From 8c653b90643e58549008d8e3a0fc74ca811da63b Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: dingo Date: Sat, 19 Sep 2026 14:24:16 -0400 Subject: [PATCH] Record cross-platform ECS measurements and the scoped storage decision --- docs/STATUS.md | 12 ++--- docs/adr/0005-ecs-strategy.md | 8 ++-- docs/architecture/OPEN_QUESTIONS.md | 2 +- docs/engineering/ECS_EVALUATION.md | 39 ++++++++++++++++ docs/engineering/VALIDATION.md | 12 +++++ docs/engineering/results/ecs-gcc142.jsonl | 57 +++++++++++++++++++++++ 6 files changed, 120 insertions(+), 10 deletions(-) create mode 100644 docs/engineering/results/ecs-gcc142.jsonl diff --git a/docs/STATUS.md b/docs/STATUS.md index f3dff69..327e42f 100644 --- a/docs/STATUS.md +++ b/docs/STATUS.md @@ -52,17 +52,17 @@ material and are not automatically included in commits. M1.5 progress: the opt-in row/EnTT4 experiment now checks canonical equality, restore continuation, retired identities and allocator balance, and records seven-sample sparse/dense/churn results. Windows Release, analysis and ASan checks -have run; Linux validation is tracked in VALIDATION.md. ADR-0005 retains rows +passed, as did Linux Release, analysis and ASan/UBSan in Gitea run 1404. All 56 +sample fingerprints match across platforms. ADR-0005 retains rows for the bounded proof; the general production ECS remains a later measured choice. | Priority | Work | Completion evidence | |---|---|---| | 1 | Verify the existing dev Argo mapping and sync the pinned, validated image | Dev Job Complete with replay_verified=true; no World0 changes | -| 2 | Close the isolated M1.5 experiment with Linux CI evidence; retain richer production ECS evaluation gates | Matching canonical results and sanitizer/static checks across supported compiler families; no automatic production adoption | -| 3 | M1.6 scheduler/input contract: ratify phase order and command admission before implementing a sequential scheduler | Stable input order, one writer, deterministic merges and replay equivalence | -| 4 | M1.7 local spatial contract | Neighborhood queries checked against brute force, wrap/boundary/unit tests and measured workload | -| 5 | M2.1 energy/matter ledger | Agreed units/ranges, atomic transfers, nonnegative balances and conservation tests before organisms | -| 6 | M2.2–2.6 first headless energy cycle | Explicit source → producer → consumer → death → decomposition → nutrients; seeded million-tick ledger evidence | +| 2 | M1.6 scheduler/input contract: ratify phase order and command admission before implementing a sequential scheduler | Stable input order, one writer, deterministic merges and replay equivalence | +| 3 | M1.7 local spatial contract | Neighborhood queries checked against brute force, wrap/boundary/unit tests and measured workload | +| 4 | M2.1 energy/matter ledger | Agreed units/ranges, atomic transfers, nonnegative balances and conservation tests before organisms | +| 5 | M2.2–2.6 first headless energy cycle | Explicit source → producer → consumer → death → decomposition → nutrients; seeded million-tick ledger evidence | Before biology, resolve the relevant heredity and energetic contracts rather than treating proof particles as organisms. Exact game tick rate, NPC mutation, diff --git a/docs/adr/0005-ecs-strategy.md b/docs/adr/0005-ecs-strategy.md index 6f1e433..4bc455f 100644 --- a/docs/adr/0005-ecs-strategy.md +++ b/docs/adr/0005-ecs-strategy.md @@ -38,12 +38,14 @@ ADR-0021 adds an isolated EnTT4 comparison, with full byte-equivalence, closed-form arithmetic, retired-ID and restore tests. See the [protocol and results](../engineering/ECS_EVALUATION.md). -Preliminary Windows evidence supports **retaining sorted rows for the bounded +Windows and Linux evidence supports **retaining sorted rows for the bounded proof and upcoming scheduler contract**, not adopting a general ECS yet. At 10000 entities, EnTT substantially reduces individual removal/replacement cost; the row adapter uses less live