From 87c1edcd2c5cab0ba62eca1f837e1d7ded1d43a4 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: dingo Date: Fri, 16 Oct 2026 07:27:48 -0400 Subject: [PATCH] M11.9: record solo feedback and living-cell reconnect blocker --- docs/ROADMAP.md | 5 ++ docs/STATUS.md | 9 +++ docs/engineering/M11_9_DELIVERY_PLAN.md | 9 +++ docs/engineering/M12_DELIVERY_PLAN.md | 8 +- docs/engineering/VALIDATION.md | 18 +++++ .../2026-10-16_M11_9_SOLO_FEEDBACK.md | 77 +++++++++++++++++++ .../playtests/M11_9_REPEATED_LIFE_PLAYTEST.md | 4 + 7 files changed, 127 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) create mode 100644 docs/playtests/2026-10-16_M11_9_SOLO_FEEDBACK.md diff --git a/docs/ROADMAP.md b/docs/ROADMAP.md index cf8a293..beced73 100644 --- a/docs/ROADMAP.md +++ b/docs/ROADMAP.md @@ -640,6 +640,11 @@ players do not progress. A recorded product review accepts the cellular loop or keeps iteration open; no invented retention percentage substitutes for that review. M12 supplies sustained world ecology rather than short-session evidence alone. +2026-10-16: [M11.9 solo feedback](playtests/2026-10-16_M11_9_SOLO_FEEDBACK.md) +records the eight answers and a living-cell reconnect blocker. Full sample, +retests and product acceptance remain open; proposed food/pacing/UI changes and +the later multicellular idea are not ratified game rules. + ## M12 - Persistent ecology 2026-10-16: 12.2b's [exact-reserve/age experiment](engineering/M12_RESERVE_STRATA_EXPERIMENT.md) diff --git a/docs/STATUS.md b/docs/STATUS.md index 84c4e7d..f55b5f6 100644 --- a/docs/STATUS.md +++ b/docs/STATUS.md @@ -1,5 +1,14 @@ # Project status and next steps +## M11.9 solo feedback - 2026-10-16 + +[The maintainer's eight answers](playtests/2026-10-16_M11_9_SOLO_FEEDBACK.md) +are recorded. Returning to a living cell is blocked by an existing-life message +with no cell visible; diagnose that resume/routing/view path first. The solo loop +felt repetitive, mutation effects and predation need more testing, and fun remains +uncertain. Food distribution, pacing and presentation suggestions remain proposals. +M11.9 product acceptance is open; this is feedback, not completion of the sample. + ## M12.2b experiment - 2026-10-16 A separate exact-reserve/age candidate matches 83 synthetic histories, including diff --git a/docs/engineering/M11_9_DELIVERY_PLAN.md b/docs/engineering/M11_9_DELIVERY_PLAN.md index 1da88a2..3f80030 100644 --- a/docs/engineering/M11_9_DELIVERY_PLAN.md +++ b/docs/engineering/M11_9_DELIVERY_PLAN.md @@ -17,6 +17,15 @@ running the complete M11 rules. ## Progress +- 2026-10-16: [solo feedback recorded](../playtests/2026-10-16_M11_9_SOLO_FEEDBACK.md) + against all eight questions. The maintainer reports repetitive food-camping, + unproven mutation effects and incomplete predation/fun evidence; offline behavior + and death-cause clarity have limited positive feedback. Returning to a living + cell shows "Existing cell is already bound to this account" with no cell visible + (M11-PT-001). Diagnose resume/routing/perception before further sessions. Proposed + food scattering, feeding-rate experiments, feedback/death UI and budding motivation + remain retest/design work. The sample and product acceptance are incomplete. + - 2026-10-14: 11.9a implemented. `summarize_cellular_play` and `evo-world-clone summary`; owner tests check death and bud aggregates, and the PostgreSQL store test runs the command on a provisioned `cellular-v4` region. diff --git a/docs/engineering/M12_DELIVERY_PLAN.md b/docs/engineering/M12_DELIVERY_PLAN.md index 6e2064d..c01891b 100644 --- a/docs/engineering/M12_DELIVERY_PLAN.md +++ b/docs/engineering/M12_DELIVERY_PLAN.md @@ -15,9 +15,11 @@ Commit and push each validated scoped segment separately. | 12.5 | Blocked on 12.2-12.4 | Finite M6 process fixtures do not qualify coupled persistent cellular/cohort atmosphere/water budgets. | M12's roadmap entry also requires the M11 playable-loop product review. The -[M11.9 plan](M11_9_DELIVERY_PLAN.md) records engineering delivery and a first -sign-in playtest, but no completed repeated-life results or product acceptance. -Beginning policy work does not fabricate that acceptance. +[M11.9 plan](M11_9_DELIVERY_PLAN.md) now links the maintainer's +[solo feedback](../playtests/2026-10-16_M11_9_SOLO_FEEDBACK.md), including the +living-cell reconnect blocker and repetitive-loop concerns. Full sample/retests +and product acceptance remain incomplete. Beginning policy work or synthetic +population experiments does not fabricate that acceptance. Executed 12.2a results and remaining limits: [M12_POPULATION_QUALIFICATION](M12_POPULATION_QUALIFICATION.md). Release CTest diff --git a/docs/engineering/VALIDATION.md b/docs/engineering/VALIDATION.md index 5bf4fd4..59f06b0 100644 --- a/docs/engineering/VALIDATION.md +++ b/docs/engineering/VALIDATION.md @@ -1,5 +1,23 @@ # Validation report +## 2026-10-16 - M11.9 maintainer feedback and reconnect triage + +Recorded the maintainer's eight playtest answers and clarification