# ADR-0041: Measure aggregate cost before enabling tier selection ## Status Accepted for M4.6 measurement tooling only. No runtime tier selector or biological rule is adopted. Uses the breeding-order correction already committed in 55a728a. Historical M4.5 results are retained; the new run independently checks them. ## Context M4.5 detected large resolution errors, and review detected mismatched parent priority at capacity. Timing those differing models would not justify a policy. ## Decision Share one test-only fixture between comparison and benchmark. Both representations allocate breeding slots oldest-first. A contested-slot control compares individual portraits, not only totals. Preserve the real collapse/advance/materialize integration. Measure 100 founders for 10,000 ticks at widths 10/25/50/100/200 and energy supplies 240/300/360 per tick. Supplies are independent experiments, not gameplay constants. Report population, energy and matter error plus false extinction. Benchmark step loops with a warmup and three fresh measured repetitions, report steady-clock elapsed nanoseconds, final census and peak row payload/vector capacity bytes. Timing excludes setup, conservation checks and conversion; these costs are not production budgets. No portable wall-time assertion. Compare costs only alongside fidelity results. Provisional research gate: no false extinction and final population, energy and matter errors each <=100 parts per thousand in every tested scarcity scenario. This is a recommendation for experiments, not an accepted production error budget. Failure keeps automatic tier selection disabled; do not pick a width merely because it runs faster. Even passing would require trajectory, mixed-genome and host evidence. ## Alternatives Considered Copying the fixture would allow rules to drift. Timing the validation loop measures assertions/ledger verification instead of model advancement. A runtime automatic selector is premature before any resolution has demonstrated acceptable fidelity. ## Benefits Costs and ecological error refer to the same fixture. Raw results are reproducible. ## Costs The individual fixture retains dead rows and sorts eligible parents each step; report that cost rather than extrapolating to a future compact active ECS. ## Risks One synthetic genome, deterministic founding distribution, no production physics, network, scheduler, conversion overhead or server hardware measurement. Payload and capacity bytes exclude allocator metadata, temporary vectors, stack and RSS. ## Consequences Keep controls and conservation in CTest. Archive native measurements with compiler, build and hardware metadata. Do not change simulation versions: only a test model changes. Repeat Linux/target-host measurements before any capacity promise.