M11.1: record the first cellular loop decisions (ADR-0098)
Foundation / checks (checks) (push) Successful in 4s
Foundation / checks (client) (push) Successful in 5s
Foundation / checks (ecs) (push) Successful in 4s
Foundation / checks (network) (push) Successful in 5s
Foundation / checks (postgres) (push) Successful in 5s
Foundation / checks (tsan) (push) Successful in 5s
Foundation / checks (deploy) (push) Successful in 3m33s
Foundation / postgres-tools (push) Successful in 5s
Foundation / image (push) Successful in 4s
Foundation / server-image (push) Successful in 5s

Maintainer decisions (2026-10-09) for the first playable loop: budding (parent keeps
control, one funded wildlife bud); funded in-life mutation from seeded candidates;
exact-copy heredity, no NPC mutation in M11; logout freezes at once, lingers vulnerable,
then suspends; resume in place or nearest valid spot within a bounded radius;
absorption plus engulfment by membrane-contested size ratio; first bud fundable within a
session (tunable); friend recognition deferred. Updates OPEN_QUESTIONS 7/10/14/31/33,
REPRODUCTION_MODEL, ROADMAP, STATUS; BACKLOG gains the open M10 native-client items.
Refresh the dev session window.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
dingo
2026-10-09 10:51:23 -04:00
co-authored by Claude Opus 5.5
parent af156ab3f0
commit c468c70933
8 changed files with 236 additions and 6 deletions
+2
View File
@@ -15,6 +15,8 @@ names it. Remove an item only when it is done, and record where it was done.
| **Store Job values.** Supply the published registry digests for `aevolution-postgres-tools` and `aevolution-server` (from each CI Publish step's `Digest:` line), and the NOLOGIN runtime group role for dev (`aevolution`) and for stage (`aevolution_stage`). Then include `stores/<env>` in each environment's path. | M8.3, 2026-09-29 | Values pending | M8.3 in-cluster evidence |
| **Alert destination.** Alertmanager routes every alert to a null receiver (ADR-0072). Choose where alerts go (Discord, email, a webhook), and optionally a heartbeat receiver for the always-firing Watchdog. Receiver credentials go in a Secret. | M8.5, 2026-09-30 | The maintainer will decide later | Any claim that alerts reach a person; M8.6 alert evidence; World0 |
| **Kubelet log rotation check.** Confirm the RKE2 nodes' `container-log-max-size` and `container-log-max-files` (default 10Mi × 5), which bound region host logs (ADR-0072). | M8.5, 2026-09-30 | Needs node access | M8.6 |
| **M10 native-client observation.** M10's exit asks that the native client stay responsive against the authoritative server. The maintainer's observation moves to the later 2k drill (ADR-0097). | M10.9, 2026-10-09 | Drills paused by maintainer decision | Closing M10's exit evidence; the 2k drill |
| **Windows client cannot connect to the dev region.** On 2026-10-09 the client failed with "unreachable or certificate does not match". The default server name was wrong (fixed, `af156ab`), and the pod had been serving the certificate from before a CA renewal (restarted; `evo-session-probe` from the same machine was then welcomed). The client still failed afterwards; the cause is not yet known. | M10, 2026-10-09 | Maintainer: revisit later | The native-client observation above |
| **Storage after the RAID/disk rework.** Re-run `deploy/kubernetes/inventory/disk-probe-local-path.yaml` (or a new class), and update INVENTORY.md. | M8.1, 2026-09-29 | Maintainer is reorganizing disks | M8.3's final storage decision |
## Accepted risks (maintainer decisions)
+6
View File
@@ -587,6 +587,12 @@ M6 accounting contracts. Read GENOME_MODEL, ENERGY_MODEL and REPRODUCTION_MODEL.
Synthetic fixtures are test oracles, not accepted gameplay balance. Ratify the
offline lifecycle before enabling persistent player lives.
Status:
- 11.1's design decisions are accepted (ADR-0098, 2026-10-09). The time-based rate
migration (ADR-0089) is next.
