diff --git a/docs/ROADMAP.md b/docs/ROADMAP.md index beced73..e3e23aa 100644 --- a/docs/ROADMAP.md +++ b/docs/ROADMAP.md @@ -647,6 +647,12 @@ the later multicellular idea are not ratified game rules. ## M12 - Persistent ecology +2026-10-17: the maintainer closes M11.9 for now and authorizes M12 continuation. +[Closure/UI review](engineering/M11_9_CLOSURE_AND_UI_REVIEW.md) preserves the +incomplete empirical sample and confirms the current microscope presentation. +Use implemented rules 8 as the cellular reference; population-model and +target-host qualification remain separate M12.2 requirements. + 2026-10-16: 12.2b's [exact-reserve/age experiment](engineering/M12_RESERVE_STRATA_EXPERIMENT.md) matches all 83 synthetic trajectories without replacing the rejected M4 baseline. It does not qualify an M11 cellular population model or automatic tier policy. diff --git a/docs/STATUS.md b/docs/STATUS.md index f55b5f6..fb710f2 100644 --- a/docs/STATUS.md +++ b/docs/STATUS.md @@ -1,5 +1,16 @@ # Project status and next steps +## M11.9 closed for now; M12 continuation - 2026-10-17 + +The maintainer explicitly closes M11.9 for now and authorizes proceeding with M12. +The solo observations and incomplete product sample remain follow-ups, not a +continuing gate block. Reviewed the current microscope HUD at three sizes, +mutation cards and central death/restart presentation through production-panel +renders; see [closure and UI review](engineering/M11_9_CLOSURE_AND_UI_REVIEW.md). +The current reference is rules 8 with finite pools/bubbles and contact feeding. +M12.2 still requires cellular/cohort fidelity and target-host fallback evidence; +no automatic tier selection follows from the M11.9 closure. + ## M11.9 solo feedback - 2026-10-16 [The maintainer's eight answers](playtests/2026-10-16_M11_9_SOLO_FEEDBACK.md) diff --git a/docs/engineering/M11_9_CLOSURE_AND_UI_REVIEW.md b/docs/engineering/M11_9_CLOSURE_AND_UI_REVIEW.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d397f9a --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/engineering/M11_9_CLOSURE_AND_UI_REVIEW.md @@ -0,0 +1,61 @@ +# M11.9 scoped closure and current UI review - 2026-10-17 + +## Maintainer decision + +The maintainer states: "We are going to close 11.9 for now. Please proceed." +Record M11.9 as closed for current M12 engineering continuation. The earlier solo +observations remain evidence and follow-up work; the three-participant sample, +fun/variety conclusions and all retests were not completed by this decision. +Do not continue treating a missing M11.9 acceptance as an engineering blocker. + +## Current baseline inspected + +Reviewed source at `fcc6c57` plus this scoped documentation/research work. The +implemented client is the microscope overhaul, not the earlier teal side panels. +Current cellular implementation is rules 8, owner format 6, habitat format 2, +genome schema/development 4, with percentage steps, skilled/twin budding, hunting +wildlife, finite pools/motes and contact feeding (ADR-0137 and ADR-0136 step A). +Behaviour weighting/colonies, nutrient infall and photosynthesis remain proposed. + +The previous invisible-living-cell report is retained historically. Subsequent +commits add bounded wildlife steering, tick-stall diagnostics and DEV promotion; +this review does not independently claim a new live incident validation. + +## Visual review + +Built the actual production panel test with Clang 19 using the `client` preset in +`build/m12-ui-clang` with clang-tidy enabled. Ran `evo-client-panel-tests` under +Xvfb and generated current screenshots in `build/m12-ui-review`. + +Inspected all three HUD renders (640/960/1280), the evolution window and the death +window. The fixtures intentionally combine legacy patch rendering and new deposit +rendering; their "Region 4" label is test data, not a claim about the deployed region. + +- Rounded microscope eyepiece, dark ink/lavender palette, separate status pill, + Field notes, Vitals and the action dock are present. +- Wide layouts retain Field notes; narrow layouts prioritise Vitals and actions. + Resource details use the existing vertically scrolling Vitals window. Panel + tests check viewport bounds and no sideways scrolling at all three sizes. +- Mutation cards