Measure aggregate cost and fidelity across scarcity scenarios

This commit is contained in:
dingo
2026-09-26 09:39:53 -04:00
parent 55a728acd4
commit c237e4da97
15 changed files with 1115 additions and 529 deletions
+6
View File
@@ -206,3 +206,9 @@ stays open.
No date or production capacity is promised without staffing and benchmark data.
Every release records simulation/world/network versions; biological upgrades use
production snapshot → clone → migrate → accelerated comparison → approval.
M4.6 completed as measurement tooling and a policy review on 2026-09-26; see
[aggregate budget report](engineering/AGGREGATE_BUDGET.md). No automatic tier policy
qualified. M5 may proceed independently; production tier selection needs the
fidelity and target-host follow-ups listed in that report.
+16 -3
View File
@@ -1,13 +1,13 @@
# Project status and next steps
Updated 2026-09-23. The repository contains an engineering foundation and a
Updated 2026-09-26. The repository contains an engineering foundation and a
deterministic headless proof. It does not yet contain cellular gameplay or a
persistent simulation server. The founding vision remains unchanged.
## Completed implementation
- Vision, architectural pillars, risks, open-question register, architecture
diagrams, biological contracts, engineering constitution and 40 ADRs.
diagrams, biological contracts, engineering constitution and 41 ADRs.
Proposed/deferred choices remain distinct from accepted proof decisions.
- M0–M4 task breakdowns with dependencies, acceptance evidence and risks,
plus M5–M14 gates in [ROADMAP.md](ROADMAP.md).
@@ -61,7 +61,8 @@ for the bounded proof; the general production ECS remains a later measured choic
| Priority | Work | Completion evidence |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | M4.6 budget and review the aggregate model | CPU and memory against the measured error regimes; the tier policy has to survive a resolution boundary that is not monotone |
| 1 | M5 small sparse voxel prototype | Deterministic generation, modification, snapshot and restore; select scoped storage contract first |
| Research | Improve aggregate fidelity and measure Linux/target-host costs | M4.6 found no qualifying width; see the aggregate budget report |
| 2 | Revisit the ADR-0031/0032 reproduction cost model | Reproduction is affordable only at the genome schema's floor; decide whether that is intended before M4 builds cohorts on it |
| Delivery gate | Add/update the dev workload when a deployable increment needs it; Argo is ready | Observe Job/pod completion separately from image publication; no World0 changes |
@@ -506,3 +507,15 @@ commit. A fifty-tick interval shedding 10,480 against 6,950 held while drawing
13,080 in reproduced it. Arrivals are now the first leg, matching the order the
arithmetic was checked in, with a regression covering it. Native Release, analysis,
ASan and formatting passed 38/38; Linux CI has not run yet.
## M4.6 - aggregate budget review (2026-09-26)
Completed test-only shared model, CPU/retained-memory benchmark, and 15-scenario
scarcity sensitivity report. The partial `tests/fixtures/resolution_model.hpp`
was integrated with existing M4.5 controls, including contested parent allocation.
No production library, simulation format, deployment or gameplay rule changed.
See [the report](engineering/AGGREGATE_BUDGET.md) and ADR-0041. None of the five
widths passes the proposed fidelity gate across supplies 240/300/360; automatic tier
selection remains disabled. The next implementation milestone is M5's sparse voxel
prototype; aggregate-model improvement and Linux/target-host measurement remain
prerequisites for a production tier policy. See VALIDATION.md for checks actually run.
+47
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,47 @@
# ADR-0041: Measure aggregate cost before enabling tier selection
## Status
Accepted for M4.6 measurement tooling only. No runtime tier selector or biological
rule is adopted. Uses the breeding-order correction already committed in 55a728a. Historical
M4.5 results are retained; the new run independently checks them.
## Context
M4.5 detected large resolution errors, and review detected mismatched parent
priority at capacity. Timing those differing models would not justify a policy.
## Decision
Share one test-only fixture between comparison and benchmark. Both representations
allocate breeding slots oldest-first. A contested-slot control compares individual
portraits, not only totals. Preserve the real collapse/advance/materialize integration.
Measure 100 founders for 10,000 ticks at widths 10/25/50/100/200 and energy supplies
240/300/360 per tick. Supplies are independent experiments, not gameplay constants.