- M10's exit evidence for native-client responsiveness is open (BACKLOG): the
maintainer's observation moves to the later 2k drill.
| ID / objective | Files/modules | Dependencies | Completion criteria | Tests / evidence | Risk |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 11.1 Ratify cellular life and design decisions | docs/biology, docs/networking, docs/adr | M10, founding requirements | Decide bounded first-loop movement/feeding/reproduction rules, mutation timing/cost and heredity; resolve reproduction-cost semantics from ADR-0031/0032; document offline freeze/resume fairness and friend recognition or explicit social-feature deferral | State diagrams, adversarial logout scenarios, worked energy/matter budgets, review against locked vision | Fixture behavior or convenience invents permanent game rules |
+22
View File
@@ -1,5 +1,27 @@
# Project status and next steps
## Current gate - 2026-10-09 (M11.1)
ADR-0098 records the maintainer's decisions for the first playable cellular loop:
- **Budding:** the parent keeps control and funds one wildlife bud.
- **Mutation:** earned during life, offered as seeded candidates and applied through
funded development.
- **Heredity:** exact copy; wildlife does not mutate in M11.
- **Logout:** biology freezes at once; the organism lingers, frozen but vulnerable, then
suspends.
- **Resume:** in place, or at the nearest valid spot within a bounded radius.
- **Feeding:** absorption and engulfment by a size ratio contested by membrane
thickness.
- **Birth cost:** a first bud fundable within a session (a tunable playtest target).
- **Friend recognition:** deferred.
Next is 11.1's ratified engineering half: migrating biological rates from per-tick to
time-based units (ADR-0089).
Open from M10 (BACKLOG):
- the maintainer's native-client observation, moved to the later 2k drill;
- the Windows client failing to connect to the dev region after a CA renewal.
## Current gate - 2026-10-03
M10.1 ratifies M10 timing and workload budgets (ADR-0089,
@@ -0,0 +1,182 @@
# ADR-0098: M11 first cellular loop decisions
## Status
Accepted for M11 (2026-10-09). M11.1 records these decisions; nothing is implemented
yet. The maintainer chose each one from presented options on 2026-10-09. They are game
rules for the first playable loop, and changing one needs a new decision.
Numeric values marked **tunable** are starting points for the 11.9 playtests. They are
not locked rules. Each one is a versioned rule constant, so a change goes through
simulation-version review (ADR-0089) and is recorded with its playtest evidence.
## Context
M11 turns the M2–M6 fixtures and the M10 session layer into repeated primitive-cell
lives (ROADMAP 11.1–11.9). The locked requirements come from the founding brief
(PROJECT_VISION): absolute permadeath, independent wildlife descendants, no offline
progression, no classes and no linear progression tree, biological costs, and shared
presentation for players and NPCs. Within those requirements, REPRODUCTION_MODEL,
GENOME_MODEL and OPEN_QUESTIONS left the first-loop rules open. The engineering
constitution forbids settling them in code. ADR-0089 already ratified time-based
biological rates, to be migrated in M11.1.
## Decision
### 1. Reproduction: budding
One accepted strategy, budding:
- The parent survives and keeps its life and control.
- It pays an explicit investment of matter and energy to build one descendant. The
investment is the ADR-0032 reproduction investment, priced at the parent's own
construction rate. Construction overhead goes to heat and waste, as in ADR-0028.
- The descendant is autonomous wildlife from its first tick. No account owns it and
nothing labels it.
Reproduction is an action under ADR-0092: it has a stable id, a durable outcome, and
duplicates resolve to the first outcome. The server decides prerequisites, cost,
placement and the child's genome; the client sends only the intention. An organism
that cannot fund the investment in every ledger channel is refused, and nothing is
spent. Abundant energy never pays for missing nitrogen. Placement capacity may refuse
or delay a bud, but it never grants a free or reduced one.
Binary fission, eggs, cohorts and spores stay open.
### 2. Mutation: earned during life, funded
A player's living organism can change its genome during its life:
- Eligibility is earned by surplus that has been fed and retained. The exact trigger
is part of 11.4's contract.
- The player is offered seeded candidates, using the M3.4 generator (ADR-0033): stable
context, no free rerolls, and stale offers rejected.
- A chosen candidate is applied through funded development (ADR-0031/0032). It
reserves and spends matter and energy for the change. It can fail for lack of
resources, and then nothing changes.
- Each applied mutation creates an immutable successor genome with ancestry (ADR-0030,
ADR-0034). The organism keeps its life id; only its genome revision advances.
There is no tree, no class and no guaranteed sequence. Offers are contextual, and every
candidate trades one cost against another.
### 3. Heredity: exact copy; wildlife does not mutate in M11
- A bud inherits its parent's current genome exactly at the moment of birth, and its
ancestry records the parent organism and genome revision.