container memory and has cheaper updates/export -in these small fixed-component workloads. These are tradeoffs, not a universal -ranking. Linux results and sanitizer evidence are recorded with the experiment. +in the Windows workloads. Linux sparse updates favor EnTT (~2.4x), while dense +updates/export still favor rows. These are tradeoffs, not a universal ranking. +Both compiler families' results and sanitizer evidence are recorded with the +experiment; native container growth differs between standard libraries. The production decision remains deferred until variable component sizes, capability add/remove, high churn over long lifetimes, interacting systems and diff --git a/docs/architecture/OPEN_QUESTIONS.md b/docs/architecture/OPEN_QUESTIONS.md index 34c3e6a..4bec02b 100644 --- a/docs/architecture/OPEN_QUESTIONS.md +++ b/docs/architecture/OPEN_QUESTIONS.md @@ -8,7 +8,7 @@ person. ADR indexes distinguish scoped proof choices from production proposals. |---|---|---|---| | 1 | Tick frequency | 20Hz proof only; measure latency, CPU, stiff biology | Simulation/network; before M7/M10 | | 2 | Fixed/variable boundaries | Fixed authoritative ticks, host wall-clock pacing; ecology integer multiples | Simulation; M1 | -| 3 | ECS | Bounded component store proof; compare EnTT/Flecs realistic iteration | Engine; M1 | +| 3 | ECS | Row/EnTT4 experiment in ADR-0021; retain bounded rows for proof, production choice awaits richer workloads (Flecs remains an alternative) | Engine; M1 and biological component gate | | 4 | Dependency manager | Evaluate vcpkg manifest vs Conan; no runtime dependency for proof | Build; first dependency | | 5 | Units library | Minimal explicit integer wrappers now; evaluate dimensional library before biology | Simulation; M2 | | 6 | Determinism | Exact integer proof; physics separately scoped | Simulation; each system ADR | diff --git a/docs/engineering/ECS_EVALUATION.md b/docs/engineering/ECS_EVALUATION.md index d6e503f..5b4d4ad 100644 --- a/docs/engineering/ECS_EVALUATION.md +++ b/docs/engineering/ECS_EVALUATION.md @@ -105,6 +105,10 @@ churn removes/replaces 1000 individuals. Memory is live requested container byte | Rows / 100% | 0.2699 | 0.9237 | 1.3829 | 0.2873 | 0.2561 | 485520 | | EnTT4 / 100% | 0.5777 | 7.0615 | 0.1399 | 0.6269 | 0.6842 | 866632 | +Observed update min–max: rows 10% 0.7312–0.8778 ms; EnTT 10% +0.9824–1.0396 ms; rows 100% 0.9203–0.9358 ms; EnTT 100% +7.0491–7.1502 ms. These are seven-sample ranges, not confidence intervals. + All paired samples have identical canonical bytes. EnTT wins this individual churn case by roughly 10–15x; rows win the measured simple updates/export and use fewer live bytes. EnTT's peak bytes can be lower than the row vector's @@ -122,3 +126,38 @@ deterministic scheduler. Preserve a future adapter boundary. Revisit with real component sizes, dynamic capabilities, interacting systems, EnTT groups, batched structural changes and a bounded persistent-ID mapping before production adoption. Do not extrapolate these synthetic counts into organism/player capacity. + +## Linux observations, Gitea run 1404 + +[Run 1404](https://git.aeternalisgames.com/dingo/AEvolution/actions/runs/1404), +source bf7d60b7cd174736d38aea42616064e55e0c5f05: GCC14 Release experiment, +Clang19 ASan/UBSan and clang-tidy contract runs all passed. Baseline regression, +TSan and image smoke/publish jobs also passed. The experiment itself remains +single-threaded; baseline TSan does not certify future ECS concurrency. + +CMake 3.28.3, GCC 14.2.0, Clang 19.1.1; Linux x86-64 Docker runner. CPU model and +cgroup limits were not captured for these samples, so they are exploratory +within-runner comparisons, not a controlled hardware benchmark. All 56 sample +fingerprints match Windows. [Raw Linux JSONL](results/ecs-gcc142.jsonl). + +10000 entities, medians in milliseconds; updates cover 100 ticks: + +| Store / density | Create ms | Update ms | Churn ms | Export ms | Restore ms | Live bytes | +|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:| +| Rows / 10% | 0.5208 | 7.6433 | 10.8217 | 1.1124 | 1.0239 | 655360 | +| EnTT4 / 10% | 1.0889 | 3.2116 | 0.1932 | 1.6101 | 1.4745 | 710392 | +| Rows / 100% | 0.8512 | 7.9037 | 10.8592 | 1.1100 | 1.0152 | 655360 | +| EnTT4 / 100% | 1.4721 | 18.9315 | 0.2737 | 1.7558 | 1.9766 | 968672 | + +Update min-max: rows 10% 7.5747-7.7266 ms; EnTT 10% 3.1476-3.2407 ms; +rows 100% 7.3748-9.3729 ms; EnTT 100% 18.7963-19.0924 ms. Combined executable +size: 180256 bytes (unstripped); this is not a per-adapter size delta. Allocation +instrumentation contributes overhead to creation/churn/restore timings. + +Unlike Windows, EnTT sparse updates win on this Linux run (~2.4x), as well as +churn (~40-56x). Rows retain cheaper dense updates, export and lower live requested +bytes. Different vector growth policies also change live/peak allocation totals. +These results strengthen the case for keeping the production choice open: +selecting a library from one compiler's synthetic loop would be unjustified. +The scoped ADR-0005 recommendation still retains rows for the bounded proof and +scheduler contract, with production adoption gated on realistic workloads. diff --git a/docs/engineering/VALIDATION.md b/docs/engineering/VALIDATION.md index 9cb9fbc..a7587ed 100644 --- a/docs/engineering/VALIDATION.md +++ b/docs/engineering/VALIDATION.md @@ -118,3 +118,15 @@ Seven measured samples plus warmup are retained in results/ecs-msvc1944.jsonl; protocol, build observations and scope limits are in ECS_EVALUATION.md. The Linux experiment CI job is pending its first pushed run; no Linux experiment success is claimed yet. + +## M1.5 Linux evidence + +[Run 1404](https://git.aeternalisgames.com/dingo/AEvolution/actions/runs/1404), +source bf7d60b7cd174736d38aea42616064e55e0c5f05: every job passed. The new ci-ecs +stage explicitly prepared the pinned header/license, then built and ran the +experiment under GCC14 Release, Clang19 ASan/UBSan and Clang19 analysis. All three +contract invocations passed. Raw measured GCC samples are retained at +results/ecs-gcc142.jsonl; all 56 fingerprints match corresponding Windows samples. +No production rule or snapshot-format change occurred. This supersedes the +pending Linux experiment note above. The final follow-up edits only record +results and decision scope; production ECS adoption remains deferred. diff --git a/docs/engineering/results/ecs-gcc142.jsonl b/docs/engineering/results/ecs-gcc142.jsonl new file mode 100644 index 0000000..5012df2 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/engineering/results/ecs-gcc142.jsonl @@ -0,0 +1,57 @@ +{"experiment":"ecs-storage-v1","entt":"4.0.0","compiler":"GCC 14.2.0","build":"release"} +{"store":"rows","entities":1000,"density_percent":10,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":0,"create_s":7.8147e-05,"tick_s":0.00107446,"churn_s":0.000136713,"export_s":0.000172947,"restore_s":9.4914e-05,"live_bytes":40960,"peak_bytes":61440,"allocations":11,"hash":"ae6c58eaaffcbb17"} +{"store":"entt4","entities":1000,"density_percent":10,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":0,"create_s":0.00021763,"tick_s":0.000580101,"churn_s":3.9124e-05,"export_s":0.000285326,"restore_s":0.000415238,"live_bytes":137608,"peak_bytes":141704,"allocations":88,"hash":"ae6c58eaaffcbb17"} +{"store":"entt4","entities":1000,"density_percent":10,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":1,"create_s":0.000216541,"tick_s":0.000574234,"churn_s":3.801e-05,"export_s":0.00028311,"restore_s":0.000373834,"live_bytes":137608,"peak_bytes":141704,"allocations":88,"hash":"ae6c58eaaffcbb17"} +{"store":"rows","entities":1000,"density_percent":10,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":1,"create_s":8.0304e-05,"tick_s":0.00104788,"churn_s":0.000116337,"export_s":0.000186493,"restore_s":9.5696e-05,"live_bytes":40960,"peak_bytes":61440,"allocations":11,"hash":"ae6c58eaaffcbb17"} +{"store":"rows","entities":1000,"density_percent":10,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":2,"create_s":7.794e-05,"tick_s":0.000933278,"churn_s":0.000116,"export_s":0.00017332,"restore_s":0.000116362,"live_bytes":40960,"peak_bytes":61440,"allocations":11,"hash":"ae6c58eaaffcbb17"} +{"store":"entt4","entities":1000,"density_percent":10,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":2,"create_s":0.00023273,"tick_s":0.000557342,"churn_s":3.9243e-05,"export_s":0.00028378,"restore_s":0.000401041,"live_bytes":137608,"peak_bytes":141704,"allocations":88,"hash":"ae6c58eaaffcbb17"} +{"store":"entt4","entities":1000,"density_percent":10,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":3,"create_s":0.000215551,"tick_s":0.000510751,"churn_s":3.4633e-05,"export_s":0.000261244,"restore_s":0.000340121,"live_bytes":137608,"peak_bytes":141704,"allocations":88,"hash":"ae6c58eaaffcbb17"} +{"store":"rows","entities":1000,"density_percent":10,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":3,"create_s":6.8885e-05,"tick_s":0.000715488,"churn_s":0.000125592,"export_s":0.000148105,"restore_s":8.1347e-05,"live_bytes":40960,"peak_bytes":61440,"allocations":11,"hash":"ae6c58eaaffcbb17"} +{"store":"rows","entities":1000,"density_percent":10,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":4,"create_s":6.7383e-05,"tick_s":0.000976585,"churn_s":0.000113215,"export_s":0.000138683,"restore_s":7.604e-05,"live_bytes":40960,"peak_bytes":61440,"allocations":11,"hash":"ae6c58eaaffcbb17"} +{"store":"entt4","entities":1000,"density_percent":10,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":4,"create_s":0.000173664,"tick_s":0.000439139,"churn_s":3.046e-05,"export_s":0.000258808,"restore_s":0.00031307,"live_bytes":137608,"peak_bytes":141704,"allocations":88,"hash":"ae6c58eaaffcbb17"} +{"store":"entt4","entities":1000,"density_percent":10,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":5,"create_s":0.000213522,"tick_s":0.000433988,"churn_s":3.1105e-05,"export_s":0.000225163,"restore_s":0.000299176,"live_bytes":137608,"peak_bytes":141704,"allocations":88,"hash":"ae6c58eaaffcbb17"} +{"store":"rows","entities":1000,"density_percent":10,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":5,"create_s":7.8771e-05,"tick_s":0.000882553,"churn_s":9.8002e-05,"export_s":0.000151781,"restore_s":7.6406e-05,"live_bytes":40960,"peak_bytes":61440,"allocations":11,"hash":"ae6c58eaaffcbb17"} +{"store":"rows","entities":1000,"density_percent":10,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":6,"create_s":8.4245e-05,"tick_s":0.000807905,"churn_s":9.2622e-05,"export_s":0.000142798,"restore_s":7.2028e-05,"live_bytes":40960,"peak_bytes":61440,"allocations":11,"hash":"ae6c58eaaffcbb17"} +{"store":"entt4","entities":1000,"density_percent":10,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":6,"create_s":0.000178616,"tick_s":0.000415259,"churn_s":3.8436e-05,"export_s":0.000200164,"restore_s":0.000289721,"live_bytes":137608,"peak_bytes":141704,"allocations":88,"hash":"ae6c58eaaffcbb17"} +{"store":"rows","entities":1000,"density_percent":100,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":0,"create_s":5.1307e-05,"tick_s":0.000723898,"churn_s":9.1627e-05,"export_s":0.000115315,"restore_s":6.292e-05,"live_bytes":40960,"peak_bytes":61440,"allocations":11,"hash":"c18e5db8d060af79"} +{"store":"entt4","entities":1000,"density_percent":100,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":0,"create_s":0.000208733,"tick_s":0.00237114,"churn_s":3.3751e-05,"export_s":0.000176472,"restore_s":0.000358004,"live_bytes":144776,"peak_bytes":148872,"allocations":94,"hash":"c18e5db8d060af79"} +{"store":"entt4","entities":1000,"density_percent":100,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":1,"create_s":0.000201288,"tick_s":0.00217698,"churn_s":3.0128e-05,"export_s":0.000173433,"restore_s":0.000263971,"live_bytes":144776,"peak_bytes":148872,"allocations":94,"hash":"c18e5db8d060