Report population, energy and matter error plus false extinction. Benchmark step
loops with a warmup and three fresh measured repetitions, report steady-clock elapsed
nanoseconds, final census and peak row payload/vector capacity bytes. Timing excludes
setup, conservation checks and conversion; these costs are not production budgets.
No portable wall-time assertion. Compare costs only alongside fidelity results.
Provisional research gate: no false extinction and final population, energy and
matter errors each <=100 parts per thousand in every tested scarcity scenario.
This is a recommendation for experiments, not an accepted production error budget.
Failure keeps automatic tier selection disabled; do not pick a width merely because
it runs faster. Even passing would require trajectory, mixed-genome and host evidence.
## Alternatives Considered
Copying the fixture would allow rules to drift. Timing the validation loop measures
assertions/ledger verification instead of model advancement. A runtime automatic
selector is premature before any resolution has demonstrated acceptable fidelity.
## Benefits
Costs and ecological error refer to the same fixture. Raw results are reproducible.
## Costs
The individual fixture retains dead rows and sorts eligible parents each step;
report that cost rather than extrapolating to a future compact active ECS.
## Risks
One synthetic genome, deterministic founding distribution, no production physics,
network, scheduler, conversion overhead or server hardware measurement. Payload and
capacity bytes exclude allocator metadata, temporary vectors, stack and RSS.
## Consequences
Keep controls and conservation in CTest. Archive native measurements with compiler,
build and hardware metadata. Do not change simulation versions: only a test model
changes. Repeat Linux/target-host measurements before any capacity promise.
+2
View File
@@ -39,3 +39,5 @@ transitive license obligations, maintenance/security review, owner and removal
boundary. Candidate performance and binary-size comparisons are hypotheses until
benchmarked. Primary sources were reviewed during the initial September 2026
design. No unadopted candidate is a link dependency of the proof.
- [ADR-0041: Aggregate cost and fidelity budget](0041-aggregate-budget.md) - M4.6 measurement only.
+8
View File
@@ -315,3 +315,11 @@ model, one scarce axis and one initial distribution, so the numbers describe thi
fixture; interval-length error is unmeasured, because the aggregate run sub-steps at
one tick to keep the averaging error attributable; and nothing here is distributed
or persistent.
## M4.6 budget review
[ADR-0041](../adr/0041-aggregate-budget.md) and the
[measurement report](../engineering/AGGREGATE_BUDGET.md) evaluate cost together with
population, energy and matter errors. No tested width qualifies across the scarcity
sweep. Faster execution alone does not authorize a resolution switch; automatic
selection remains disabled. This fixture is not a production ecological model.
+98
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,98 @@
# M4.6 aggregate budget and sensitivity report
## Decision
M4.6 measurement work is complete; automatic tier selection remains **disabled**.
None of the tested resolutions meets the provisional research gate in ADR-0041.
This is a measured rejection of this model as a production tier policy, not a
promise to simulate every organism individually at world scale.
## Reproduce
```sh
cmake --preset release
cmake --build --preset release
ctest --preset release
./build/release/evo-resolution-benchmark > resolution-budget.jsonl
```
Windows: `tools/windows-check.ps1 -Preset release -Action check`, then
`build/release/evo-resolution-benchmark.exe`. `--verify` runs conservation and
sensitivity without timings and is registered in CTest. Exceptions fail the run.
The executable rejects other arguments. Use a Release build for cost comparisons.
## Method and host
Measured 2026-09-26 on Windows, AMD Ryzen 7 9800X3D, 8 cores/16 logical processors,
MSVC 19.44 x64, CMake Release /O2, single simulation thread, no CPU affinity or
frequency lock. The host is a workstation, not the R730xd. Raw data:
[resolution-budget-msvc1944.jsonl](results/resolution-budget-msvc1944.jsonl).
Base checkout: 55a728a plus the M4.6 working changes. Fixture version 2 identifies
the shared configurable model, not a persistent simulation version.
100 founders, 10,000 ticks, capacity 200; no randomness. Five age widths and energy
supply 240/300/360; only supply varies between scarcity scenarios. Four identical
matter channels remain abundant. A warmup and three fresh measured repetitions
per representation/scenario alternate timing order. Timings include step allocation,
sorting and peak-counter observation, exclude setup/copy, logging, conservation
checks, cohort validation and collapse/advance/materialize transactions. Terminal
censuses are output so the compiler cannot discard the computation.
