks, 12 offspring, 48 applied mutations and 57 deaths**.
Counts include repeated reference scenarios at three conversion widths, not
independent biological replicates. Some rich seeds produce no offspring; the
test requires actual conversion coverage in seed 1 and across the full matrix.
The short CTest also runs that long seed-1 case, preventing a vacuous pass with
no cohorts. Controlled founder collapse, missing intentions, duplicate collapse
and repeated materialization refusals preserve state. Per-tick checks validate
tags against live unowned active cells and preserve total inventory.
Raw output: [MSVC](results/m12-2d-cohorts-msvc1944.jsonl),
[GCC](results/m12-2d-cohorts-gcc14.jsonl).
| Living cells | MSVC p95 step (ms) | GCC/WSL p95 step (ms) | Snapshot bytes |
|---|---:|---:|---:|
| 16 | 0.045 | 0.058 | 21,108 |
| 64 | 0.274 | 0.200 | 71,076 |
| 128 | 0.773 | 0.777 | 137,700 |
| 256 | 2.359 | 2.326 | 270,948 |
These are 32 local warm stepping observations per size, fully funded controlled
founders and finite contact food. They include the complete biological owner
step but exclude network, storage/publication, rendering, initialization and
the qualification's byte comparisons. They are not a mature wildlife stress
workload, long-term tail distribution or the Linux deployment host. Refusing a
257th admission leaves the existing 256 alive and the snapshot unchanged.
The hard ceiling is retained; production headroom remains unqualified.
## Limits and next work
Local exact-state fidelity passes the declared matrix; useful aggregation and
target-host fallback capacity remain open parts of M12.2. The largest observed
cohort in these ecological histories is small. Full predation, twin-bud,
multi-member cohort, capacity wildlife and blocked-resume matrices need stronger
coverage before production enablement. No arbitrary approximation may fill that
gap. Bins do not exist; widths change conversion timing, not biological quantum.
M12.3 can implement the exact owner's durable conversion contract without
enabling a live selector. Database publication, process loss and deployment
qualification must be reported separately from codec/replay success. No World0
state is accessed.
+23
View File
@@ -1,5 +1,28 @@
# Validation report
## 2026-10-17 - M12.2d exact cellular cohorts
ADR-0139 selects exact retained-member local cohorts under delegated M12.2
decision authority. Changes affect portable lifecycle orchestration, a shared
rules-8 qualification fixture and the paired executable, not the foundation
proof, old ecology model, persisted versions, goldens or live world.
Executed: MSVC 19.44 Release configure/build and **72/72 CTests** outside the
filesystem sandbox; GCC 14.2 Release build/reference and cohort CTests; full
24-case cohort matrices on MSVC/GCC with all non-timing paired fields equal;
clang-format 19 repository check, clang-tidy 19 analysis build and both affected
CTests (23.81 s); ASan/UBSan cohort CTest with required nonempty conversion case
(61.58 s), no reports. Tests use explicit checks under NDEBUG. No threading added.
Full evidence: [M12_EXACT_CELLULAR_COHORTS](M12_EXACT_CELLULAR_COHORTS.md).
196,608 canonical paired comparisons per platform, zero state error; 2354
collapses and 2354 materializations. Local 32-sample capacity observations at
16/64/128/256 cells include stepping, not publication or network. The R730/worker
deployment host was not measured; no service-capacity acceptance follows. The
initial short matrix had no conversions; it was strengthened with the full
seed-1 case, and the final matrix requires nonzero cohort coverage. No live DB,
process-loss, migration, regional resource coupling or unattended soak claimed.
