diff --git a/docs/STATUS.md b/docs/STATUS.md index fbaf348..0c9e371 100644 --- a/docs/STATUS.md +++ b/docs/STATUS.md @@ -11,6 +11,11 @@ open M11 product review and M12.2 population qualification prerequisites. Automatic tier selection remains disabled; 12.3-12.5 cannot proceed on M4's failed aggregation model. +12.2a reproduces all 15 historical scenarios, including eight false extinctions +and zero qualified widths; Release CTest passed 69/69. See +[population qualification](engineering/M12_POPULATION_QUALIFICATION.md). +M12.2 remains open; no production aggregation or unattended scheduling was added. + ## Client update - 2026-10-14 (v10) The desktop cellular client now negotiates v10, exposes mutations with funded diff --git a/docs/engineering/AGGREGATE_BUDGET.md b/docs/engineering/AGGREGATE_BUDGET.md index 1f9f133..02c579c 100644 --- a/docs/engineering/AGGREGATE_BUDGET.md +++ b/docs/engineering/AGGREGATE_BUDGET.md @@ -1,5 +1,9 @@ # M4.6 aggregate budget and sensitivity report +2026-10-15: [M12.2a](M12_POPULATION_QUALIFICATION.md) independently reproduces all +historical non-timing sensitivity/policy results, including eight false-extinction +scenarios and zero qualified widths. The original data below is preserved. + ## Decision M4.6 measurement work is complete; automatic tier selection remains **disabled**. None of the tested resolutions meets the provisional research gate in ADR-0041. diff --git a/docs/engineering/M12_DELIVERY_PLAN.md b/docs/engineering/M12_DELIVERY_PLAN.md index d78df0f..ffd5cf9 100644 --- a/docs/engineering/M12_DELIVERY_PLAN.md +++ b/docs/engineering/M12_DELIVERY_PLAN.md @@ -9,7 +9,7 @@ Commit and push each validated scoped segment separately. | Subset | State | Evidence or condition for completion | |---|---|---| | 12.1 | Engineering evidence policy and explicit deferrals documented | ADR-0133, identity/time contract and worked histories; no new game rules or runtime versions. | -| 12.2 | Qualification open; automatic tier selection disabled | ADR-0041 rejects every tested width. Reproduce failures, then qualify a model against M11 cellular rules with hold-outs and target-host budgets. | +| 12.2 | Baseline reproduction complete (12.2a); qualification open | All 15 scenarios reproduce the historical results, including eight false extinctions; zero widths qualify. See M12_POPULATION_QUALIFICATION. A model against M11 rules, hold-outs and target-host budgets remains required. | | 12.3 | Blocked on 12.2 | No accepted population model, deterministic durable conversion sample or profile integrating cellular/cohort state. | | 12.4 | Blocked on 12.2-12.3 | Existing cellular worker pauses without sessions/lingering players; bounded unattended recovery and biological migration escrow remain unimplemented. | | 12.5 | Blocked on 12.2-12.4 | Finite M6 process fixtures do not qualify coupled persistent cellular/cohort atmosphere/water budgets. | @@ -19,6 +19,10 @@ M12's roadmap entry also requires the M11 playable-loop product review. The sign-in playtest, but no completed repeated-life results or product acceptance. Beginning policy work does not fabricate that acceptance. +Executed 12.2a results and remaining limits: +[M12_POPULATION_QUALIFICATION](M12_POPULATION_QUALIFICATION.md). Release CTest +passed 69/69 outside the filesystem sandbox. No production model was adopted. + ## Architectural conflict and resolution Automatic transitions or regional aggregation now would conflict with ADR-0041 diff --git a/docs/engineering/M12_POPULATION_QUALIFICATION.md b/docs/engineering/M12_POPULATION_QUALIFICATION.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..7c4f11c --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/engineering/M12_POPULATION_QUALIFICATION.md @@ -0,0 +1,77 @@ +# M12.2 population qualification: baseline reproduction + +## Result (2026-10-15) + +M12.2a reproduces the rejected M4.6 baseline without modifying its model or +historical results. All 15 sensitivity records and five policy records exactly +match the historical non-timing output. Eight scenarios exhibit false extinction; +zero widths qualify. **M12.2 is not complete. Automatic tier selection remains +disabled, and M12.3-12.5 implementation is blocked on qualification.** + +Raw run: [m12-2-baseline-msvc1944.jsonl](results/m12-2-baseline-msvc1944.jsonl). +Historical method and full error matrix: +[AGGREGATE_BUDGET](AGGREGATE_BUDGET.md), ADR-0040/0041. Fixture version 2, +100 founders, 10,000 ticks, widths 10/25/50/100/200, energy supplies 240/300/360, +no randomness. Every run checks exact energy/matter conservation at every tick. +The executable's successful exit validates its arithmetic/instrument; it does +not mean that any reported fidelity gate passed. + +## Execution and costs + +Executed on the local Windows x64 development host with MSVC 19.44 Release +(`/O2`, `NDEBUG`), using the checked-in `release` preset and +`tools/windows-check.ps1 -Preset release -Action check`. Processor identifier: +`AMD64 Family 26 Model 68 Stepping 0, AuthenticAMD`. Hardware model retrieval +through CIM was denied in the sandbox; this is not target-host qualification. +No affinity or frequency lock was applied. + +```powershell +./tools/windows-check.ps1 -Preset release -Action check +./build/release/evo-resolution-benchmark.exe | + Set-Content -Encoding utf8 docs/engineering/results/m12-2-baseline-msvc1944.jsonl +``` + +Warmup plus three fresh measured repetitions; baseline supply 300 median time for +10,000 ticks follows. These are uncontrolled local observations, not capacity bounds. + +| Age width | Individual ms | Aggregate ms | False extinction at supply 300 | +|---|---:|---:|---| +| 10 | 30.084 | 0.241 | no | +| 25 | 30.616 | 0.055 | yes | +| 50 | 29.853 | 0.131 | no | +| 100 | 30.407 | 0.045 | yes | +| 200 | 28.648 | 0.046 | yes | + +Small elapsed times for empty aggregates cannot count as useful throughput. +All original methodological limitations remain: dead individual rows are retained, +temporary scratch/allocator overhead and RSS are excluded, conversions are outside +timings, and there is one genome with abundant matter and no cellular space, +predation or M11 controller. This deterministic fixture has no hold-out seeds; +it cannot establish multi-genome diversity bounds or M11 demographic fidelity. + +## Checks and limits + +- Release configure/build passed with warnings-as-errors. The sandboxed CTest run + passed 67/69; `world-local-files-contracts` and `cli-file-integration` failed + where the sandbox denied filesystem hard-link fixtures. Repeating Release CTest + outside the sandbox passed **69/69**, with no source or test changes. +- Parsed every JSONL record; checked 15 sensitivity and five policy records; + compared every non-timing field in those 20 records against the retained + `resolution-budget-msvc1944.jsonl`. Exact match. Eight false-extinction cases, + zero accepted widths. The historical baseline was preserved. +- No C++ changes or candidate model were introduced. clang-format, clang-tidy + and sanitizers were not rerun for documentation/raw measurement output. +- A sandboxed `wsl --list --quiet` returned `Wsl/E_ACCESSDENIED`. No new Linux, + R730xd, PostgreSQL, worker-recovery, migration or World0 validation is claimed. +- M11 repeated-life product acceptance is not recorded. The first sign-in feedback + and engineering suite cannot stand in for that human review. + +## Resolution before dependent implementation + +Follow the [M12 delivery plan](M12_DELIVERY_PLAN.md): separately version a candidate, +predeclare trajectory/demographic/biomass/diversity bounds and held-out seeds/regimes, +retain within-cohort viable variation, compare against M11 cellular rules, exercise +bin/interval sensitivity and measure complete region/conversion/fallback costs on +the Linux target host. Unsupported states stay active only within a measured budget; +capacity refusal uses explicit backpressure, never culling or silent skipped work. +No numerical production error budget or fallback capacity is accepted by this run. diff --git a/docs/engineering/VALIDATION.md b/docs/engineering/VALIDATION.md index 552a92b..e479997 100644 --- a/docs/engineering/VALIDATION.md +++ b/docs/engineering/VALIDATION.md @@ -1,5 +1,24 @@ # Validation report +## 2026-10-15 - M12.2a rejected baseline reproduction + +No C++ changes. MSVC 19.44 `release` configure/build passed. Sandboxed CTest was +67/69 with filesystem fixture denials; outside-sandbox Release CTest passed +69/69 without source changes. Ran `evo-resolution-benchmark.exe` with timings: +15 sensitivity and five policy records exactly match historical non-timing +fields; eight false extinctions, zero qualified widths. Checked JSON parsing, +matrix size and `git diff --check`. Full method, local costs and raw output: +[M12_POPULATION_QUALIFICATION](M12_POPULATION_QUALIFICATION.md). + +Sandbox denied CIM hardware retrieval and WSL enumeration. No new Linux or target +host evidence, model repair, multi-genome/seed qualification, active fallback +budget, durable automatic tier, unattended worker or regional atmosphere/water +validation. M12.2 remains open; 12.3-12.5 stay blocked under ADR-0041 and the +constitution. M11 product acceptance is also unrecorded. No clang-format/tidy or +sanitizer rerun for these documentation/measurement-only changes. Unrelated +untracked files were preserved. The M12.1 push failed remote authentication; +credentials must be refreshed before the pending commits can be pushed. + ## 2026-10-15 - M12.1 identity and time evidence Documentation-only segment: ADR-0133, ecological identity/time policy, semantic diff --git a/docs/engineering/results/m12-2-baseline-msvc1944.jsonl b/docs/engineering/results/m12-2-baseline-msvc1944.jsonl new file mode 100644 index 0000000..dc83f3a --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/engineering/results/m12-2-baseline-msvc1944.jsonl @@ -0,0 +1,111 @@ +{"kind":"metadata","model":"resolution-fixture-2","founders":100,"ticks":10000,"randomness":"none","warmups":1,"samples":3,"compiler":"MSVC 