Peak payload is vector size times row sizeof; peak capacity includes spare vector
storage. Neither includes allocator metadata, per-step eligible-index scratch,
object/stack bytes or RSS. The individual fixture retains every dead row and scans
it, whereas aggregate empty classes are erased. This inflates its cost relative to
a future compact active ECS. These figures compare these fixtures only.
## Baseline costs (supply 300)
Median elapsed milliseconds for all 10,000 ticks. Extinct runs still execute the
remaining empty steps, so their low cost must not be treated as useful throughput.
| Width | Individual ms | Aggregate ms | Peak individual capacity bytes | Peak aggregate capacity bytes | Aggregate survives |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---|
| 10 | 27.107 | 0.250 | 122528 | 360 | yes |
| 25 | 27.256 | 0.054 | 122528 | 160 | no |
| 50 | 29.190 | 0.135 | 122528 | 120 | yes |
| 100 | 27.180 | 0.045 | 122528 | 80 | no |
| 200 | 27.263 | 0.045 | 122528 | 80 | no |
## Sensitivity
Errors are integer parts per thousand: abs(a-b)/max(a,b), rounded down; zero when
both values are zero. Matter is per channel; all four channels are identical here.
The proposed gate requires no false extinction at any tick and final population,
energy and matter error each <=100 ppt in **every** scenario. This threshold was
written before the run; it is a research recommendation, not a biological law.
Maximum errors over the trajectory are also recorded in the raw data and are often
much worse than the terminal errors. No candidate passes even the terminal gate.
| Width | Supply | Individual/aggregate survivors | Population error | Energy error | Matter error | False extinction |
|---|---|---|---:|---:|---:|---|
| 10 | 240 | 108/120 | 100 | 127 | 346 | no |
| 10 | 300 | 75/100 | 250 | 24 | 724 | no |
| 10 | 360 | 130/130 | 0 | 34 | 531 | no |
| 25 | 240 | 108/100 | 74 | 272 | 189 | no |
| 25 | 300 | 75/0 | 1000 | 1000 | 1000 | yes |
| 25 | 360 | 130/130 | 0 | 151 | 657 | no |
| 50 | 240 | 108/0 | 1000 | 1000 | 1000 | yes |
| 50 | 300 | 75/120 | 375 | 43 | 35 | no |
| 50 | 360 | 130/180 | 277 | 217 | 589 | no |
| 100 | 240 | 108/0 | 1000 | 1000 | 1000 | yes |
| 100 | 300 | 75/0 | 1000 | 1000 | 1000 | yes |
| 100 | 360 | 130/0 | 1000 | 1000 | 1000 | yes |
| 200 | 240 | 108/0 | 1000 | 1000 | 1000 | yes |
| 200 | 300 | 75/0 | 1000 | 1000 | 1000 | yes |
| 200 | 360 | 130/0 | 1000 | 1000 | 1000 | yes |
The shared fixture reproduces M4.5's baseline survivor results. Width 10 avoids
extinction but has large matter errors; width 50 fails under reduced energy supply.
Widths 100 and 200 go extinct in every scenario. Conservation passed at every tick
for both representations in all 15 scenarios; that does not imply ecological fidelity.
## Limits and next steps
This is one genome and one deterministic founding distribution. No ensemble,
spatial interactions, oxygen, predation, network load or production threading is
represented. There is no R730xd capacity estimate or Kubernetes resource request.
CPU measurements are wall time on an uncontrolled host and are reports, not CI gates.
Before adopting a tier model: preserve within-class reserve variation, test multiple
genomes and founding distributions, measure trajectory/distribution errors, and
compare an individual store with dead rows retired. Measure conversions, catch-up
and complete region workloads on Linux and the target host. Calibrate acceptable
error budgets with biological/playtest requirements. M5 can independently begin its
small sparse-voxel prototype; no terrain dependency is added to this fixture.
+25
View File
@@ -1373,3 +1373,28 @@ order-sensitive stage, and the environment is sized so intake never depletes it,
which the fixture asserts rather than assumes. A future stage introducing another
order-sensitive decision would need its own control before these numbers could be
trusted again.
## M4.6 local validation - 2026-09-26
Base 55a728a plus working M4.6 changes. Integrated the prior agent's untracked
`tests/fixtures/resolution_model.hpp`; no production library changes or format
version changes. Existing contested-parent and round-trip controls remain active.