show before/after phenotype drawings, named tradeoffs, per-channel + costs, available choices and an explicit shortage on the unaffordable choice. + The window warns that the cell keeps moving while it is open. +- Death is central and names the cause. "Begin a new life" is prominent, with + descendant/history continuity explained. This is a new primitive life, not + resurrection of the old identity. +- Feedback includes specific engulf refusal wording. Nutrient colours, pools, + motes and cellular morphology share the production drawing path. + +No UI redesign or interaction change is made here. Static fixture review does not +validate live feel, hover timing, glow animation, hardware/DPI behavior or product +fun. The native running-window capture timed out waiting for app approval; no +authentication or live gameplay was automated. A first GCC-14 client build hit an +existing `AuthGrant` maybe-uninitialized warning under warnings-as-errors; it was +left unchanged, and the separate Clang-19 build/panel test completed successfully. + +## Validation and consequences + +Executed production panel test: passed, with clang-tidy during its Clang build. +Inspected the five generated images above. Relative Markdown links and +`git diff --check` checked for the closure documents. No runtime, simulation, +protocol, persistent format, deployment or World0 change. Resume M12.2 using the +current cellular contracts, keeping aggregation and target-host evidence gates. diff --git a/docs/engineering/M11_9_DELIVERY_PLAN.md b/docs/engineering/M11_9_DELIVERY_PLAN.md index 3f80030..d73b532 100644 --- a/docs/engineering/M11_9_DELIVERY_PLAN.md +++ b/docs/engineering/M11_9_DELIVERY_PLAN.md @@ -1,5 +1,16 @@ # M11.9: Run repeated-life playtests and close the loop +## Maintainer closure - 2026-10-17 + +The maintainer explicitly closes M11.9 **for now** and authorizes proceeding with +M12. This is the gate decision for continued engineering. The incomplete sample, +solo feedback and fun/variety questions remain recorded; this closure does not +invent completed sessions or empirical product validation. Retain the local +playtest backlog for later iteration rather than using it to block M12 work. +Review the current microscope UI and rules-8 contracts before further integration. +The [closure and UI review](M11_9_CLOSURE_AND_UI_REVIEW.md) records the actual +production-panel screenshots inspected and the scope of this decision. + The playtests themselves are human work for the maintainer and participants. This plan tracks what engineering provides for them: the predeclared plan ([M11_9_REPEATED_LIFE_PLAYTEST](../playtests/M11_9_REPEATED_LIFE_PLAYTEST.md)), diff --git a/docs/engineering/M12_DELIVERY_PLAN.md b/docs/engineering/M12_DELIVERY_PLAN.md index c01891b..ae52ee2 100644 --- a/docs/engineering/M12_DELIVERY_PLAN.md +++ b/docs/engineering/M12_DELIVERY_PLAN.md @@ -4,7 +4,7 @@ Requested scope: ecological identity, population qualification, durable automati tier transitions, unattended scheduling/migration and environmental coupling. Commit and push each validated scoped segment separately. -## Gate status (2026-10-16) +## Gate status (2026-10-17) | Subset | State | Evidence or condition for completion | |---|---|---| @@ -14,12 +14,13 @@ Commit and push each validated scoped segment separately. | 12.4 | Blocked on 12.2-12.3 | Existing cellular worker pauses without sessions/lingering players; bounded unattended recovery and biological migration escrow remain unimplemented. | | 12.5 | Blocked on 12.2-12.4 | Finite M6 process fixtures do not qualify coupled persistent cellular/cohort atmosphere/water budgets. | -M12's roadmap entry also requires the M11 playable-loop product review. The -[M11.9 plan](M11_9_DELIVERY_PLAN.md) now links the maintainer's -[solo feedback](../playtests/2026-10-16_M11_9_SOLO_FEEDBACK.md), including the -living-cell reconnect blocker and repetitive-loop concerns. Full sample/retests -and product acceptance remain incomplete. Beginning policy work or synthetic -population experiments does not fabricate that acceptance. +The maintainer explicitly closes M11.9 for now on 2026-10-17 and authorizes M12 +continuation; see the [closure decision](M11_9_DELIVERY_PLAN.md). The recorded +solo sample and