## 2026-10-17 - M12.2c current cellular reference
ADR-0138 scopes an isolated headless research executable over the current rules-8
@@ -0,0 +1,29 @@
{"kind":"metadata","model":"exact-cellular-cohorts-1","rules":8,"quantum_us":50000,"regional_approximation":false,"compression_claimed":false,"runtime_enabled":false}
{"kind":"paired","seed":0,"holdout":false,"rich":true,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":1,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":0,"buds":0,"mutations":4,"reference_ns":72869300,"population_ns":67712038,"conversion_ns":249665,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":0,"holdout":false,"rich":true,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":16,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":0,"buds":0,"mutations":4,"reference_ns":70965756,"population_ns":70058568,"conversion_ns":37867,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":0,"holdout":false,"rich":true,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":64,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":0,"buds":0,"mutations":4,"reference_ns":59653588,"population_ns":58224478,"conversion_ns":10112,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":0,"holdout":false,"rich":false,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":1,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":4,"buds":0,"mutations":0,"reference_ns":31851651,"population_ns":30474676,"conversion_ns":197263,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":0,"holdout":false,"rich":false,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":16,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":4,"buds":0,"mutations":0,"reference_ns":30804521,"population_ns":30142879,"conversion_ns":17924,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":0,"holdout":false,"rich":false,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":64,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":4,"buds":0,"mutations":0,"reference_ns":29899945,"population_ns":29510995,"conversion_ns":6913,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":1,"holdout":false,"rich":true,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":1,"collapsed":1048,"materialized":1048,"cohort_member_ticks":1048,"peak_members":1,"deaths":0,"buds":1,"mutations":4,"reference_ns":78692413,"population_ns":92228994,"conversion_ns":416627,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":1,"holdout":false,"rich":true,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":16,"collapsed":65,"materialized":65,"cohort_member_ticks":1040,"peak_members":1,"deaths":0,"buds":1,"mutations":4,"reference_ns":77510113,"population_ns":92380369,"conversion_ns":73074,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":1,"holdout":false,"rich":true,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":64,"collapsed":16,"materialized":16,"cohort_member_ticks":1024,"peak_members":1,"deaths":0,"buds":1,"mutations":4,"reference_ns":77010079,"population_ns":92608570,"conversion_ns":22708,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":1,"holdout":false,"rich":false,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":1,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":4,"buds":0,"mutations":0,"reference_ns":30871717,"population_ns":29629546,"conversion_ns":178037,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":1,"holdout":false,"rich":false,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":16,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":4,"buds":0,"mutations":0,"reference_ns":29482526,"population_ns":28755916,"conversion_ns":18267,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":1,"holdout":false,"rich":false,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":64,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":4,"buds":0,"mutations":0,"reference_ns":29243431,"population_ns":28548913,"conversion_ns":6733,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":2,"holdout":true,"rich":true,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":1,"collapsed":92,"materialized":92,"cohort_member_ticks":92,"peak_members":2,"deaths":1,"buds":2,"mutations":4,"reference_ns":65520558,"population_ns":64282957,"conversion_ns":232683,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":2,"holdout":true,"rich":true,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":16,"collapsed":4,"materialized":4,"cohort_member_ticks":64,"peak_members":2,"deaths":1,"buds":2,"mutations":4,"reference_ns":62061716,"population_ns":62918965,"conversion_ns":30676,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":2,"holdout":true,"rich":true,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":64,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":1,"buds":2,"mutations":4,"reference_ns":63541908,"population_ns":64404835,"conversion_ns":10887,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":2,"holdout":true,"rich":false,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":1,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":4,"buds":0,"mutations":0,"reference_ns":31716929,"population_ns":30172844,"conversion_ns":181926,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":2,"holdout":true,"rich":false,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":16,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":4,"buds":0,"mutations":0,"reference_ns":30328184,"population