# ADR-0015: Metrics outside authoritative state ## Status Small proof boundary adopted; Prometheus/Grafana/Loki/Otel adapters proposed for M7–M8. M7.8 (ADR-0066) implements the region server exposition with a tiny direct responder and fixed-label metrics; client libraries remain unadopted. ## Context Need tick/entity/recovery evidence without observer effects on decisions. ## Decision Kernel exposes deterministic values; host measures monotonic duration and exports separately. Proof text sink reports tick/entity gauges and benchmark runtime; no HTTP needed. No entity/genome/account metric labels. ## Alternatives Considered prometheus-cpp (MIT) provides client APIs; Otel C++ (Apache-2.0) adds metrics/logs/traces/exporter dependencies. Tiny direct exposition needs format tests. ## Benefits Replay-safe instrumentation and replaceable exporter. ## Costs Host aggregation, retention and cardinality budgets. ## Risks Blocking observers, high-cardinality exhaustion and wall-time/logical-time confusion. ## Consequences M7 adds tick histograms, checkpoint age, fencing/recovery/queue/persistence metrics. Biology flows when implemented. Compare binary/allocations/tail latency/drop behavior/portability; no noisy timing gates. [prometheus-cpp](https://github.com/jupp0r/prometheus-cpp), [Otel C++](https://github.com/open-telemetry/opentelemetry-cpp).