fun/variety questions remain incomplete empirical evidence and a +follow-up backlog. They no longer block M12 engineering under that decision. +Current work must use the overhauled microscope UI and implemented rules 8 +(ADR-0136 step A, ADR-0137), not the older square-patch/rules-6 baseline. Proposed +colony, infall and photosynthesis mechanics remain outside this implementation. Executed 12.2a results and remaining limits: [M12_POPULATION_QUALIFICATION](M12_POPULATION_QUALIFICATION.md). Release CTest @@ -50,7 +51,7 @@ cannot by itself establish useful aggregation or acceptable target-host cost. Measure bin/interval sensitivity, conversion and full-region costs on the Linux target host, including active fallback capacity and backpressure. Passing the M4 -synthetic envelope alone is insufficient. Record M11's product review separately. +synthetic envelope alone is insufficient. Preserve the scoped M11 closure above. Only then accept the model/tier ADR and proceed to 12.3, followed by owned durable intervals/escrow in 12.4 and versioned finite resource coupling in 12.5. No World0 deployment or promotion follows from these gates. diff --git a/docs/engineering/VALIDATION.md b/docs/engineering/VALIDATION.md index a2c3359..d800ddb 100644 --- a/docs/engineering/VALIDATION.md +++ b/docs/engineering/VALIDATION.md @@ -1,5 +1,22 @@ # Validation report +## 2026-10-17 - M11.9 scoped closure and UI review + +Recorded the maintainer's explicit closure for now and authorization for M12. +The earlier solo feedback/sample limitations remain historical follow-ups. +Rendered and inspected production-panel HUD screenshots at 640/960/1280 plus +evolution and central death/restart windows in `build/m12-ui-review`. + +Executed `client` preset with Clang 19 and clang-tidy in `build/m12-ui-clang`, +built `evo-client-panel-tests`, then ran it under Xvfb with the output directory; +passed. The initial GCC-14 client build failed on the pre-existing AuthGrant +maybe-uninitialized warning; no suppression or unrelated source change was made. +Native running-window capture timed out waiting for app approval. Fixture renders +do not establish live DEV behavior, animations, hardware/DPI or product acceptance. +See [review](M11_9_CLOSURE_AND_UI_REVIEW.md) for exact scope. No UI/runtime, +deployment or world-state changes. Documentation links and `git diff --check` +checked. M12.2's cellular/model and target-host evidence remain required. + ## 2026-10-16 - M11.9 maintainer feedback and reconnect triage Recorded the maintainer's eight playtest answers and clarification that the diff --git a/docs/playtests/2026-10-16_M11_9_SOLO_FEEDBACK.md b/docs/playtests/2026-10-16_M11_9_SOLO_FEEDBACK.md index 38b325f..8e07f06 100644 --- a/docs/playtests/2026-10-16_M11_9_SOLO_FEEDBACK.md +++ b/docs/playtests/2026-10-16_M11_9_SOLO_FEEDBACK.md @@ -1,5 +1,10 @@ # M11.9 solo feedback recorded 2026-10-16 +Later decision (2026-10-17): the maintainer closes M11.9 for now and authorizes +M12 continuation. This report preserves what was observed at the time; its open +questions are follow-ups rather than a continuing M11.9 prerequisite block. +Later commits also replace the older UI and food rules described by this report. + Source: the maintainer's answers to the eight questions in [the predeclared playtest plan](M11_9_REPEATED_LIFE_PLAYTEST.md), supplied in chat. This is a report date, not a verified session date. One solo participant is diff --git a/docs/playtests/M11_9_REPEATED_LIFE_PLAYTEST.md b/docs/playtests/M11_9_REPEATED_LIFE_PLAYTEST.md index 7a43bea..2269ca8 100644 --- a/docs/playtests/M11_9_REPEATED_LIFE_PLAYTEST.md +++ b/docs/playtests/M11_9_REPEATED_LIFE_PLAYTEST.md @@ -1,5 +1,10 @@ # M11.9 repeated-life playtest plan +2026-10-17: the maintainer closes this gate for now and authorizes proceeding to +M12. The original sample plan and observations remain historical evidence; +uncompleted tests and reported issues stay on the follow-up backlog. See the +[closure decision](../engineering/M11_9_DELIVERY_PLAN.md). + Recorded feedback: [2026-10-16 solo report](2026-10-16_M11_9_SOLO_FEEDBACK.md). It preserves the original questions below, records a living-cell reconnect blocker and six local retest issues, and does not grant product acceptance.