- Native MSVC 19.44 Release configure/build and CTest: 39/39 passed.
- Native analysis (clang-tidy 19, including fixture headers): build and 39/39 passed.
Initial analysis found a throwing error-reporting boundary in the benchmark;
replaced catch-handler stream writes with stdio diagnostics and reran successfully.
- Native AddressSanitizer: build and 39/39 passed. Windows ASan does not cover UBSan.
- clang-format 19 format-check passed, now including tests/*.hpp. Diff whitespace
check passed.
- Full Release benchmark: 15 scenarios, one warmup plus three measured repetitions
per representation. Raw results and host/method caveats are in
[AGGREGATE_BUDGET.md](AGGREGATE_BUDGET.md). All scenarios conserved every channel;
none qualified across all scarcity inputs under the proposed research gate.
- Linux CI, UBSan, target-server profiling and production deployment were not run.
No World0 resources or user source documents were changed.
The final exception-handler-only adjustment was compiled in analysis; Release and
ASan benchmark targets were then rebuilt and their resolution tests rerun. No
performance or model algorithm changed after the archived timing run.
@@ -0,0 +1,111 @@
{"kind":"metadata","model":"resolution-fixture-2","founders":100,"ticks":10000,"randomness":"none","warmups":1,"samples":3,"compiler":"MSVC 1944","build":"release"}
{"kind":"sensitivity","supply":240,"width":10,"individual_living":108,"aggregate_living":120,"population_gap_ppt":100,"energy_gap_ppt":127,"matter_gap_ppt":346,"max_population_gap_ppt":725,"max_energy_gap_ppt":650,"max_matter_gap_ppt":932,"false_extinction":false,"research_gate_pass":false}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":240,"width":10,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":146800,"peak_rows":6,"peak_payload_bytes":240,"peak_capacity_bytes":240,"living":120,"energy":6000,"matter_per_channel":134340}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":240,"width":10,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":25031400,"peak_rows":2471,"peak_payload_bytes":79072,"peak_capacity_bytes":81696,"living":108,"energy":6875,"matter_per_channel":87828}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":240,"width":10,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":25904400,"peak_rows":2471,"peak_payload_bytes":79072,"peak_capacity_bytes":81696,"living":108,"energy":6875,"matter_per_channel":87828}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":240,"width":10,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":141600,"peak_rows":6,"peak_payload_bytes":240,"peak_capacity_bytes":240,"living":120,"energy":6000,"matter_per_channel":134340}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":240,"width":10,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":140900,"peak_rows":6,"peak_payload_bytes":240,"peak_capacity_bytes":240,"living":120,"energy":6000,"matter_per_channel":134340}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":240,"width":10,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":25541800,"peak_rows":2471,"peak_payload_bytes":79072,"peak_capacity_bytes":81696,"living":108,"energy":6875,"matter_per_channel":87828}
{"kind":"sensitivity","supply":300,"width":10,"individual_living":75,"aggregate_living":100,"population_gap_ppt":250,"energy_gap_ppt":24,"matter_gap_ppt":724,"max_population_gap_ppt":530,"max_energy_gap_ppt":485,"max_matter_gap_ppt":935,"false_extinction":false,"research_gate_pass":false}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":300,"width":10,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":249600,"peak_rows":7,"peak_payload_bytes":280,"peak_capacity_bytes":360,"living":100,"energy":6120,"matter_per_channel":14360}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":300,"width":10,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":27547800,"peak_rows":2625,"peak_payload_bytes":84000,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":75,"energy":6275,"matter_per_channel":52115}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":300,"width":10,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":26594700,"peak_rows":2625,"peak_payload_bytes":84000,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":75,"energy":6275,"matter_per_channel":52115}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":300,"width":10,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":252100,"peak_rows":7,"peak_payload_bytes":280,"peak_capacity_bytes":360,"living":100,"energy":6120,"matter_per_channel":14360}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":300,"width":10,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":247300,"peak_rows":7,"peak_payload_bytes":280,"peak_capacity_bytes":360,"living":100,"energy":6120,"matter_per_channel":14360}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":300,"width":10,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":27106700,"peak_rows":2625,"peak_payload_bytes":84000,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":75,"energy":6275,"matter_per_channel":52115}
{"kind":"sensitivity","supply":360,"width":10,"individual_living":130,"aggregate_living":130,"population_gap_ppt":0,"energy_gap_ppt":34,"matter_gap_ppt":531,"max_population_gap_ppt":400,"max_energy_gap_ppt":501,"max_matter_gap_ppt":923,"false_extinction":false,"research_gate_pass":false}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":360,"width":10,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":200600,"peak_rows":8,"peak_payload_bytes":320,"peak_capacity_bytes":360,"living":130,"energy":6800,"matter_per_channel":104940}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":360,"width":10,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":32192200,"peak_rows":3156,"peak_payload_bytes":100992,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":130,"energy":7040,"matter_per_channel":49113}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":360,"width":10,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":32369500,"peak_rows":3156,"peak_payload_bytes":100992,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":130,"energy":7040,"matter_per_channel":49113}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":360,"width":10,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":207300,"peak_rows":8,"peak_payload_bytes":320,"peak_capacity_bytes":360,"living":130,"energy":6800,"matter_per_channel":104940}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":360,"width":10,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":198700,"peak_rows":8,"peak_payload_bytes":320,"peak_capacity_bytes":360,"living":130,"energy":6800,"matter_per_channel":104940}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":360,"width":10,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":32798600,"peak_rows":3156,"peak_payload_bytes":100992,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":130,"energy":7040,"matter_per_channel":49113}
{"kind":"policy","width":10,"passes_all_scenarios":false}
{"kind":"sensitivity","supply":240,"width":25,"individual_living":108,"aggregate_living":100,"population_gap_ppt":74,"energy_gap_ppt":272,"matter_gap_ppt":189,"max_population_gap_ppt":580,"max_energy_gap_ppt":718,"max_matter_gap_ppt":923,"false_extinction":false,"research_gate_pass":false}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":240,"width":25,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":126900,"peak_rows":3,"peak_payload_bytes":120,"peak_capacity_bytes":120,"living":100,"energy":5000,"matter_per_channel":71150}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":240,"width":25,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":24614400,"peak_rows":2471,"peak_payload_bytes":79072,"peak_capacity_bytes":81696,"living":108,"energy":6875,"matter_per_channel":87828}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":240,"width":25,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":26241400,"peak_rows":2471,"peak_payload_bytes":79072,"peak_capacity_bytes":81696,"living":108,"energy":6875,"matter_per_channel":87828}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":240,"width":25,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":127800,"peak_rows":3,"peak_payload_bytes":120,"peak_capacity_bytes":120,"living":100,"energy":5000,"matter_per_channel":71150}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":240,"width":25,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":126800,"peak_rows":3,"peak_payload_bytes":120,"peak_capacity_bytes":120,"living":100,"energy":5000,"matter_per_channel":71150}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":240,"width":25,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":25096400,"peak_rows":2471,"peak_payload_bytes":79072,"peak_capacity_bytes":81696,"living":108,"energy":6875,"matter_per_channel":87828}
{"kind":"sensitivity","supply":300,"width":25,"individual_living":75,"aggregate_living":0,"population_gap_ppt":1000,"energy_gap_ppt":1000,"matter_gap_ppt":1000,"max_population_gap_ppt":1000,"max_energy_gap_ppt":1000,"max_matter_gap_ppt":1000,"false_extinction":true,"research_gate_pass":false}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":300,"width":25,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":55100,"peak_rows":4,"peak_payload_bytes":160,"peak_capacity_bytes":160,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":300,"width":25,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":27255700,"peak_rows":2625,"peak_payload_bytes":84000,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":75,"energy":6275,"matter_per_channel":52115}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":300,"width":25,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":26745600,"peak_rows":2625,"peak_payload_bytes":84000,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":75,"energy":6275,"matter_per_channel":52115}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":300,"width":25,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":54500,"peak_rows":4,"peak_payload_bytes":160,"peak_capacity_bytes":160,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":300,"width":25,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":53400,"peak_rows":4,"peak_payload_bytes":160,"peak_capacity_bytes":160,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":300,"width":25,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":27301400,"peak_rows":2625,"peak_payload_bytes":84000,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":75,"energy":6275,"matter_per_channel":52115}