1944","build":"release"} +{"kind":"sensitivity","supply":240,"width":10,"individual_living":108,"aggregate_living":120,"population_gap_ppt":100,"energy_gap_ppt":127,"matter_gap_ppt":346,"max_population_gap_ppt":725,"max_energy_gap_ppt":650,"max_matter_gap_ppt":932,"false_extinction":false,"research_gate_pass":false} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":240,"width":10,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":139800,"peak_rows":6,"peak_payload_bytes":240,"peak_capacity_bytes":240,"living":120,"energy":6000,"matter_per_channel":134340} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":240,"width":10,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":27913500,"peak_rows":2471,"peak_payload_bytes":79072,"peak_capacity_bytes":81696,"living":108,"energy":6875,"matter_per_channel":87828} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":240,"width":10,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":27497300,"peak_rows":2471,"peak_payload_bytes":79072,"peak_capacity_bytes":81696,"living":108,"energy":6875,"matter_per_channel":87828} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":240,"width":10,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":139300,"peak_rows":6,"peak_payload_bytes":240,"peak_capacity_bytes":240,"living":120,"energy":6000,"matter_per_channel":134340} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":240,"width":10,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":141100,"peak_rows":6,"peak_payload_bytes":240,"peak_capacity_bytes":240,"living":120,"energy":6000,"matter_per_channel":134340} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":240,"width":10,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":27761600,"peak_rows":2471,"peak_payload_bytes":79072,"peak_capacity_bytes":81696,"living":108,"energy":6875,"matter_per_channel":87828} +{"kind":"sensitivity","supply":300,"width":10,"individual_living":75,"aggregate_living":100,"population_gap_ppt":250,"energy_gap_ppt":24,"matter_gap_ppt":724,"max_population_gap_ppt":530,"max_energy_gap_ppt":485,"max_matter_gap_ppt":935,"false_extinction":false,"research_gate_pass":false} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":300,"width":10,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":241000,"peak_rows":7,"peak_payload_bytes":280,"peak_capacity_bytes":360,"living":100,"energy":6120,"matter_per_channel":14360} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":300,"width":10,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":30429700,"peak_rows":2625,"peak_payload_bytes":84000,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":75,"energy":6275,"matter_per_channel":52115} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":300,"width":10,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":30084200,"peak_rows":2625,"peak_payload_bytes":84000,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":75,"energy":6275,"matter_per_channel":52115} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":300,"width":10,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":247900,"peak_rows":7,"peak_payload_bytes":280,"peak_capacity_bytes":360,"living":100,"energy":6120,"matter_per_channel":14360} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":300,"width":10,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":241500,"peak_rows":7,"peak_payload_bytes":280,"peak_capacity_bytes":360,"living":100,"energy":6120,"matter_per_channel":14360} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":300,"width":10,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":28594900,"peak_rows":2625,"peak_payload_bytes":84000,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":75,"energy":6275,"matter_per_channel":52115} +{"kind":"sensitivity","supply":360,"width":10,"individual_living":130,"aggregate_living":130,"population_gap_ppt":0,"energy_gap_ppt":34,"matter_gap_ppt":531,"max_population_gap_ppt":400,"max_energy_gap_ppt":501,"max_matter_gap_ppt":923,"false_extinction":false,"research_gate_pass":false} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":360,"width":10,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":191400,"peak_rows":8,"peak_payload_bytes":320,"peak_capacity_bytes":360,"living":130,"energy":6800,"matter_per_channel":104940} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":360,"width":10,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":35238200,"peak_rows":3156,"peak_payload_bytes":100992,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":130,"energy":7040,"matter_per_channel":49113} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":360,"width":10,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":36316400,"peak_rows":3156,"peak_payload_bytes":100992,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":130,"energy":7040,"matter_per_channel":49113} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":360,"width":10,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":193800,"peak_rows":8,"peak_payload_bytes":320,"peak_capacity_bytes":360,"living":130,"energy":6800,"matter_per_channel":104940} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":360,"width":10,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":191800,"peak_rows":8,"peak_payload_bytes":320,"peak_capacity_bytes":360,"living":130,"energy":6800,"matter_per_channel":104940} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":360,"width":10,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":34107500,"peak_rows":3156,"peak_payload_bytes":100992,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":130,"energy":7040,"matter_per_channel":49113} +{"kind":"policy","width":10,"passes_all_scenarios":false} +{"kind":"sensitivity","supply":240,"width":25,"individual_living":108,"aggregate_living":100,"population