19 KiB
Ecology and simulation fidelity
M12.1's current scoped identity/time policy and explicit deferrals are in ECOLOGICAL_IDENTITY_AND_TIME and ADR-0133. Historical M4 sections below retain their original implementation scope; no population model or automatic tier policy has qualified. See the M12 delivery plan.
M12.2b's isolated exact-state experiment repairs the synthetic averaging failure by retaining per-member age/reserve and identity order. It is not Cohort v1, an M11 cellular model or a production tier.
Locked: scalable tiers and independent persistent descendants. Contracts below are recommended; population math, lineage/species classifications are experiments.
| Tier | Owned state |
|---|---|
| 1 active | Identified individuals, position, phenotype, reserve, lifecycle and interactions |
| 2 local | Genome/cohort, counts, demographic distributions, matter/composition/reserve |
| 3 regional | Genome/lineage density distributions, inventories and environmental coupling |
No inventory is spendable in two tiers. Representatives are either debited cohort shares or read-only noninteractive visuals. Never average distinct genomes into one genome. Controlled organisms cannot collapse into progressing populations; offline state is separate. Carry uncertainty and approximation error explicitly.
flowchart LR
I[Individuals] -->|freeze / reserve| T[Conversion transaction]
T -->|commit inventory| P[Population]
P <-->|conservative allocation| E[Regional ecology]
P -->|reserve feasible share| T
T -->|install identities| I
S[Suspended inventory] --- A[World accounting]
T --> A
P --> A
I --> A
PopulationRecord proposes habitat/genome/lineage identity, representation version, owner epoch, last simulated tick, demographic bins, count semantics, material/ element inventory, reserve, spatial support, uncertainty and conversion sequence. Preserve reproductive state or exclude it until conversion is valid. Expected fractional density differs from an available individual; integer materialization uses a seeded rule/residual and remains bounded by funded biomass/energy.
| Contract | Invariant |
|---|---|
| PlanCollapse | Reject controlled/suspended/dead/unsettled members; group compatible states and total exact inventory |
| CommitCollapse | Remove active spending rights and install cohort once under current epoch |
| AdvancePopulation | Bounded flux proposals over a declared interval and environment view |
| PlanMaterialize | Reserve feasible count, composition, reserve and demographics |
| CommitMaterialize | Debit cohort/install active identities while retaining provenance |
| TransferPopulation | Source escrow, idempotent destination credit and durable settlement |
Prefer local deterministic transactions. At a tick boundary freeze the old representation, reserve under conversion ID/epoch, validate conservation and destination, commit source removal/destination installation recoverably, then expose. Recovery replays the committed sample, never samples again. A timeout cannot release remote reservations. Cross-worker bus delivery is not exactly-once authority. Count escrow in global totals.
Keep IDs in initial fixtures. Later statistical representation needs an ADR for retained individuals versus cohort representatives; never invent precise parentage from statistical ancestry. Adversarial conversion cannot select only healthy/high energy members or reset age/injury/fertility/incubation. Unsupported states stay explicit until a valid conversion exists.
Population math and timing experiments
N_next = N + births - deaths + immigration - emigration.
B_next = B + assimilated_growth + immigrant_biomass - mortality_biomass - predation_biomass - emigrant_biomass.
Births redistribute funded investment, not independently created biomass. Predation changes counts and transfers biomass once; death returns detritus. Compare bounded flux, seeded stochastic cohort and deterministic expected-density models. Reject/subdivide unstable intervals; never hide negative populations with clamps. Operational capacity limits backpressure rather than ecologically cull. Shared bounded perception/intention controllers are the initial AI proposal; evolving behavior/learning and universal species definitions remain open.
Advance whole declared intervals and record last committed tick. One owner integrates each interval; late transfers are not new production. Expose catch-up backlog/freshness. Whole-world outage wall-time catch-up is an explicit later policy, while offline controlled biology remains frozen either way. Exact seeded repeatability does not imply exact fidelity to individual ecology: compare matched ensembles and publish population/biomass/diversity error envelopes.
Extinction and acceptance
Distinguish no active observation, ecological absence and terminal extinction. Require a globally reconciled watermark covering active individuals, cohorts, eggs/spores, in-flight transfers and every viable store. Suspended members make absence differ from recoverable viability: extinction stays provisional until policy acceptance. Rounding a density to zero cannot declare irreversible extinction. Preserve genome/ancestry/origin/extinction evidence permanently; census series may be summarized at declared resolution. Clones have isolated IDs/event destinations and cannot publish into World0.
M4: collapse 100 funded compatible individuals, simulate 10,000 ticks, materialize feasible representatives. Test conservation including flux/residual/escrow, genome identity, deterministic replay, crashes at every conversion boundary, interval uniqueness, mixed-genome diversity, repeated conversion attacks, extreme rates, late migrations/censuses and suspended viability. Compare explicit individuals: passing conservation alone is insufficient ecological evidence.