{"kind":"sensitivity","supply":360,"width":25,"individual_living":130,"aggregate_living":130,"population_gap_ppt":0,"energy_gap_ppt":151,"matter_gap_ppt":657,"max_population_gap_ppt":435,"max_energy_gap_ppt":528,"max_matter_gap_ppt":915,"false_extinction":false,"research_gate_pass":false}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":360,"width":25,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":176900,"peak_rows":4,"peak_payload_bytes":160,"peak_capacity_bytes":160,"living":130,"energy":8300,"matter_per_channel":143460}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":360,"width":25,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":31631700,"peak_rows":3156,"peak_payload_bytes":100992,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":130,"energy":7040,"matter_per_channel":49113}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":360,"width":25,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":32229400,"peak_rows":3156,"peak_payload_bytes":100992,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":130,"energy":7040,"matter_per_channel":49113}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":360,"width":25,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":178000,"peak_rows":4,"peak_payload_bytes":160,"peak_capacity_bytes":160,"living":130,"energy":8300,"matter_per_channel":143460}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":360,"width":25,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":177200,"peak_rows":4,"peak_payload_bytes":160,"peak_capacity_bytes":160,"living":130,"energy":8300,"matter_per_channel":143460}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":360,"width":25,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":31715900,"peak_rows":3156,"peak_payload_bytes":100992,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":130,"energy":7040,"matter_per_channel":49113}
{"kind":"policy","width":25,"passes_all_scenarios":false}
{"kind":"sensitivity","supply":240,"width":50,"individual_living":108,"aggregate_living":0,"population_gap_ppt":1000,"energy_gap_ppt":1000,"matter_gap_ppt":1000,"max_population_gap_ppt":1000,"max_energy_gap_ppt":1000,"max_matter_gap_ppt":1000,"false_extinction":true,"research_gate_pass":false}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":240,"width":50,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":42700,"peak_rows":2,"peak_payload_bytes":80,"peak_capacity_bytes":80,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":240,"width":50,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":26048600,"peak_rows":2471,"peak_payload_bytes":79072,"peak_capacity_bytes":81696,"living":108,"energy":6875,"matter_per_channel":87828}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":240,"width":50,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":25978000,"peak_rows":2471,"peak_payload_bytes":79072,"peak_capacity_bytes":81696,"living":108,"energy":6875,"matter_per_channel":87828}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":240,"width":50,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":42500,"peak_rows":2,"peak_payload_bytes":80,"peak_capacity_bytes":80,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":240,"width":50,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":42500,"peak_rows":2,"peak_payload_bytes":80,"peak_capacity_bytes":80,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":240,"width":50,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":24559800,"peak_rows":2471,"peak_payload_bytes":79072,"peak_capacity_bytes":81696,"living":108,"energy":6875,"matter_per_channel":87828}
{"kind":"sensitivity","supply":300,"width":50,"individual_living":75,"aggregate_living":120,"population_gap_ppt":375,"energy_gap_ppt":43,"matter_gap_ppt":35,"max_population_gap_ppt":868,"max_energy_gap_ppt":977,"max_matter_gap_ppt":943,"false_extinction":false,"research_gate_pass":false}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":300,"width":50,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":134500,"peak_rows":3,"peak_payload_bytes":120,"peak_capacity_bytes":120,"living":120,"energy":6000,"matter_per_channel":54060}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":300,"width":50,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":29189700,"peak_rows":2625,"peak_payload_bytes":84000,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":75,"energy":6275,"matter_per_channel":52115}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":300,"width":50,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":27115300,"peak_rows":2625,"peak_payload_bytes":84000,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":75,"energy":6275,"matter_per_channel":52115}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":300,"width":50,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":153300,"peak_rows":3,"peak_payload_bytes":120,"peak_capacity_bytes":120,"living":120,"energy":6000,"matter_per_channel":54060}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":300,"width":50,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":130600,"peak_rows":3,"peak_payload_bytes":120,"peak_capacity_bytes":120,"living":120,"energy":6000,"matter_per_channel":54060}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":300,"width":50,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":34029700,"peak_rows":2625,"peak_payload_bytes":84000,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":75,"energy":6275,"matter_per_channel":52115}
{"kind":"sensitivity","supply":360,"width":50,"individual_living":130,"aggregate_living":180,"population_gap_ppt":277,"energy_gap_ppt":217,"matter_gap_ppt":589,"max_population_gap_ppt":561,"max_energy_gap_ppt":772,"max_matter_gap_ppt":934,"false_extinction":false,"research_gate_pass":false}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":360,"width":50,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":128500,"peak_rows":3,"peak_payload_bytes":120,"peak_capacity_bytes":120,"living":180,"energy":9000,"matter_per_channel":119700}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":360,"width":50,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":32230800,"peak_rows":3156,"peak_payload_bytes":100992,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":130,"energy":7040,"matter_per_channel":49113}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":360,"width":50,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":34034400,"peak_rows":3156,"peak_payload