_gap_ppt":74,"energy_gap_ppt":272,"matter_gap_ppt":189,"max_population_gap_ppt":580,"max_energy_gap_ppt":718,"max_matter_gap_ppt":923,"false_extinction":false,"research_gate_pass":false} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":240,"width":25,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":127300,"peak_rows":3,"peak_payload_bytes":120,"peak_capacity_bytes":120,"living":100,"energy":5000,"matter_per_channel":71150} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":240,"width":25,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":27173100,"peak_rows":2471,"peak_payload_bytes":79072,"peak_capacity_bytes":81696,"living":108,"energy":6875,"matter_per_channel":87828} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":240,"width":25,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":27811700,"peak_rows":2471,"peak_payload_bytes":79072,"peak_capacity_bytes":81696,"living":108,"energy":6875,"matter_per_channel":87828} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":240,"width":25,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":127900,"peak_rows":3,"peak_payload_bytes":120,"peak_capacity_bytes":120,"living":100,"energy":5000,"matter_per_channel":71150} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":240,"width":25,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":124200,"peak_rows":3,"peak_payload_bytes":120,"peak_capacity_bytes":120,"living":100,"energy":5000,"matter_per_channel":71150} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":240,"width":25,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":27223500,"peak_rows":2471,"peak_payload_bytes":79072,"peak_capacity_bytes":81696,"living":108,"energy":6875,"matter_per_channel":87828} +{"kind":"sensitivity","supply":300,"width":25,"individual_living":75,"aggregate_living":0,"population_gap_ppt":1000,"energy_gap_ppt":1000,"matter_gap_ppt":1000,"max_population_gap_ppt":1000,"max_energy_gap_ppt":1000,"max_matter_gap_ppt":1000,"false_extinction":true,"research_gate_pass":false} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":300,"width":25,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":54100,"peak_rows":4,"peak_payload_bytes":160,"peak_capacity_bytes":160,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":300,"width":25,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":30572800,"peak_rows":2625,"peak_payload_bytes":84000,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":75,"energy":6275,"matter_per_channel":52115} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":300,"width":25,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":30936200,"peak_rows":2625,"peak_payload_bytes":84000,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":75,"energy":6275,"matter_per_channel":52115} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":300,"width":25,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":55500,"peak_rows":4,"peak_payload_bytes":160,"peak_capacity_bytes":160,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":300,"width":25,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":54600,"peak_rows":4,"peak_payload_bytes":160,"peak_capacity_bytes":160,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":300,"width":25,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":30616200,"peak_rows":2625,"peak_payload_bytes":84000,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":75,"energy":6275,"matter_per_channel":52115} +{"kind":"sensitivity","supply":360,"width":25,"individual_living":130,"aggregate_living":130,"population_gap_ppt":0,"energy_gap_ppt":151,"matter_gap_ppt":657,"max_population_gap_ppt":435,"max_energy_gap_ppt":528,"max_matter_gap_ppt":915,"false_extinction":false,"research_gate_pass":false} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":360,"width":25,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":168300,"peak_rows":4,"peak_payload_bytes":160,"peak_capacity_bytes":160,"living":130,"energy":8300,"matter_per_channel":143460} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":360,"width":25,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":35811500,"peak_rows":3156,"peak_payload_bytes":100992,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":130,"energy":7040,"matter_per_channel":49113} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":360,"width":25,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":34374800,"peak_rows":3156,"peak_payload_bytes":100992,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":130,"energy":7040,"matter_per_channel":49113} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":360,"width":25,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":173400,"peak_rows":4,"peak_payload_bytes":160,"peak_capacity_bytes":160,"living":130,"energy":8300,"matter_per_channel":143460} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":360,"width":25,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":168300,"peak_rows":4,"peak_payload_bytes":160,"peak_capacity_bytes":160,"living":130,"energy":8300,"matter_per_channel":143460} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":360,"width":25,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":36219800,"peak_rows":3156,"peak_payload_bytes":100992,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":130,"energy":7040,"matter_per_channel":49113} +{"kind":"policy","width":25,"passes_all_scenarios":false} +{"kind":"sensitivity","supply":240,"width":50,"individual_living":108,"aggregate_living":0,"population_gap_ppt":1000,"energy_gap_ppt":1000,"matter_gap_ppt":1000,"max_population_gap_ppt":1000,"max_energy_gap_ppt":1000,"max_matter_gap_ppt":1000,"false_extinction":true,"research_gate_pass":false} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":240,"width":50,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":43000,"peak_rows":2,"peak_payload_bytes":80,"peak_capacity_bytes":80,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":240,"width":50,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":27712100,"peak_rows":2471,"peak_payload_bytes":79072,"peak_capacity_bytes":81696,"living":108,"energy":6875,"matter_per_channel":87828} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":240,"width":50,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":26950900,"peak_rows":2471,"peak_payload_bytes":79072,"peak_capacity_bytes":81696,"living":108,"energy":6875,"matter_per_channel":87828} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":240,"width":50,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":42900,"peak_rows":2,"peak_payload_bytes":80,"peak_capacity_bytes":80,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":240,"width":50,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":42500,"peak_rows":2,"peak_payload_bytes":80,"peak_capacity_bytes":80,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":240,"width":50,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":26910000,"peak_rows":2471,"peak_payload_bytes":79072,"peak_capacity_bytes":81696,"living":108,"energy":6875,"matter_per_channel":87828} +{"kind":"sensitivity","supply":300,"width":50,"individual_living":75,"aggregate_living":120,"population_gap_ppt":375,"energy_gap_ppt":43,"matter_gap_ppt":35,"max_population_gap_ppt":868,"max_energy_gap_ppt":977,"max_matter_gap_ppt":943,"false_extinction":false,"research_gate_pass":false} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":300,"width":50,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":130000,"peak_rows":3,"peak_payload_bytes":120,"peak_capacity_bytes":120,"living":120,"energy":6000,"matter_per_channel":54060} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":300,"width":50,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":29058000,"peak_rows":2625,"peak_payload_bytes":84000,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":75,"energy":6275,"matter_per_channel":52115} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":300,"width":50,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":29852800,"peak_rows":2625,"peak_payload_bytes":84000,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":75,"energy":6275,"matter_per_channel":52115} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":300,"width":50,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":130500,"peak_rows":3,"peak_payload_bytes":120,"peak_capacity_bytes":120,"living":120,"energy":6000,"matter_per_channel":54060} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":300,"width":50,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":130700,"peak_rows":3,"peak_payload_bytes":120,"peak_capacity_bytes":120,"living":120,"energy":6000,"matter_per_channel":54060} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":300,"width":50,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":30554500,"peak_rows":2625,"peak_payload_bytes":84000,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":75,"energy":6275,"matter_per_channel":52115} +{"kind":"sensitivity","supply":360,"width":50,"individual_living":130,"aggregate_living":180,"population_gap_ppt":277,"energy_gap_ppt":217,"matter_gap_ppt":589,"max_population_gap_ppt":561,"max_energy_gap_ppt":772,"max_matter_gap_ppt":934,"false_extinction":false,"research_gate_pass":false} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":360,"width":50,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":126400,"peak_rows":3,"peak_payload_bytes":120,"peak_capacity_bytes":120,"living":180,"energy":9000,"matter_per_channel":119700} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":360,"width":50,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":38851700,"peak_rows":3156,"peak_payload_bytes":100992,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":130,"energy":7040,"matter_per_channel":49113} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":360,"width":50,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":35809200,"peak_rows":3156,"peak_payload_bytes":100992,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":130,"energy":7040,"matter_per_channel":49113} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":360,"width":50,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":184000,"peak_rows":3,"peak_payload_bytes":120,"peak_capacity_bytes":120,"living":180,"energy":9000,"matter_per_channel":119700} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":360,"width":50,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":160500,"peak_rows":3,"peak_payload_bytes":120,"peak_capacity_bytes":120,"living":180,"energy":9000,"matter_per_channel":119700} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