that the +existing-life message occurred when returning to a living cell with nothing +visible. Preserved the predeclared plan, documented missing session/build/telemetry +metadata, linked six local issues and kept proposed balance/progression changes +unaccepted. M11 product acceptance remains open. + +Read-only source trace covered client birth-result gating, server one-active-life +semantics, session-driven resume ticks, suspended-state perception exclusion and +bounded resume placement. These identify diagnostic candidates, not a reproduced +cause or fix for the affected DEV session. No code/runtime, simulation version, +binding, region or deployment changed. No live incident, UI or balance validation +is claimed. `kubectl config current-context` reports no current context, preventing +live DEV log/state confirmation. Documentation checks: `git diff --check` and +relative Markdown links (9 resolved). +No build, clang-format/tidy or sanitizer rerun for this documentation-only segment. + ## 2026-10-16 - M12.2b exact reserve-strata experiment ADR-0134 scopes a new research executable, not a public library/runtime change. diff --git a/docs/playtests/2026-10-16_M11_9_SOLO_FEEDBACK.md b/docs/playtests/2026-10-16_M11_9_SOLO_FEEDBACK.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..0868e05 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/playtests/2026-10-16_M11_9_SOLO_FEEDBACK.md @@ -0,0 +1,77 @@ +# M11.9 solo feedback recorded 2026-10-16 + +Source: the maintainer's answers to the eight questions in +[the predeclared playtest plan](M11_9_REPEATED_LIFE_PLAYTEST.md), supplied in chat. +This is a report date, not a verified session date. One solo participant is +reported; session duration, exact life count, region/server digest, client build, +assistance settings and start/end telemetry were not supplied. No additional +participants, full protocol completion or product acceptance are inferred. + +## Findings against the original questions + +| Question | Reported observation | Assessment and proposed follow-up | +|---|---|---| +| 1. Movement and food | The maintainer suggests smaller food pools with many more scattered spots, including clumps, like rice thrown onto the ground. Further testing was blocked by "Existing cell is already bound to this account" on login. | Time to food and first offer were not measured. First repair/diagnose returning-player access; then compare scattered small patches and clumps while explicitly controlling total finite resource stock. Distribution is a proposal, not accepted balance. | +| 2. Mutation tradeoffs | Choices/costs are visible. No meaningful play change has been established; too few mutations were obtained to assess a viable change. | Readability has positive solo feedback; affordability, accumulation and meaningful effects need further observation. Do not claim mutation variety is validated. | +| 3. Predation | Testing was unsuccessful/incomplete. More testing and actual UI/animation changes are needed, including toast-like feedback describing what happened and why. | Predation usability is unvalidated. Exercise successful and refused engulfment, owner-visible reasons, timing and presentation with more players. | +| 4. Descendants | The maintainer budded intentionally but questions its purpose. A possible future idea is creating similar cells and gathering them for multicellularity. | Intentional budding is observed; competition, ecological significance and player motivation remain unproven. Record multicellular gathering as an exploratory design idea for the later gate, not a new M11 rule or mandatory progression path. | +| 5. Death and restart | Cause of death seems clear. The message should appear in the middle with an option to start as a new cell. | Preserve terminal death and primitive restart. Improve prominence of the death/restart presentation; never describe the old organism as reviving. Repeat the flow with the same account. | +| 6. Offline | Offline behavior seems fine so far. | Positive limited feedback; it does not close the offline gate. The subsequently clarified return-to-living-cell failure below needs separate investigation. | +| 7. Variety | No variety was experienced in the solo test. Each new life rushed to the nearest food, then stayed feeding until it was drained. Offered mutations did not meaningfully change play; long waits dominate. A higher feeding rate might help, but the maintainer is unsure. | Strong solo evidence of a repetitive loop, not a measured cross-player result. Test food placement, feeding dwell time, mutation cadence and actual behavioral effects separately. Feeding-rate changes are a hypothesis, not an approved tune. | +| 8. Fun | The maintainer is unsure whether the loop is fun; more people and further confirmation are needed. | Product acceptance remains open. Do not substitute passing engineering tests or synthetic ecology for the missing product review. | + +## Blocking incident: M11-PT-001 + +Reported message: **"Existing cell is