# M12.2d exact cellular cohort qualification Decision: [ADR-0139](../adr/0139-exact-cellular-local-cohorts.md), accepted under the maintainer's delegated M12.2 decision authority. The rules-8 model retains every member exactly. Regional approximation remains disabled. No compression, speedup, deployment or production capacity is claimed. ## Executed evidence, 2026-10-17 Full Release runs on MSVC 19.44 and GCC 14.2 use the current reference's four seeds (0/1 development, 2/3 held out), rich/scarce finite deposits and conversion oscillation widths 1/16/64. Each of 24 cases compares complete canonical biological snapshots at every one of 8192 ticks: **196,608 paired ticks** per platform, with zero state error. All non-timing paired JSON fields agree across compilers. The original reference's setup, rules and goldens are unchanged. Across these repetitions: **2354 collapsed members, 2354 materialized members, 6380 cohort member-ticks, 12 offspring, 48 applied mutations and 57 deaths**. Counts include repeated reference scenarios at three conversion widths, not independent biological replicates. Some rich seeds produce no offspring; the test requires actual conversion coverage in seed 1 and across the full matrix. The short CTest also runs that long seed-1 case, preventing a vacuous pass with no cohorts. Controlled founder collapse, missing intentions, duplicate collapse and repeated materialization refusals preserve state. Per-tick checks validate tags against live unowned active cells and preserve total inventory. Raw output: [MSVC](results/m12-2d-cohorts-msvc1944.jsonl), [GCC](results/m12-2d-cohorts-gcc14.jsonl). | Living cells | MSVC p95 step (ms) | GCC/WSL p95 step (ms) | Snapshot bytes | |---|---:|---:|---:| | 16 | 0.045 | 0.058 | 21,108 | | 64 | 0.274 | 0.200 | 71,076 | | 128 | 0.773 | 0.777 | 137,700 | | 256 | 2.359 | 2.326 | 270,948 | These are 32 local warm stepping observations per size, fully funded controlled founders and finite contact food. They include the complete biological owner step but exclude network, storage/publication, rendering, initialization and the qualification's byte comparisons. They are not a mature wildlife stress workload, long-term tail distribution or the Linux deployment host. Refusing a 257th admission leaves the existing 256 alive and the snapshot unchanged. The hard ceiling is retained; production headroom remains unqualified. ## Limits and next work Local exact-state fidelity passes the declared matrix; useful aggregation and target-host fallback capacity remain open parts of M12.2. The largest observed cohort in these ecological histories is small. Full predation, twin-bud, multi-member cohort, capacity wildlife and blocked-resume matrices need stronger coverage before production enablement. No arbitrary approximation may fill that gap. Bins do not exist; widths change conversion timing, not biological quantum. M12.3 can implement the exact owner's durable conversion contract without enabling a live selector. Database publication, process loss and deployment qualification must be reported separately from codec/replay success. No World0 state is accessed.