- Wildlife never mutates on its own in M11. Open question 11 (NPC mutation) stays open
for M12. Lineages diverge in M11 only through mutations players choose before
budding.
### 4. Logout and disconnect: linger, then freeze
On a clean logout or a detected disconnect, the organism enters **SuspendPending**:
- Its biology freezes at once. It cannot move, feed, grow, mutate or reproduce.
Maintenance, gestation, construction and every other biological timer stop, because
an offline organism may never progress (locked).
- It stays in the world for a fixed linger time (**tunable**, starting at 10 s). During
that time it is perceivable and vulnerable: other organisms can engulf it, and lethal
outcomes apply.
- If it survives the linger time, it becomes **Suspended** durably and leaves the
world. Its inventory stays in global accounting and cannot interact.
- A reconnect during the linger time resumes it in place.
- A death decided before the freeze boundary is committed first (REPRODUCTION_MODEL
state diagram).
Lingering costs the organism nothing biologically and gains it nothing; it only stops
logging out from being an escape. Detection bounds for a disconnect (heartbeat and
timeout) are the session layer's: they reuse the M10 session timeouts and are stated
in 11.7's contract.
### 5. Resume: the same spot, else the nearest valid spot
A resume first replays any committed death, and a dead life never resumes. Then:
- The organism resumes at its frozen position if that position is still valid.
- Otherwise it resumes at the nearest valid position within a small bounded radius
(**tunable**, starting at a few cell diameters). It is never placed farther away:
there is no free travel.
- If no valid position exists within the radius, the life stays suspended and the
player is told why.
Resume performs no elapsed-time biology. It needs a unique control grant: two sessions
never resume the same life (ADR-0091).
### 6. Feeding and predation: absorb and engulf
- **Absorption.** A cell takes up environmental nutrients through surface contact, at
most at the genome's intake budget (ADR-0032), channel by channel. It takes only
what the environment holds (atomic transfers, ADR-0053).
- **Engulfment.** A cell can engulf a contacted cell that is sufficiently smaller.
- The size-ratio threshold is **tunable**, starting at 1.5 by mass.
- The prey's membrane thickness contests it: a thicker membrane raises the ratio
required, so defence is a built trait with a cost, not a percentage modifier.
- The engulfed cell dies. Its whole inventory moves to the predator exactly once,
bounded by the predator's capacity. Any excess becomes detritus at the contact
point, so nothing is destroyed or created.
- **Corpses.** A cell that dies another way leaves a corpse or detritus with its
inventory (ADR-0027, ADR-0056), and any cell can absorb it.
The server resolves contact, perception, motion and intake (11.3). Clients send only
movement and engulf intentions.
### 7. Birth cost: reachable within a session
GENOME_MODEL found that a birth can be funded within a plausible lifespan only near
the schema's minimum reproduction fraction. M11 re-derives the development-version
constants (ADR-0032) so a typical primitive cell can fund its first bud in roughly 5
to 15 minutes of competent feeding (**tunable**). This is a new development version
with migration and regression evidence, not an edit of the existing one. The target
is a playtest hypothesis, and 11.9 adjusts it.
### 8. Friend recognition: deferred
M11 has no friend mechanism. Players and wildlife look identical (locked shared
presentation). Open question 31 is deferred explicitly, to be revisited after the 11.9
playtests.
### Ratified earlier: time-based biological rates
Ratified in ADR-0089. M11.1 migrates per-tick genome and checkpoint rate fields to
time-based units, with deterministic per-tick conversion and explicit units,
precision, remainder carry, rounding and overflow bounds. Regression evidence must
show unchanged 50 ms behaviour where the version is unchanged.
## Scope
These decisions bound M11 only. Still open:
- binary fission, eggs, cohorts and spores;
- NPC mutation (open question 11) and speciation;
- recombination and multiple parents;
- how long suspension is retained, and what happens to the matter of a life suspended
indefinitely;
- friend recognition;
- evolvable behaviour.
Wildlife behaviour in M11 is a bounded, deterministic controller over the same
intentions players use (open question 33). It has no special biological rules.
## Alternatives considered
- **Reproduction.** Binary fission needs a rule for which half the player controls.
Spores and cohorts add cohort materialisation to the first loop.
- **Mutation.** Mutating only at reproduction would leave a life with no evolutionary
choices of its own. Mutating both during life and at reproduction would double the
rule surface before the first playtest.
- **Heredity.** Random inherited drift would settle NPC mutation now, without M12's
ecology evidence.