Implemented M2.6 episode boundary
ADR-0029 measures bounded episodes of the synthetic community. It settles none of the contracts above. There is no tier, no cohort, no conversion transaction, no representative materialization and no habitat. Every process stays an identified individual for its whole life.
Extinction here is the narrow, local statement that an episode has no living consumer, recorded with the tick it happened. It is not the globally reconciled watermark this document requires: there are no suspended members, eggs, spores, in-flight transfers or other viable stores to reconcile, and no policy acceptance. Surviving lineage counts come from retained parent references, not from species classification, and lineages differ only by founder strategy because no genome exists yet.
The shared bounded controller proposal is exercised only as a measurement driver. It has no perception, no learning and no evolving behavior, and its constants are inputs rather than results. Population math, cohort collapse and resolution equivalence remain M4 work.
Implemented M4.1 cohort record
ADR-0036 defines the tier 2 record
and who may act on it. It settles nothing else above: there is no conversion
transaction, no population advance, no representative materialization and no
habitat geometry. PlanCollapse, CommitCollapse, AdvancePopulation,
PlanMaterialize, CommitMaterialize and TransferPopulation remain contracts
nothing implements.
A cohort is per genome, so distinct genomes are never averaged into one. Its age classes each carry their own count and their own reserve, which is how the record answers the risk that population averages hide viable outliers: a count with a mean reserve cannot distinguish a provisioned cohort from one where half the members hold nothing, and nothing later can recover that. Within one class members are indistinguishable, and that is the declared resolution rather than an oversight. No accessor returns a mean.
Lineage is not stored. It is resolved from the genome through the archive, so a cohort cannot claim a parentage the archive would contradict and cannot invent precise parentage from statistical membership. Totals are derived from the classes rather than stored beside them.
Fractional members are carried per class as integer numerators over a declared scale, strictly below one member. An expected fractional density is therefore never mistaken for an available individual. Funding a residual against biomass, and the seeded rule that turns one into a member, are M4.3 and M4.4.
CohortRegistry enforces that no inventory is spendable in two tiers by admitting
at most one record per habitat and genome, and by requiring a replacement to be a
strictly later view of the same record: same worker, no older epoch, an advancing
revision within an epoch, and an interval boundary that never runs backwards. An
epoch alone is too coarse, because an owner replaying its own earlier record
inside one epoch would restore inventory the installed record had already spent. This is a single-process invariant: epochs
make a stale writer fail locally and are not cross-worker fencing, which is M7 and
M10. The registry holds no lock, lease or quorum, and nothing is serialized.
Approximation error is a declared field that nothing computes or checks yet. Carrying a bound is not meeting one; M4.5 is where resolution equivalence is measured. Conservation between a cohort and the rest of the world is the ledger's property and is not asserted by this type, which holds an inventory without participating in any transfer.
Implemented M4.2 collapse
ADR-0037 implements PlanCollapse and
CommitCollapse for a single habitat and genome in one process. It settles
nothing else: AdvancePopulation, PlanMaterialize, CommitMaterialize and
TransferPopulation remain contracts nothing implements, and the direction is
one-way until M4.4.
Collapse is two phases over one sample, so recovery replays a committed sample and never samples again: the plan is immutable, carries an already-validated cohort, and commit derives nothing. Members that are controlled, suspended, dead or unsettled are rejected as this document requires, and rejection refuses the whole plan rather than dropping the member. That is what makes adversarial selection visible: a conversion cannot quietly exclude the unhealthy and still look honest. Age, and the per-class reserve distribution, are carried through unchanged; a member whose age fits no declared class refuses the plan rather than being moved into one.
Exact inventory is totalled through the ledger, not alongside it. One atomic transaction carries one leg per member, each moving that member's entire reserve, so the conserved total is unchanged by construction and no remainder is left in a second tier. The destination is proved available and empty before anything moves, so a refusal cannot strand biomass in a reservoir nothing owns and a cohort's recorded reserve is the whole of what backs it rather than a part sharing a reservoir with inventory it never sampled. Every rejection leaves both the ledger and the registry exactly as they were.
Two gaps are explicit. This cannot establish that the members offered were all the members there were; completeness is the caller's obligation. And "remove active spending rights" is implemented as emptying, because the ledger has no reservoir removal: nothing prevents a later transfer crediting an emptied reservoir, and only the registry's single-ownership rule bounds what that would mean. Durable conversion sequence numbers, escrow and crash recovery across a process boundary are M7 and M8; the before-and-after property proved here holds across a rejection inside one process.
Implemented M4.3 interval accounting
ADR-0038 implements AdvancePopulation as
accounting rather than as a model. The population maths above stays an experiment:
no birth rate, mortality curve, functional response or carrying capacity is chosen
here, so none of the candidate models listed above has been made the only one.
What is enforced is the arithmetic around whichever model runs.
Nothing is clamped. A loss larger than what is present refuses the interval and names whether it was the population or the biomass, so an unstable interval is rejected and can be subdivided. Subtraction is checked against what is there rather than performed and repaired, so a negative population is never constructed.