_bytes":100992,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":130,"energy":7040,"matter_per_channel":49113}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":360,"width":50,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":129300,"peak_rows":3,"peak_payload_bytes":120,"peak_capacity_bytes":120,"living":180,"energy":9000,"matter_per_channel":119700}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":360,"width":50,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":126900,"peak_rows":3,"peak_payload_bytes":120,"peak_capacity_bytes":120,"living":180,"energy":9000,"matter_per_channel":119700}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":360,"width":50,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":33152200,"peak_rows":3156,"peak_payload_bytes":100992,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":130,"energy":7040,"matter_per_channel":49113}
{"kind":"policy","width":50,"passes_all_scenarios":false}
{"kind":"sensitivity","supply":240,"width":100,"individual_living":108,"aggregate_living":0,"population_gap_ppt":1000,"energy_gap_ppt":1000,"matter_gap_ppt":1000,"max_population_gap_ppt":1000,"max_energy_gap_ppt":1000,"max_matter_gap_ppt":1000,"false_extinction":true,"research_gate_pass":false}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":240,"width":100,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":41900,"peak_rows":1,"peak_payload_bytes":40,"peak_capacity_bytes":40,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":240,"width":100,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":25856900,"peak_rows":2471,"peak_payload_bytes":79072,"peak_capacity_bytes":81696,"living":108,"energy":6875,"matter_per_channel":87828}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":240,"width":100,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":25132500,"peak_rows":2471,"peak_payload_bytes":79072,"peak_capacity_bytes":81696,"living":108,"energy":6875,"matter_per_channel":87828}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":240,"width":100,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":40700,"peak_rows":1,"peak_payload_bytes":40,"peak_capacity_bytes":40,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":240,"width":100,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":40300,"peak_rows":1,"peak_payload_bytes":40,"peak_capacity_bytes":40,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":240,"width":100,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":25615500,"peak_rows":2471,"peak_payload_bytes":79072,"peak_capacity_bytes":81696,"living":108,"energy":6875,"matter_per_channel":87828}
{"kind":"sensitivity","supply":300,"width":100,"individual_living":75,"aggregate_living":0,"population_gap_ppt":1000,"energy_gap_ppt":1000,"matter_gap_ppt":1000,"max_population_gap_ppt":1000,"max_energy_gap_ppt":1000,"max_matter_gap_ppt":1000,"false_extinction":true,"research_gate_pass":false}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":300,"width":100,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":44800,"peak_rows":2,"peak_payload_bytes":80,"peak_capacity_bytes":80,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":300,"width":100,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":28119900,"peak_rows":2625,"peak_payload_bytes":84000,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":75,"energy":6275,"matter_per_channel":52115}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":300,"width":100,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":27056100,"peak_rows":2625,"peak_payload_bytes":84000,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":75,"energy":6275,"matter_per_channel":52115}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":300,"width":100,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":45400,"peak_rows":2,"peak_payload_bytes":80,"peak_capacity_bytes":80,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":300,"width":100,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":44600,"peak_rows":2,"peak_payload_bytes":80,"peak_capacity_bytes":80,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":300,"width":100,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":27179600,"peak_rows":2625,"peak_payload_bytes":84000,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":75,"energy":6275,"matter_per_channel":52115}
{"kind":"sensitivity","supply":360,"width":100,"individual_living":130,"aggregate_living":0,"population_gap_ppt":1000,"energy_gap_ppt":1000,"matter_gap_ppt":1000,"max_population_gap_ppt":1000,"max_energy_gap_ppt":1000,"max_matter_gap_ppt":1000,"false_extinction":true,"research_gate_pass":false}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":360,"width":100,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":45800,"peak_rows":2,"peak_payload_bytes":80,"peak_capacity_bytes":80,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":360,"width":100,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":32033200,"peak_rows":3156,"peak_payload_bytes":100992,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":130,"energy":7040,"matter_per_channel":49113}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":360,"width":100,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":32456600,"peak_rows":3156,"peak_payload_bytes":100992,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":130,"energy":7040,"matter_per_channel":49113}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":360,"width":100,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":45900,"peak_rows":2,"peak_payload_bytes":80,"peak_capacity_bytes":80,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":360,"width":100,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":44700,"peak_rows":2,"peak_payload_bytes":80,"peak_capacity_bytes":80,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":360,"width":100,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":32254100,"peak_rows":3156,"peak_payload_bytes":100992,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":130,"energy":7040,"matter_per_channel":49113}