- **Logout.** An instant freeze makes logging out an escape from predation. Blocking
logout while engaged punishes clean exits and still freezes on a disconnect.
- **Feeding.** Absorption alone delays the predation pillar. Damage over contact adds a
combat model with more invented constants.
- **Birth cost.** A rare birth makes descendants nearly unobservable in a playtest.
Deferring the cost leaves budding effectively unreachable.
## Benefits
- **Little new rule surface.** Budding, the candidate generator, funded development and
the corpse transfers already exist as fixtures.
- **Conservation stays checkable.** Every change spends ledger channels, and engulfment
and corpses move inventories exactly once.
- **Offline fairness.** The locked rule holds even during the linger time, because
freezing happens before lingering.
## Costs and risks
- **Lingering can still be gamed.** A player could log out where nothing can reach
them. 11.7's tests cover this, and the linger time is tunable.
- **Mutation could look like progression.** Funded in-life mutation risks reading as a
progression system. Offers must stay contextual tradeoffs, and 11.4's tests check
that no candidate dominates.
- **Size could dominate predation.** Engulfment by size ratio may favour size; the
membrane contest and the cost of size (ADR-0032) are the counterweights, and 11.9
watches for monopoly.
- **Tunables could harden into rules.** Each tunable value is versioned and must be
changed with evidence, never silently.
## Consequences
- Updated: REPRODUCTION_MODEL and OPEN_QUESTIONS rows 7, 10, 14, 31 and 33.
- 11.2–11.7 implement against this ADR, and each states its own contract.
- The first implementation increment is the ratified time-based rate migration.
+1
View File
@@ -98,6 +98,7 @@ design. No unadopted candidate is a link dependency of the proof.
- [ADR-0084: Engineering UI toolkit](0084-engineering-ui-toolkit.md) - Dear ImGui 1.92.9b pinned (M9.8a) and integrated as the engineering client overlay with toolkit-first input routing (M9.8c).
- [ADR-0090: M10 QUIC transport](0090-m10-quic-transport.md) - msquic 2.6.2 with OpenSSL 3.5.9 LTS (TLS 1.3 only) from pinned sources on Windows and Linux; DATAGRAM frames for superseding state, streams for reliable actions; M9 TLS/TCP kept as dev fallback; owned impairment relay; exact CA pinning due in 10.2b.
- [ADR-0098: M11 first cellular loop decisions](0098-m11-first-cellular-loop-decisions.md) - maintainer decisions for the first playable loop: budding (parent keeps control, one funded wildlife bud); funded in-life mutation from seeded candidates; exact-copy heredity with no NPC mutation in M11; logout lingers frozen but vulnerable, then suspends; resume in place or nearest valid spot within a bounded radius; absorption plus engulfment by contested size ratio; birth reachable within a session (tunable); friend recognition deferred.
- [ADR-0097: M10 load and abuse qualification](0097-m10-load-and-abuse-qualification.md) - only evolution-dev reference-worker runs qualify; one multi-client evo-load tool with per-client distributions; a load governor over per-tick work (p95 window of 40 ticks) and tick debt refuses grant logins, then sheds replication radius and cadence in 3 levels with hysteresis (tickets still admitted); abuse suite of fuzz, floods, slow peers, storms and lease loss.
- [ADR-0096: M10 probe handoff](0096-m10-probe-handoff.md) - EXPERIMENT durable probe records with one owning region and a conserved test inventory; fenced prepared/staged/committed/aborted transfers; signed single-use transfer tickets; protocol v4 offers, redirects and ghosts; recovery sweep (schema v14) and replay guard proven by a two-process fault matrix.
- [ADR-0095: M10 interpolation and session loss](0095-m10-interpolation-and-session-loss.md) - drift-corrected client tick clock, adaptive 2-6 tick interpolation of remote markers with at most 2 ticks of extrapolation (organisms never), frozen stale view on loss and a fresh baseline on reconnect.
