# M4.6 aggregate budget and sensitivity report 2026-10-15: [M12.2a](M12_POPULATION_QUALIFICATION.md) independently reproduces all historical non-timing sensitivity/policy results, including eight false-extinction scenarios and zero qualified widths. The original data below is preserved. ## Decision M4.6 measurement work is complete; automatic tier selection remains **disabled**. None of the tested resolutions meets the provisional research gate in ADR-0041. This is a measured rejection of this model as a production tier policy, not a promise to simulate every organism individually at world scale. ## Reproduce ```sh cmake --preset release cmake --build --preset release ctest --preset release ./build/release/evo-resolution-benchmark > resolution-budget.jsonl ``` Windows: `tools/windows-check.ps1 -Preset release -Action check`, then `build/release/evo-resolution-benchmark.exe`. `--verify` runs conservation and sensitivity without timings and is registered in CTest. Exceptions fail the run. The executable rejects other arguments. Use a Release build for cost comparisons. ## Method and host Measured 2026-09-26 on Windows, AMD Ryzen 7 9800X3D, 8 cores/16 logical processors, MSVC 19.44 x64, CMake Release /O2, single simulation thread, no CPU affinity or frequency lock. The host is a workstation, not the R730xd. Raw data: [resolution-budget-msvc1944.jsonl](results/resolution-budget-msvc1944.jsonl). Base checkout: 55a728a plus the M4.6 working changes. Fixture version 2 identifies the shared configurable model, not a persistent simulation version. 100 founders, 10,000 ticks, capacity 200; no randomness. Five age widths and energy supply 240/300/360; only supply varies between scarcity scenarios. Four identical matter channels remain abundant. A warmup and three fresh measured repetitions per representation/scenario alternate timing order. Timings include step allocation, sorting and peak-counter observation, exclude setup/copy, logging, conservation checks, cohort validation and collapse/advance/materialize transactions. Terminal censuses are output so the compiler cannot discard the computation. Peak payload is vector size times row sizeof; peak capacity includes spare vector storage. Neither includes allocator metadata, per-step eligible-index scratch, object/stack bytes or RSS. The individual fixture retains every dead row and scans it, whereas aggregate empty classes are erased. This inflates its cost relative to a future compact active ECS. These figures compare these fixtures only. ## Baseline costs (supply 300) Median elapsed milliseconds for all 10,000 ticks. Extinct runs still execute the remaining empty steps, so their low cost must not be treated as useful throughput. | Width | Individual ms | Aggregate ms | Peak individual capacity bytes | Peak aggregate capacity bytes | Aggregate survives | |---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---| | 10 | 27.107 | 0.250 | 122528 | 360 | yes | | 25 | 27.256 | 0.054 | 122528 | 160 | no | | 50 | 29.190 | 0.135 | 122528 | 120 | yes | | 100 | 27.180 | 0.045 | 122528 | 80 | no | | 200 | 27.263 | 0.045 | 122528 | 80 | no | ## Sensitivity Errors are integer parts per thousand: abs(a-b)/max(a,b), rounded down; zero when both values are zero. Matter is per channel; all four channels are identical here. The proposed gate requires no false extinction at any tick and final population, energy and matter error each <=100 ppt in **every** scenario. This threshold was written before the run; it is a research recommendation, not a biological law. Maximum errors over the trajectory are also recorded in the raw data and are often much worse than the terminal errors. No candidate passes even the terminal gate. | Width | Supply | Individual/aggregate survivors | Population error | Energy error | Matter error | False extinction | |---|---|---|---:|---:|---:|---| | 10 | 240 | 108/120 | 100 | 127 | 346 | no | | 10 | 300 | 75/100 | 250 | 24 | 724 | no | | 10 | 360 | 130/130 | 0 | 34 | 531 | no | | 25 | 240 | 108/100 | 74 | 272 | 189 | no | | 25 | 300 | 75/0 | 1000 | 1000 | 1000 | yes | | 25 | 360 | 130/130 | 0 | 151 | 657 | no | | 50 | 240 | 108/0 | 1000 | 1000 | 1000 | yes | | 50 | 300 | 75/120 | 375 | 43 | 35 | no | | 50 | 360 | 130/180 | 277 | 217 | 589 | no | | 100 | 240 | 108/0 | 1000 | 1000 | 1000 | yes | | 100 | 300 | 75/0 | 1000 | 1000 | 1000 | yes | | 100 | 360 | 130/0 | 1000 | 1000 | 1000 | yes | | 200 | 240 | 108/0 | 1000 | 1000 | 1000 | yes | | 200 | 300 | 75/0 | 1000 | 1000 | 1000 | yes | | 200 | 360 | 130/0 | 1000 | 1000 | 1000 | yes | The shared fixture reproduces M4.5's baseline survivor results. Width 10 avoids extinction but has large matter errors; width 50 fails under reduced energy supply. Widths 100 and 200 go extinct in every scenario. Conservation passed at every tick for both representations in all 15 scenarios; that does not imply ecological fidelity. ## Limits and next steps This is one genome and one deterministic founding distribution. No ensemble, spatial interactions, oxygen, predation, network load or production threading is represented. There is no R730xd capacity estimate or Kubernetes resource request. CPU measurements are wall time on an uncontrolled host and are reports, not CI gates. Before adopting a tier model: preserve within-class reserve variation, test multiple genomes and founding distributions, measure trajectory/distribution errors, and compare an individual store with dead rows retired. Measure conversions, catch-up and complete region workloads on Linux and the target host. Calibrate acceptable error budgets with biological/playtest requirements. M5 can independently begin its small sparse-voxel prototype; no terrain dependency is added to this fixture.