{"kind":"policy","width":100,"passes_all_scenarios":false}
{"kind":"sensitivity","supply":240,"width":200,"individual_living":108,"aggregate_living":0,"population_gap_ppt":1000,"energy_gap_ppt":1000,"matter_gap_ppt":1000,"max_population_gap_ppt":1000,"max_energy_gap_ppt":1000,"max_matter_gap_ppt":1000,"false_extinction":true,"research_gate_pass":false}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":240,"width":200,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":40300,"peak_rows":1,"peak_payload_bytes":40,"peak_capacity_bytes":40,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":240,"width":200,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":25126700,"peak_rows":2471,"peak_payload_bytes":79072,"peak_capacity_bytes":81696,"living":108,"energy":6875,"matter_per_channel":87828}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":240,"width":200,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":25820000,"peak_rows":2471,"peak_payload_bytes":79072,"peak_capacity_bytes":81696,"living":108,"energy":6875,"matter_per_channel":87828}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":240,"width":200,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":41200,"peak_rows":1,"peak_payload_bytes":40,"peak_capacity_bytes":40,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":240,"width":200,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":40800,"peak_rows":1,"peak_payload_bytes":40,"peak_capacity_bytes":40,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":240,"width":200,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":24109700,"peak_rows":2471,"peak_payload_bytes":79072,"peak_capacity_bytes":81696,"living":108,"energy":6875,"matter_per_channel":87828}
{"kind":"sensitivity","supply":300,"width":200,"individual_living":75,"aggregate_living":0,"population_gap_ppt":1000,"energy_gap_ppt":1000,"matter_gap_ppt":1000,"max_population_gap_ppt":1000,"max_energy_gap_ppt":1000,"max_matter_gap_ppt":1000,"false_extinction":true,"research_gate_pass":false}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":300,"width":200,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":45300,"peak_rows":2,"peak_payload_bytes":80,"peak_capacity_bytes":80,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":300,"width":200,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":25969900,"peak_rows":2625,"peak_payload_bytes":84000,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":75,"energy":6275,"matter_per_channel":52115}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":300,"width":200,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":30360100,"peak_rows":2625,"peak_payload_bytes":84000,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":75,"energy":6275,"matter_per_channel":52115}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":300,"width":200,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":46900,"peak_rows":2,"peak_payload_bytes":80,"peak_capacity_bytes":80,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":300,"width":200,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":45200,"peak_rows":2,"peak_payload_bytes":80,"peak_capacity_bytes":80,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":300,"width":200,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":27263300,"peak_rows":2625,"peak_payload_bytes":84000,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":75,"energy":6275,"matter_per_channel":52115}
{"kind":"sensitivity","supply":360,"width":200,"individual_living":130,"aggregate_living":0,"population_gap_ppt":1000,"energy_gap_ppt":1000,"matter_gap_ppt":1000,"max_population_gap_ppt":1000,"max_energy_gap_ppt":1000,"max_matter_gap_ppt":1000,"false_extinction":true,"research_gate_pass":false}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":360,"width":200,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":45600,"peak_rows":2,"peak_payload_bytes":80,"peak_capacity_bytes":80,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":360,"width":200,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":32157600,"peak_rows":3156,"peak_payload_bytes":100992,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":130,"energy":7040,"matter_per_channel":49113}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":360,"width":200,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":31966100,"peak_rows":3156,"peak_payload_bytes":100992,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":130,"energy":7040,"matter_per_channel":49113}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":360,"width":200,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":46900,"peak_rows":2,"peak_payload_bytes":80,"peak_capacity_bytes":80,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":360,"width":200,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":45900,"peak_rows":2,"peak_payload_bytes":80,"peak_capacity_bytes":80,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0}
{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":360,"width":200,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":31683700,"peak_rows":3156,"peak_payload_bytes":100992,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":130,"energy":7040,"matter_per_channel":49113}
{"kind":"policy","width":200,"passes_all_scenarios":false}