+5 -5
View File
@@ -12,14 +12,14 @@ person. ADR indexes distinguish scoped proof choices from production proposals.
| 4 | Dependency manager | Evaluate vcpkg manifest vs Conan; no runtime dependency for proof | Build; first dependency |
| 5 | Units library | Minimal explicit integer wrappers now; evaluate dimensional library before biology | Simulation; M2 |
| 6 | Determinism | Exact integer proof; physics separately scoped | Simulation; each system ADR |
| 7 | Mutation generation | Seeded context-conditioned candidates with validated prerequisites | Biology/design; M3/M11 |
| 7 | Mutation generation | Seeded context-conditioned candidates with validated prerequisites. M11: earned during life, offered from seeded candidates and applied through funded development (ADR-0098); candidate count and the eligibility trigger come in 11.4's contract | Biology/design; M3/M11 |
| 8 | Genome representation | Immutable versioned developmental capabilities, not DNA | Biology; M3 |
| 9 | Developmental body | Typed body graph proposal | Biology/engine; M13 |
| 10 | Heredity/reproductive mutation | Preserve ancestry, define mutation budget and costs | Biology/design; M3/M11 |
| 10 | Heredity/reproductive mutation | M11 (ADR-0098): budding; a bud copies its parent's current genome exactly, with ancestry; no mutation at birth. Recombination stays open | Biology/design; M3/M11 |
| 11 | NPC mutation | Undecided; no silent autonomous divergence | Biology/design; M12 |
| 12 | Species/speciation | Derived classifications; no class mechanics | Biology/design; M12 |
| 13 | Lineage extinction | Need world-wide no-living/no-viable-reserve evidence | Ecology; M4/M12 |
| 14 | Offline state | Park without any progression; disconnect fairness unresolved | Design/security; before player persistence |
| 14 | Offline state | M11 (ADR-0098): biology freezes at once on logout or a detected disconnect; the organism lingers in the world, frozen but vulnerable (tunable, 10 s), then suspends durably; resume in place or at the nearest valid spot within a bounded radius, else it stays suspended. How long suspension is retained stays open | Design/security; before player persistence |
| 15 | Multicellular transition | Physiological and ecological criteria unresolved | Design/biology; M14 |
| 16 | Population abstraction | Conservative cohort ledger + distributions, ensemble validation | Ecology; M4 |
| 17 | Region dimensions | Benchmark against interest, entities and migration overhead | Engine/platform; M7 |
@@ -36,9 +36,9 @@ person. ADR indexes distinguish scoped proof choices from production proposals.
| 28 | Recovery | Committed contiguous replay range and unique epoch | Persistence; M7/M8 |
| 29 | Cross-version migration | Clone, migrate, accelerated comparison, approved world barrier | Simulation/platform; M7+ |
| 30 | Steam identity | Provider subject → internal account boundary | Backend/security; before Steam |
| 31 | Friend recognition | Separate social channel, no player/NPC labels | Design; M11 |
| 31 | Friend recognition | Deferred explicitly for M11 (ADR-0098); revisit after the 11.9 playtests. No player/NPC labels | Design; after M11.9 |
| 32 | Anti-cheat | Authoritative outcomes plus authenticated bounded intentions | Security; M10 |
| 33 | AI behavior | Shared intention interface; bounded deterministic controller | Simulation; M2/M11 |
| 33 | AI behavior | Shared intention interface; bounded deterministic controller. M11 wildlife uses the same intentions as players, with no special biological rules (ADR-0098) | Simulation; M2/M11 |
| 34 | Evolvable behavior | Undecided; intelligence not mandatory | Biology/design; M12/R&D |
| 35 | Morphology limits | Development graph validates material, attachment and capability | Biology/design; M13 |
| 36 | Procedural animation | Isolated locomotion prototypes; no authored animation dependence | Engine; M13 |
+17
View File
@@ -79,6 +79,23 @@ preserves every timer; same-tick death/reproduction ordering; huge spore request
all suspend/resume crash points; changed habitat; unique control grants and
death committed after snapshot. Extinction includes suspended viability.
## M11 decisions (ADR-0098)
The maintainer accepted these for the first playable loop (2026-10-09):
- **Budding.** The parent keeps its life and control, and funds one wildlife bud at
its construction rate.
- **Heredity.** A bud copies its parent's current genome exactly. Wildlife does not
mutate in M11.
- **Mutation.** Mutations are earned and applied during life through funded
development.
- **Logout.** On logout or a detected disconnect, biology freezes at once. The organism
lingers frozen but vulnerable, then suspends.
- **Resume.** In place, or at the nearest valid spot within a bounded radius; otherwise
the life stays suspended.
Fission, eggs, cohorts, spores, NPC mutation, and how long suspension is retained stay
open. The values marked tunable are playtest hypotheses, not locked rules.
## Implemented M2.5 fixture boundary
[ADR-0028](../adr/0028-funded-reproduction.md) implements funded budding inside