Counts carry whole members and owed fractions as one scaled quantity, so a density below one member is still a number and rounding it to zero is not available as a decision. A population that reaches exactly zero becomes a vacant record, which is neither absence nor extinction: the genome, the habitat, the owner and the provenance all remain and the record stays installed. Deleting it would have been the false extinction this milestone is named against.
Births redistribute funded investment because there is no term by which a birth could bring biomass in. Immigration draws from a reservoir that already held the inventory, so a late transfer is not new production. Death returns detritus and predation transfers once, each to a named counterparty, as one atomic ledger transaction against the cohort's reservoir.
Three gaps are explicit. Closure is checked and stability is not, so an interval
whose arithmetic balances and whose ecology is nonsense is accepted; comparing
matched ensembles and publishing error envelopes is M4.5. The resulting age
structure is supplied by the caller and is not verified to be what ageing would
produce, because ageing across a class boundary needs the within-class
distribution the declared resolution discards. And emigration escrows into a
reservoir nothing settles with, because TransferPopulation does not exist.
Implemented M4.4 materialization
ADR-0039 implements
PlanMaterialize and CommitMaterialize for one cohort in one process.
TransferPopulation remains a contract nothing implements, and no
resolution-equivalence claim is made here.
Representatives are debited cohort shares, as this document requires, and never anything else. A drawn member receives its class share by integer division rounded down; rounding up would create biomass. A class drawn empty hands over everything it held, because a class with no members may keep no reserve. A residual is never drawable, so an expected fractional density stays distinct from an available individual.
Age is carried, not reset, in the only direction that is safe when the exact value is unrecoverable: a member materializes at the oldest age its class admits. Every other rule lets an adversary who chooses when to convert roll back towards youth, and repeating that is immortality. A round trip can therefore only age someone, so oscillation is strictly lossy rather than free. This is a defence, not a model of ageing, and under repeated conversion it will make a population look older than it is.
What the declared resolution discards is stated rather than mitigated. Within one class members are indistinguishable, so collapsing a starving member together with a well-provisioned one and materializing both returns two average members, healing the first at the second's expense. Conservation of the total is not evidence that any individual is right. A round trip is exact when each class holds one member, and the mitigation available to a caller is to declare narrower classes when it collapses; nothing here can recover what a coarse class threw away.
A destination reservoir must be unowned as well as empty. A vacant cohort, or one holding nothing, still owns its store, so crediting it would put inventory there that the owning record does not account for. This holds on both sides of the conversion, and the registry is asked rather than inferred from what a reservoir contains.
A habitat and genome holding a vacant record is repopulated rather than refused, because this document requires the record to be retained and a retained record would otherwise bar the lineage from ever returning. The repopulation continues the retained record's ownership and revision series; it does not reset them, and a record that still holds a population is never merged into silently.
A materialized member carries the cohort's genome, its habitat and a fresh identity, and nothing else. It has no parentage, no history and no condition, because a cohort never carried them, and none of that may later be invented from a statistical membership.
Implemented M4.5 resolution comparison
ADR-0040 carries out the comparison this document asks for: a hundred funded individuals collapsed, advanced over ten thousand ticks and materialized, against the same hundred simulated explicitly. The numbers are in resolution-equivalence-msvc1944.jsonl.
One rule is written once and applied at both resolutions, and a control with one member per class establishes that the two runs are the same rule before any gap is blamed on resolution. Every state the aggregate run passes through is checked to be a representable cohort, so the envelope describes this library rather than a model it could not hold.
The claim this document warns against is not made. Nothing asserts the trajectories agree; the tests assert that they differ, so equivalence cannot be read as identity, and the word is not used for what was measured.
What was measured is two regimes rather than a gradient. At some class widths the aggregate tracks the individuals within a few hundred parts per thousand. At others it dies out entirely while the individuals persist, which is a false extinction caused by resolution alone: a whole class starves the moment its average cannot pay upkeep, where individuals starve a few at a time and the survivors keep the shared per-capita share up. This is the "population averages hide viable outliers" risk arriving as a measurable quantity.
The collapse is not monotone in class width: a narrower class is not reliably safer. A tier policy therefore cannot be derived by assuming degradation worsens smoothly as resolution coarsens, and the boundary between the regimes is not characterised here.
Conservation held exactly at every tick of every run, including the ones whose populations died out. That is this document's point about conservation being insufficient ecological evidence, demonstrated rather than restated.
Not covered: one genome only, so the mixed-genome diversity case remains open; one model, one scarce axis and one initial distribution, so the numbers describe this fixture; interval-length error is unmeasured, because the aggregate run sub-steps at one tick to keep the averaging error attributable; and nothing here is distributed or persistent.
M4.6 budget review
ADR-0041 and the measurement report evaluate cost together with population, energy and matter errors. No tested width qualifies across the scarcity sweep. Faster execution alone does not authorize a resolution switch; automatic selection remains disabled. This fixture is not a production ecological model.