2.1 KiB
ADR-0106: Cellular contested patch arbitration trial
Status
Accepted for the M11.3 exploratory slice (2026-10-10). The arbitration order is explicit and reviewable with the 11.3e playtest evidence; it is not a claim of long-term balance.
Context
ADR-0101 makes each cellular patch finite. ADR-0104 orders one life's maintenance, movement and intake, but a shared patch can receive claims from multiple lives in the same tick. Resolving each life against the original patch would duplicate stock. Network arrival order is nondeterministic and cannot decide the biological result.
Decision
- Resolve a region's life proposals in ascending stable world life identity, independent of input, session and connection order.
- Each valid claimant receives its per-channel intake limit from the patch stock remaining after earlier identities. An exhausted channel transfers zero; other channels remain independent.
- Produce one detached region candidate with the final patch stocks and every life result. If any life cannot produce its tick candidate, refuse the entire result; the caller publishes no partial tick.
- This trial does not define death/corpse closure, cell-to-cell contact, engulfment or durable publication. Those remain later 11.3c/11.3d work.
Alternatives considered
- Connection or arrival order: rejected because it is nondeterministic and gives transport timing biological effect.
- Proportional allocation: deferred; it changes the meaning of the existing per-life intake cap and needs a different conservation/fairness trial.
- Seeded rotation: deferred until playtest evidence shows fixed identity order causes a meaningful fairness problem. It would add state or a new deterministic arbitration rule.
Consequences
The first implementation provides a bounded deterministic shared-patch candidate and verifies channel conservation. Ascending identity can favour older lives under repeated scarcity; 11.3e records whether that is understandable and acceptable. Changing the order requires updating this decision and deterministic replay evidence.