":360,"width":50,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":35709800,"peak_rows":3156,"peak_payload_bytes":100992,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":130,"energy":7040,"matter_per_channel":49113} +{"kind":"policy","width":50,"passes_all_scenarios":false} +{"kind":"sensitivity","supply":240,"width":100,"individual_living":108,"aggregate_living":0,"population_gap_ppt":1000,"energy_gap_ppt":1000,"matter_gap_ppt":1000,"max_population_gap_ppt":1000,"max_energy_gap_ppt":1000,"max_matter_gap_ppt":1000,"false_extinction":true,"research_gate_pass":false} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":240,"width":100,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":40900,"peak_rows":1,"peak_payload_bytes":40,"peak_capacity_bytes":40,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":240,"width":100,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":27612300,"peak_rows":2471,"peak_payload_bytes":79072,"peak_capacity_bytes":81696,"living":108,"energy":6875,"matter_per_channel":87828} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":240,"width":100,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":27555700,"peak_rows":2471,"peak_payload_bytes":79072,"peak_capacity_bytes":81696,"living":108,"energy":6875,"matter_per_channel":87828} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":240,"width":100,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":41500,"peak_rows":1,"peak_payload_bytes":40,"peak_capacity_bytes":40,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":240,"width":100,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":40700,"peak_rows":1,"peak_payload_bytes":40,"peak_capacity_bytes":40,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":240,"width":100,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":27838700,"peak_rows":2471,"peak_payload_bytes":79072,"peak_capacity_bytes":81696,"living":108,"energy":6875,"matter_per_channel":87828} +{"kind":"sensitivity","supply":300,"width":100,"individual_living":75,"aggregate_living":0,"population_gap_ppt":1000,"energy_gap_ppt":1000,"matter_gap_ppt":1000,"max_population_gap_ppt":1000,"max_energy_gap_ppt":1000,"max_matter_gap_ppt":1000,"false_extinction":true,"research_gate_pass":false} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":300,"width":100,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":45200,"peak_rows":2,"peak_payload_bytes":80,"peak_capacity_bytes":80,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":300,"width":100,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":30407200,"peak_rows":2625,"peak_payload_bytes":84000,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":75,"energy":6275,"matter_per_channel":52115} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":300,"width":100,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":29985600,"peak_rows":2625,"peak_payload_bytes":84000,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":75,"energy":6275,"matter_per_channel":52115} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":300,"width":100,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":45600,"peak_rows":2,"peak_payload_bytes":80,"peak_capacity_bytes":80,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":300,"width":100,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":45000,"peak_rows":2,"peak_payload_bytes":80,"peak_capacity_bytes":80,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":300,"width":100,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":30774300,"peak_rows":2625,"peak_payload_bytes":84000,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":75,"energy":6275,"matter_per_channel":52115} +{"kind":"sensitivity","supply":360,"width":100,"individual_living":130,"aggregate_living":0,"population_gap_ppt":1000,"energy_gap_ppt":1000,"matter_gap_ppt":1000,"max_population_gap_ppt":1000,"max_energy_gap_ppt":1000,"max_matter_gap_ppt":1000,"false_extinction":true,"research_gate_pass":false} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":360,"width":100,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":50700,"peak_rows":2,"peak_payload_bytes":80,"peak_capacity_bytes":80,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":360,"width":100,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":34249600,"peak_rows":3156,"peak_payload_bytes":100992,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":130,"energy":7040,"matter_per_channel":49113} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":360,"width":100,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":34185500,"peak_rows":3156,"peak_payload_bytes":100992,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":130,"energy":7040,"matter_per_channel":49113} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":360,"width":100,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":45900,"peak_rows":2,"peak_payload_bytes":80,"peak_capacity_bytes":80,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":360,"width":100,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":44900,"peak_rows":2,"peak_payload_bytes":80,"peak_capacity_bytes":80,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":360,"width":100,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":34752500,"peak_rows":3156,"peak_payload_bytes":100992,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":130,"energy":7040,"matter_per_channel":49113} +{"kind":"policy","width":100,"passes_all_scenarios":false} +{"kind":"sensitivity","supply":240,"width":200,"individual_living":108,"aggregate_living":0,"population_gap_ppt":1000,"energy_gap_ppt":1000,"matter_gap_ppt":1000,"max_population_gap_ppt":1000,"max_energy_gap_ppt":1000,"max_matter_gap_ppt":1000,"false_extinction":true,"research_gate_pass":false} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":240,"width":200,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":40500,"peak_rows":1,"peak_payload_bytes":40,"peak_capacity_bytes":40,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":240,"width":200,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":27785400,"peak_rows":2471,"peak_payload_bytes":79072,"peak_capacity_bytes":81696,"living":108,"energy":6875,"matter_per_channel":87828} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":240,"width":200,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":28468300,"peak_rows":2471,"peak_payload_bytes":79072,"peak_capacity_bytes":81696,"living":108,"energy":6875,"matter_per_channel":87828} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":240,"width":200,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":41000,"peak_rows":1,"peak_payload_bytes":40,"peak_capacity_bytes":40,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":240,"width":200,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":40900,"peak_rows":1,"peak_payload_bytes":40,"peak_capacity_bytes":40,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":240,"width":200,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":27971700,"peak_rows":2471,"peak_payload_bytes":79072,"peak_capacity_bytes":81696,"living":108,"energy":6875,"matter_per_channel":87828} +{"kind":"sensitivity","supply":300,"width":200,"individual_living":75,"aggregate_living":0,"population_gap_ppt":1000,"energy_gap_ppt":1000,"matter_gap_ppt":1000,"max_population_gap_ppt":1000,"max_energy_gap_ppt":1000,"max_matter_gap_ppt":1000,"false_extinction":true,"research_gate_pass":false} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":300,"width":200,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":48300,"peak_rows":2,"peak_payload_bytes":80,"peak_capacity_bytes":80,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":300,"width":200,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":31002600,"peak_rows":2625,"peak_payload_bytes":84000,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":75,"energy":6275,"matter_per_channel":52115} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":300,"width":200,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":28647500,"peak_rows":2625,"peak_payload_bytes":84000,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":75,"energy":6275,"matter_per_channel":52115} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":300,"width":200,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":46500,"peak_rows":2,"peak_payload_bytes":80,"peak_capacity_bytes":80,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":300,"width":200,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":45300,"peak_rows":2,"peak_payload_bytes":80,"peak_capacity_bytes":80,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":300,"width":200,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":28539100,"peak_rows":2625,"peak_payload_bytes":84000,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":75,"energy":6275,"matter_per_channel":52115} +{"kind":"sensitivity","supply":360,"width":200,"individual_living":130,"aggregate_living":0,"population_gap_ppt":1000,"energy_gap_ppt":1000,"matter_gap_ppt":1000,"max_population_gap_ppt":1000,"max_energy_gap_ppt":1000,"max_matter_gap_ppt":1000,"false_extinction":true,"research_gate_pass":false} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":360,"width":200,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":46200,"peak_rows":2,"peak_payload_bytes":80,"peak_capacity_bytes":80,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":360,"width":200,"sample":1,"elapsed_ns":35718900,"peak_rows":3156,"peak_payload_bytes":100992,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":130,"energy":7040,"matter_per_channel":49113} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":360,"width":200,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":35891300,"peak_rows":3156,"peak_payload_bytes":100992,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":130,"energy":7040,"matter_per_channel":49113} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":360,"width":200,"sample":2,"elapsed_ns":46700,"peak_rows":2,"peak_payload_bytes":80,"peak_capacity_bytes":80,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"aggregate","supply":360,"width":200,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":47100,"peak_rows":2,"peak_payload_bytes":80,"peak_capacity_bytes":80,"living":0,"energy":0,"matter_per_channel":0} +{"kind":"timing","tier":"individual","supply":360,"width":200,"sample":3,"elapsed_ns":36257600,"peak_rows":3156,"peak_payload_bytes":100992,"peak_capacity_bytes":122528,"living":130,"energy":7040,"matter_per_channel":49113} +{"kind":"policy","width":200,"passes_all_scenarios":false}