af79"} +{"store":"rows","entities":1000,"density_percent":100,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":1,"create_s":4.5831e-05,"tick_s":0.000621822,"churn_s":7.0091e-05,"export_s":9.9471e-05,"restore_s":5.4716e-05,"live_bytes":40960,"peak_bytes":61440,"allocations":11,"hash":"c18e5db8d060af79"} +{"store":"rows","entities":1000,"density_percent":100,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":2,"create_s":4.4242e-05,"tick_s":0.000616799,"churn_s":6.9882e-05,"export_s":0.000109444,"restore_s":5.4814e-05,"live_bytes":40960,"peak_bytes":61440,"allocations":11,"hash":"c18e5db8d060af79"} +{"store":"entt4","entities":1000,"density_percent":100,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":2,"create_s":0.000164315,"tick_s":0.00201198,"churn_s":2.8942e-05,"export_s":0.000170333,"restore_s":0.00027358,"live_bytes":144776,"peak_bytes":148872,"allocations":94,"hash":"c18e5db8d060af79"} +{"store":"entt4","entities":1000,"density_percent":100,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":3,"create_s":0.000159102,"tick_s":0.00194852,"churn_s":3.1222e-05,"export_s":0.000156748,"restore_s":0.000259755,"live_bytes":144776,"peak_bytes":148872,"allocations":94,"hash":"c18e5db8d060af79"} +{"store":"rows","entities":1000,"density_percent":100,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":3,"create_s":4.2144e-05,"tick_s":0.000550908,"churn_s":6.1276e-05,"export_s":9.0821e-05,"restore_s":4.9972e-05,"live_bytes":40960,"peak_bytes":61440,"allocations":11,"hash":"c18e5db8d060af79"} +{"store":"rows","entities":1000,"density_percent":100,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":4,"create_s":4.5043e-05,"tick_s":0.000529077,"churn_s":6.6715e-05,"export_s":9.0906e-05,"restore_s":5.0339e-05,"live_bytes":40960,"peak_bytes":61440,"allocations":11,"hash":"c18e5db8d060af79"} +{"store":"entt4","entities":1000,"density_percent":100,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":4,"create_s":0.000167765,"tick_s":0.00186859,"churn_s":2.5967e-05,"export_s":0.000147614,"restore_s":0.000262209,"live_bytes":144776,"peak_bytes":148872,"allocations":94,"hash":"c18e5db8d060af79"} +{"store":"entt4","entities":1000,"density_percent":100,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":5,"create_s":0.000152773,"tick_s":0.00188612,"churn_s":2.6206e-05,"export_s":0.000145845,"restore_s":0.000252392,"live_bytes":144776,"peak_bytes":148872,"allocations":94,"hash":"c18e5db8d060af79"} +{"store":"rows","entities":1000,"density_percent":100,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":5,"create_s":4.1412e-05,"tick_s":0.000569091,"churn_s":6.3421e-05,"export_s":9.0644e-05,"restore_s":4.9331e-05,"live_bytes":40960,"peak_bytes":61440,"allocations":11,"hash":"c18e5db8d060af79"} +{"store":"rows","entities":1000,"density_percent":100,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":6,"create_s":4.0422e-05,"tick_s":0.000564227,"churn_s":6.2832e-05,"export_s":9.0537e-05,"restore_s":4.9219e-05,"live_bytes":40960,"peak_bytes":61440,"allocations":11,"hash":"c18e5db8d060af79"} +{"store":"entt4","entities":1000,"density_percent":100,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":6,"create_s":0.000167931,"tick_s":0.0018864,"churn_s":2.5764e-05,"export_s":0.000154813,"restore_s":0.000259482,"live_bytes":144776,"peak_bytes":148872,"allocations":94,"hash":"c18e5db8d060af79"} +{"store":"rows","entities":10000,"density_percent":10,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":0,"create_s":0.000894344,"tick_s":0.00764334,"churn_s":0.0104967,"export_s":0.00111806,"restore_s":0.00102895,"live_bytes":655360,"peak_bytes":983040,"allocations":15,"hash":"1e0aaac006ff1a06"} +{"store":"entt4","entities":10000,"density_percent":10,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":0,"create_s":0.00107393,"tick_s":0.00315109,"churn_s":0.000184599,"export_s":0.0016079,"restore_s":0.00147123,"live_bytes":710392,"peak_bytes":710392,"allocations":158,"hash":"1e0aaac006ff