_ns":29810575,"conversion_ns":19862,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":2,"holdout":true,"rich":false,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":64,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":4,"buds":0,"mutations":0,"reference_ns":31373917,"population_ns":30973437,"conversion_ns":6963,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":3,"holdout":true,"rich":true,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":1,"collapsed":1048,"materialized":1048,"cohort_member_ticks":1048,"peak_members":1,"deaths":2,"buds":1,"mutations":4,"reference_ns":67664442,"population_ns":80044229,"conversion_ns":388135,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":3,"holdout":true,"rich":true,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":16,"collapsed":65,"materialized":65,"cohort_member_ticks":1040,"peak_members":1,"deaths":2,"buds":1,"mutations":4,"reference_ns":66749928,"population_ns":79618241,"conversion_ns":66623,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":3,"holdout":true,"rich":true,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":64,"collapsed":16,"materialized":16,"cohort_member_ticks":1024,"peak_members":1,"deaths":2,"buds":1,"mutations":4,"reference_ns":69393875,"population_ns":84295460,"conversion_ns":20125,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":3,"holdout":true,"rich":false,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":1,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":4,"buds":0,"mutations":0,"reference_ns":31509866,"population_ns":30254577,"conversion_ns":178899,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":3,"holdout":true,"rich":false,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":16,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":4,"buds":0,"mutations":0,"reference_ns":30723658,"population_ns":29980614,"conversion_ns":19559,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":3,"holdout":true,"rich":false,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":64,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":4,"buds":0,"mutations":0,"reference_ns":30027737,"population_ns":29407690,"conversion_ns":6849,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"capacity","lives":16,"samples":32,"p50_step_ns":27464,"p95_step_ns":58384,"max_step_ns":69180,"snapshot_bytes":21108}
{"kind":"capacity","lives":64,"samples":32,"p50_step_ns":156652,"p95_step_ns":200302,"max_step_ns":206407,"snapshot_bytes":71076}
{"kind":"capacity","lives":128,"samples":32,"p50_step_ns":463772,"p95_step_ns":777120,"max_step_ns":860498,"snapshot_bytes":137700}
{"kind":"capacity","lives":256,"samples":32,"p50_step_ns":1642881,"p95_step_ns":2326166,"max_step_ns":2346854,"snapshot_bytes":270948}
@@ -0,0 +1,29 @@
{"kind":"metadata","model":"exact-cellular-cohorts-1","rules":8,"quantum_us":50000,"regional_approximation":false,"compression_claimed":false,"runtime_enabled":false}
{"kind":"paired","seed":0,"holdout":false,"rich":true,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":1,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":0,"buds":0,"mutations":4,"reference_ns":79518200,"population_ns":78399100,"conversion_ns":294100,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":0,"holdout":false,"rich":true,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":16,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":0,"buds":0,"mutations":4,"reference_ns":78496800,"population_ns":77822200,"conversion_ns":23600,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":0,"holdout":false,"rich":true,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":64,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":0,"buds":0,"mutations":4,"reference_ns":80076700,"population_ns":79481900,"conversion_ns":8100,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":0,"holdout":false,"rich":false,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":1,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":4,"buds":0,"mutations":0,"reference_ns":36539800,"population_ns":35949100,"conversion_ns":268800,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":0,"holdout":false,"rich":false,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":16,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":4,"buds":0,"mutations":0,"reference_ns":35103900,"population_ns":34638700,"conversion_ns":16400,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":0,"holdout":false,"rich":false,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":64,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":4,"buds":0,"mutations":0,"reference_ns":34786100,"population_ns":34289600,"conversion_ns":5500,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":1,"holdout":false,"rich":true,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":1,"collapsed":1048,"materialized":1048,"cohort_member_ticks":1048,"peak_members":1,"deaths":0,"buds":1,"mutations":4,"reference_ns":114624300,"population_ns":142200400,"conversion_ns":526600,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":1,"holdout":false,"rich":true,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":16,"collapsed":65,"materialized":65,"cohort_member_ticks":1040,"peak_members":1,"deaths":0,"buds":1,"mutations":4,"reference_ns":111942600,"population_ns":140512100,"conversion_ns":63700,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":