already bound to this account"**. + +The maintainer clarified that this occurred when **logging back into a living +cell**, and **nothing appeared**. This is a resume/reconnect incident, not a request +to replace a living organism or evidence that the organism died. Exact region, +build, logout interval, server tick/commit, session route and persisted presence +were not supplied. Root cause and a live fix are not yet established. + +Read-only source triage found: + +- `RemoteSession::cellular_results` displays this string for the server's + `PrimitiveLifeResult::existing_life` result. Each freshly opened client issues + a primitive-life request; that result alone cannot establish a resume failure. +- The outcome intentionally carries no existing life identity on the wire. The + owner-filtered perception supplies the actual controlled life when available. +- The client disables a new-life attempt for `existing_life` while waiting for + that perception. Allowing a second life or changing the account is not a repair + for an invisible living organism. +- ADR-0128 excludes suspended cells from replication/perception. The accepted + resume rule tries the retained position and bounded nearby positions, and can + remain suspended when all are blocked. The server's owner tick reports + `resume_blocked`, but the bridge skips suspended lives before building their + owner perception. This is a diagnostic candidate, not confirmation that the + maintainer's cell was blocked by placement. +- The server should tick when an established session holds a living account and + submit an unfrozen baseline to request resume. Verify that ownership routing, + account control, publication and subsequent perception actually complete on + the affected DEV instance; local owner resume tests alone do not prove this. + +Investigation order: reproduce return to an isolated suspended cell; repeat after +wildlife occupies its old position; distinguish bounded placement refusal from +wrong/unavailable region routing, non-advancing commits and missing owner views. +Retain life/genome/inventory identities through recovery. Do not delete bindings, +create a new account, reset a region or expand the resume radius as a workaround. +No deployment, database mutation or runtime fix was performed for this note. +`kubectl config current-context` reports that no current context is set in this +workspace, so live DEV logs/state were unavailable for confirming these candidates. + +## Retest backlog + +| Local issue | Priority / scope | Acceptance evidence | +|---|---|---| +| M11-PT-001 | Blocking: living-cell reconnect/resume | Same account returns to the same funded life after logout/recovery; control and visible owner state arrive, or a specific bounded-resume failure is explained. No duplicate life or resource changes. | +| M11-PT-002 | Food distribution experiment | Compare scattered small spots/clumps with the current layout under matched total stock; record travel, competition, dwell time and time to first offer. No implicit refill. | +| M11-PT-003 | Feeding/mutation pacing and effects | Observe enough affordable choices to compare movement/intake/defense behavior; measure waits and test one declared versioned tuning hypothesis at a time. | +| M11-PT-004 | Predation feedback and animation | Multiple-player successful/refused attempts have timely, understandable reasons; owner feedback does not expose hidden opponent state. Retest presentation with participants. | +| M11-PT-005 | Central death/new-cell action | Prominent cause and primitive-new-life action; reconnect and repeated deaths never restore the dead organism. | +| M11-PT-006 | Budding purpose / later multicellular idea | Explore ecological reasons to bud during M11 testing. Review any gathering/multicellularity proposal at the later design gate without mandatory intelligence, collection ownership or a linear class ladder. | + +The suggestions do not select new resource budgets, feeding rates, mutation sizes, +resume radii, new life stages or a multicellular progression mechanic. First unblock +the test, then recruit the predeclared sample and repeat sessions before accepting +the loop or using it to calibrate M12 cellular population fidelity. diff --git a/docs/playtests/M11_9_REPEATED_LIFE_PLAYTEST.md b/docs/playtests/M11_9_REPEATED_LIFE_PLAYTEST.md index e2b7300..7a43bea 100644 --- a/docs/playtests/M11_9_REPEATED_LIFE_PLAYTEST.md +++ b/docs/playtests/M11_9_REPEATED_LIFE_PLAYTEST.md @@ -1,5 +1,9 @@ # M11.9 repeated-life playtest plan +Recorded feedback: [2026-10-16 solo report](2026-10-16_M11_9_SOLO_FEEDBACK.md). +It preserves the original questions below, records a living-cell reconnect blocker +and six local retest issues, and does not grant product acceptance. + This plan predeclares what the M11.9 playtests try to learn, who plays, how sessions run and what is recorded. It is written before any session so that results are not read into after the fact. It is not a balance sign-off; every value it touches is a