1a06"} +{"store":"entt4","entities":10000,"density_percent":10,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":1,"create_s":0.00128858,"tick_s":0.00321304,"churn_s":0.000192583,"export_s":0.00201759,"restore_s":0.00170476,"live_bytes":710392,"peak_bytes":710392,"allocations":158,"hash":"1e0aaac006ff1a06"} +{"store":"rows","entities":10000,"density_percent":10,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":1,"create_s":0.000493474,"tick_s":0.00771479,"churn_s":0.0109975,"export_s":0.000928768,"restore_s":0.000733986,"live_bytes":655360,"peak_bytes":983040,"allocations":15,"hash":"1e0aaac006ff1a06"} +{"store":"rows","entities":10000,"density_percent":10,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":2,"create_s":0.000530267,"tick_s":0.00762633,"churn_s":0.0106324,"export_s":0.00111236,"restore_s":0.00102625,"live_bytes":655360,"peak_bytes":983040,"allocations":15,"hash":"1e0aaac006ff1a06"} +{"store":"entt4","entities":10000,"density_percent":10,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":2,"create_s":0.00107207,"tick_s":0.00324073,"churn_s":0.000194532,"export_s":0.00159807,"restore_s":0.00146928,"live_bytes":710392,"peak_bytes":710392,"allocations":158,"hash":"1e0aaac006ff1a06"} +{"store":"entt4","entities":10000,"density_percent":10,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":3,"create_s":0.00127386,"tick_s":0.00321161,"churn_s":0.000199773,"export_s":0.00202001,"restore_s":0.00171949,"live_bytes":710392,"peak_bytes":710392,"allocations":158,"hash":"1e0aaac006ff1a06"} +{"store":"rows","entities":10000,"density_percent":10,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":3,"create_s":0.000491505,"tick_s":0.00764157,"churn_s":0.010959,"export_s":0.00092803,"restore_s":0.000731839,"live_bytes":655360,"peak_bytes":983040,"allocations":15,"hash":"1e0aaac006ff1a06"} +{"store":"rows","entities":10000,"density_percent":10,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":4,"create_s":0.000520756,"tick_s":0.00767642,"churn_s":0.010907,"export_s":0.00111843,"restore_s":0.0010239,"live_bytes":655360,"peak_bytes":983040,"allocations":15,"hash":"1e0aaac006ff1a06"} +{"store":"entt4","entities":10000,"density_percent":10,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":4,"create_s":0.00106453,"tick_s":0.00322633,"churn_s":0.000207463,"export_s":0.00160014,"restore_s":0.00147454,"live_bytes":710392,"peak_bytes":710392,"allocations":158,"hash":"1e0aaac006ff1a06"} +{"store":"entt4","entities":10000,"density_percent":10,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":5,"create_s":0.00129792,"tick_s":0.00318484,"churn_s":0.000193237,"export_s":0.00201153,"restore_s":0.00173868,"live_bytes":710392,"peak_bytes":710392,"allocations":158,"hash":"1e0aaac006ff1a06"} +{"store":"rows","entities":10000,"density_percent":10,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":5,"create_s":0.000491646,"tick_s":0.00772663,"churn_s":0.0108217,"export_s":0.000931725,"restore_s":0.000774561,"live_bytes":655360,"peak_bytes":983040,"allocations":15,"hash":"1e0aaac006ff1a06"} +{"store":"rows","entities":10000,"density_percent":10,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":6,"create_s":0.00052156,"tick_s":0.00757465,"churn_s":0.0107485,"export_s":0.00112823,"restore_s":0.00107417,"live_bytes":655360,"peak_bytes":983040,"allocations":15,"hash":"1e0aaac006ff1a06"} +{"store":"entt4","entities":10000,"density_percent":10,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":6,"create_s":0.00108886,"tick_s":0.00314763,"churn_s":0.000190296,"export_s":0.00161012,"restore_s":0.00144853,"live_bytes":710392,"peak_bytes":710392,"allocations":158,"hash":"1e0aaac006ff1a06"} +{"store":"rows","entities":10000,"density_percent":100,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":0,"create_s":0.000874157,"tick_s":0.00937289,"churn_s":0.0106848,"export_s":0.00111279,"restore_s":0.00101158,"live_bytes":655360,"peak_bytes":983040,"allocations":15,"hash":"56e63b67