4.0 KiB
ADR-0134: Exact reserve-strata population experiment
Status
Accepted for the isolated M12.2b research instrument (2026-10-16). No runtime tier policy, biological rule, public API, persistent version or golden changes.
Context
ADR-0041 and M12.2a reproduce false extinctions when an age class pays upkeep from its mean reserve. Narrower age bins do not reliably repair this. Before approximating M11 cellular ecology, test whether retaining exact age/reserve variation removes that mechanism in the original synthetic model.
Decision
Add an experiment using exact per-member age/energy/matter, run-length encoded only across contiguous identities with identical state. Retain monotonic identity ranges and oldest-first, then identity-first birth priority. Partial reproduction splits a range; equal newborns can share a range. Dead members leave the working representation; no averaging, resampling, age reset or death-rounding occurs. Keep the existing failed fixture, benchmark and goldens unchanged.
Predeclare the acceptance instrument before measurement:
- Every tick must exactly match identified living portraits, population, reserve, cumulative births/deaths, environment, detritus and conserved totals against the retained individual reference. No terminal-only tolerance. Any mismatch fails.
- Revisit supplies 240/300/360 for 10,000 ticks from the original 100 founders.
- Seeds 0-7 are development and 8-15 held out. For each seed, test supplies 180/240/300/360/480 for 1,500 ticks. Generate blocks of five identical founders with seeded heterogeneous ages/reserves, so both compression and variation occur. These are declared synthetic regimes, not M11 calibration or diversity evidence.
- Check contested partial births with same-age unequal reserves, empty/dead input, fragmented identities, conservation and interval partitioning without enlarging the model's one-tick integration quantum.
- Report local time, peak active rows, state payload and vector capacity alongside error. Timing runs exclude verification and setup; no portable timing assertion. Report the historical reference's retained-dead-row bias explicitly. Include an identified compact-individual cost control that retires dead rows while keeping birth priority, and check its identified outcomes against the same reference.
The candidate representation is not Cohort v1: that contract retains only age-class totals and cannot recover the exact reserve distribution. No converter is provided that silently upgrades v1. This experiment retains identified state; it must not be described as statistically sampled ancestry or a production model.
Alternatives considered
Changing the old fixture would invalidate the rejection evidence. Exact individual rows provide a useful control but cannot demonstrate any grouping benefit. Reserve bins that still mix viable and starving members need an error/viability model; test the exact sufficient-state control first. Directly wiring the old aggregate into the cellular owner remains prohibited by ADR-0041.
Benefits
Tests a specific repair with an independent implementation of interval accounting and identified outcomes. Shared scalar Rule predicates keep the synthetic biology constant while the representation changes.
Costs
Heterogeneous states may require one row per living member. Identity order can prevent merging otherwise identical states. Per-tick splitting and sorting cost time and temporary memory; report rather than assume a speedup.
Risks
This single-genome, nonspatial fixture lacks M11 controller, contact, predation, mutation, budding placement and suspension. Exact synthetic fidelity does not qualify current cellular workloads or establish a target-host fallback budget.
Consequences
Add release-safe CTest coverage and run formatting, analysis and ASan/UBSan for the experiment. Publish results with limitations. M12.2 remains open until M11 paired ensembles, supported-state admission and target-host cost/error evidence are accepted; M12.3-12.5 remain dependent on that qualification.