1,"holdout":false,"rich":true,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":64,"collapsed":16,"materialized":16,"cohort_member_ticks":1024,"peak_members":1,"deaths":0,"buds":1,"mutations":4,"reference_ns":110333100,"population_ns":139143200,"conversion_ns":20900,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":1,"holdout":false,"rich":false,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":1,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":4,"buds":0,"mutations":0,"reference_ns":36818400,"population_ns":35576600,"conversion_ns":290700,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":1,"holdout":false,"rich":false,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":16,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":4,"buds":0,"mutations":0,"reference_ns":37690000,"population_ns":37046500,"conversion_ns":21900,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":1,"holdout":false,"rich":false,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":64,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":4,"buds":0,"mutations":0,"reference_ns":35733400,"population_ns":35013500,"conversion_ns":6000,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":2,"holdout":true,"rich":true,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":1,"collapsed":92,"materialized":92,"cohort_member_ticks":92,"peak_members":2,"deaths":1,"buds":2,"mutations":4,"reference_ns":89974500,"population_ns":91528800,"conversion_ns":331400,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":2,"holdout":true,"rich":true,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":16,"collapsed":4,"materialized":4,"cohort_member_ticks":64,"peak_members":2,"deaths":1,"buds":2,"mutations":4,"reference_ns":90020800,"population_ns":92138900,"conversion_ns":32800,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":2,"holdout":true,"rich":true,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":64,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":1,"buds":2,"mutations":4,"reference_ns":91760300,"population_ns":93397100,"conversion_ns":10500,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":2,"holdout":true,"rich":false,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":1,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":4,"buds":0,"mutations":0,"reference_ns":36148400,"population_ns":35062700,"conversion_ns":284800,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":2,"holdout":true,"rich":false,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":16,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":4,"buds":0,"mutations":0,"reference_ns":36434900,"population_ns":35393500,"conversion_ns":25000,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":2,"holdout":true,"rich":false,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":64,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":4,"buds":0,"mutations":0,"reference_ns":36644500,"population_ns":36073900,"conversion_ns":7100,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":3,"holdout":true,"rich":true,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":1,"collapsed":1048,"materialized":1048,"cohort_member_ticks":1048,"peak_members":1,"deaths":2,"buds":1,"mutations":4,"reference_ns":96796400,"population_ns":124074500,"conversion_ns":466300,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":3,"holdout":true,"rich":true,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":16,"collapsed":65,"materialized":65,"cohort_member_ticks":1040,"peak_members":1,"deaths":2,"buds":1,"mutations":4,"reference_ns":95656900,"population_ns":123448500,"conversion_ns":44100,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":3,"holdout":true,"rich":true,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":64,"collapsed":16,"materialized":16,"cohort_member_ticks":1024,"peak_members":1,"deaths":2,"buds":1,"mutations":4,"reference_ns":96276900,"population_ns":123619300,"conversion_ns":15100,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":3,"holdout":true,"rich":false,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":1,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":4,"buds":0,"mutations":0,"reference_ns":35880600,"population_ns":35016700,"conversion_ns":279700,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":3,"holdout":true,"rich":false,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":16,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":4,"buds":0,"mutations":0,"reference_ns":35098200,"population_ns":34524500,"conversion_ns":18600,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"paired","seed":3,"holdout":true,"rich":false,"ticks":8192,"conversion_width":64,"collapsed":0,"materialized":0,"cohort_member_ticks":0,"peak_members":0,"deaths":4,"buds":0,"mutations":0,"reference_ns":36080000,"population_ns":35380700,"conversion_ns":6200,"max_state_error":0}
{"kind":"capacity","lives":16,"samples":32,"p50_step_ns":38600,"p95_step_ns":45000,"max_step_ns":50800,"snapshot_bytes":21108}
{"kind":"capacity","lives":64,"samples":32,"p50_step_ns":255500,"p95_step_ns":274400,"max_step_ns":297800,"snapshot_bytes":71076}
{"kind":"capacity","lives":128,"samples":32,"p50_step_ns":694500,"p95_step_ns":773300,"max_step_ns":799500,"snapshot_bytes":137700}
{"kind":"capacity","lives":256,"samples":32,"p50_step_ns":2246300,"p95_step_ns":2358700,"max_step_ns":2375100,"snapshot_bytes":270948}