590e4cf9"} +{"store":"entt4","entities":10000,"density_percent":100,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":0,"create_s":0.00146614,"tick_s":0.0188303,"churn_s":0.000268234,"export_s":0.00172531,"restore_s":0.00195422,"live_bytes":968672,"peak_bytes":968672,"allocations":189,"hash":"56e63b67590e4cf9"} +{"store":"entt4","entities":10000,"density_percent":100,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":1,"create_s":0.00183016,"tick_s":0.0190924,"churn_s":0.000280435,"export_s":0.00200165,"restore_s":0.00225849,"live_bytes":968672,"peak_bytes":968672,"allocations":189,"hash":"56e63b67590e4cf9"} +{"store":"rows","entities":10000,"density_percent":100,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":1,"create_s":0.000540883,"tick_s":0.00790372,"churn_s":0.0109622,"export_s":0.00105587,"restore_s":0.00103016,"live_bytes":655360,"peak_bytes":983040,"allocations":15,"hash":"56e63b67590e4cf9"} +{"store":"rows","entities":10000,"density_percent":100,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":2,"create_s":0.000862154,"tick_s":0.00777129,"churn_s":0.0109818,"export_s":0.0011428,"restore_s":0.00105379,"live_bytes":655360,"peak_bytes":983040,"allocations":15,"hash":"56e63b67590e4cf9"} +{"store":"entt4","entities":10000,"density_percent":100,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":2,"create_s":0.00147214,"tick_s":0.0187963,"churn_s":0.000260753,"export_s":0.00173691,"restore_s":0.00197655,"live_bytes":968672,"peak_bytes":968672,"allocations":189,"hash":"56e63b67590e4cf9"} +{"store":"entt4","entities":10000,"density_percent":100,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":3,"create_s":0.00181888,"tick_s":0.0190529,"churn_s":0.000270837,"export_s":0.00203215,"restore_s":0.00227142,"live_bytes":968672,"peak_bytes":968672,"allocations":189,"hash":"56e63b67590e4cf9"} +{"store":"rows","entities":10000,"density_percent":100,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":3,"create_s":0.000512822,"tick_s":0.00827035,"churn_s":0.0111243,"export_s":0.00106136,"restore_s":0.00103925,"live_bytes":655360,"peak_bytes":983040,"allocations":15,"hash":"56e63b67590e4cf9"} +{"store":"rows","entities":10000,"density_percent":100,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":4,"create_s":0.000854071,"tick_s":0.00799333,"churn_s":0.0108592,"export_s":0.00112641,"restore_s":0.00101121,"live_bytes":655360,"peak_bytes":983040,"allocations":15,"hash":"56e63b67590e4cf9"} +{"store":"entt4","entities":10000,"density_percent":100,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":4,"create_s":0.00144042,"tick_s":0.0189315,"churn_s":0.000273708,"export_s":0.00170615,"restore_s":0.00194496,"live_bytes":968672,"peak_bytes":968672,"allocations":189,"hash":"56e63b67590e4cf9"} +{"store":"entt4","entities":10000,"density_percent":100,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":5,"create_s":0.00182635,"tick_s":0.0188591,"churn_s":0.000281538,"export_s":0.00201876,"restore_s":0.00223865,"live_bytes":968672,"peak_bytes":968672,"allocations":189,"hash":"56e63b67590e4cf9"} +{"store":"rows","entities":10000,"density_percent":100,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":5,"create_s":0.000510223,"tick_s":0.00737481,"churn_s":0.0106048,"export_s":0.00105058,"restore_s":0.00101516,"live_bytes":655360,"peak_bytes":983040,"allocations":15,"hash":"56e63b67590e4cf9"} +{"store":"rows","entities":10000,"density_percent":100,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":6,"create_s":0.000851167,"tick_s":0.00746952,"churn_s":0.0106683,"export_s":0.00111004,"restore_s":0.00101083,"live_bytes":655360,"peak_bytes":983040,"allocations":15,"hash":"56e63b67590e4cf9"} +{"store":"entt4","entities":10000,"density_percent":100,"seed":123456,"ticks":100,"sample":6,"create_s":0.00146026,"tick_s":0.0190615,"churn_s":0.000276677,"export_s":0.00175583,"restore_s":0.00196496,"live_bytes":968672,"peak_bytes":968672,"allocations":189,"hash":"56e63b67590e4cf9"}