Files
aevolution/docs/architecture/OPEN_QUESTIONS.md
T
dingoandClaude Opus 5.5 c468c70933
Foundation / checks (checks) (push) Successful in 4s
Foundation / checks (client) (push) Successful in 5s
Foundation / checks (ecs) (push) Successful in 4s
Foundation / checks (network) (push) Successful in 5s
Foundation / checks (postgres) (push) Successful in 5s
Foundation / checks (tsan) (push) Successful in 5s
Foundation / checks (deploy) (push) Successful in 3m33s
Foundation / postgres-tools (push) Successful in 5s
Foundation / image (push) Successful in 4s
Foundation / server-image (push) Successful in 5s
M11.1: record the first cellular loop decisions (ADR-0098)
Maintainer decisions (2026-10-09) for the first playable loop: budding (parent keeps
control, one funded wildlife bud); funded in-life mutation from seeded candidates;
exact-copy heredity, no NPC mutation in M11; logout freezes at once, lingers vulnerable,
then suspends; resume in place or nearest valid spot within a bounded radius;
absorption plus engulfment by membrane-contested size ratio; first bud fundable within a
session (tunable); friend recognition deferred. Updates OPEN_QUESTIONS 7/10/14/31/33,
REPRODUCTION_MODEL, ROADMAP, STATUS; BACKLOG gains the open M10 native-client items.
Refresh the dev session window.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-10-09 10:51:23 -04:00

5.8 KiB

Design decision register

All recommendations below are reviewable, not silent product decisions. Owner means the engineering/design role accountable at the gate, not an assigned person. ADR indexes distinguish scoped proof choices from production proposals.

# Open question Current position / experiment Owner; gate
1 Tick frequency and biological rate units 50 ms (20 Hz) remains the ratified M10 engineering tick. Maintainer ratified time-based biological rates on 2026-10-04: M11.1 will convert rates deterministically at each tick and migrate per-tick genome/checkpoint fields with explicit units, precision, remainder/rounding and overflow bounds, plus 50 ms regression evidence (ADR-0089). Biology/design; M11.1 migration
2 Fixed/variable boundaries Fixed authoritative ticks, host wall-clock pacing; ecology integer multiples Simulation; M1
3 ECS Row/EnTT4 experiment in ADR-0021; retain bounded rows for proof, production choice awaits richer workloads (Flecs remains an alternative) Engine; M1 and biological component gate
4 Dependency manager Evaluate vcpkg manifest vs Conan; no runtime dependency for proof Build; first dependency
5 Units library Minimal explicit integer wrappers now; evaluate dimensional library before biology Simulation; M2
6 Determinism Exact integer proof; physics separately scoped Simulation; each system ADR
7 Mutation generation Seeded context-conditioned candidates with validated prerequisites. M11: earned during life, offered from seeded candidates and applied through funded development (ADR-0098); candidate count and the eligibility trigger come in 11.4's contract Biology/design; M3/M11
8 Genome representation Immutable versioned developmental capabilities, not DNA Biology; M3
9 Developmental body Typed body graph proposal Biology/engine; M13
10 Heredity/reproductive mutation M11 (ADR-0098): budding; a bud copies its parent's current genome exactly, with ancestry; no mutation at birth. Recombination stays open Biology/design; M3/M11
11 NPC mutation Undecided; no silent autonomous divergence Biology/design; M12
12 Species/speciation Derived classifications; no class mechanics Biology/design; M12
13 Lineage extinction Need world-wide no-living/no-viable-reserve evidence Ecology; M4/M12
14 Offline state M11 (ADR-0098): biology freezes at once on logout or a detected disconnect; the organism lingers in the world, frozen but vulnerable (tunable, 10 s), then suspends durably; resume in place or at the nearest valid spot within a bounded radius, else it stays suspended. How long suspension is retained stays open Design/security; before player persistence
15 Multicellular transition Physiological and ecological criteria unresolved Design/biology; M14
16 Population abstraction Conservative cohort ledger + distributions, ensemble validation Ecology; M4
17 Region dimensions Benchmark against interest, entities and migration overhead Engine/platform; M7
18 Planet coordinates M5.1 bounded local integer contract accepted (ADR-0042); global hierarchy remains proposed World; M5/M13
19 Spherical voxels Prototype cubed sphere versus alternatives; no fixed topology yet World; M13
20 Voxel LOD Sparse procedural base, aggregate fields, active chunks World; M5/M13
21 Surface meshing Marching Cubes / Surface Nets / Dual Contouring comparison Render/world; M13
22 Hydrology Conserved regional reservoirs/flux before full flow physics World; M6/later R&D
23 Atmosphere Aggregate mass and species budgets; no global CFD promise Ecology/world; M12
24 Cross-region ownership Fenced leases + explicit handoff state machine Distributed systems; M7/M10
25 Reliability layer Evaluate secure datagram/reliable transports before bespoke reliability Network/security; M10
26 Serialization Local bounded binary proof; production schemas undecided Engine/platform; M7/M10
27 Snapshot/events Snapshot + deterministic replay batches + durable semantic history Persistence; M7
28 Recovery Committed contiguous replay range and unique epoch Persistence; M7/M8
29 Cross-version migration Clone, migrate, accelerated comparison, approved world barrier Simulation/platform; M7+
30 Steam identity Provider subject → internal account boundary Backend/security; before Steam
31 Friend recognition Deferred explicitly for M11 (ADR-0098); revisit after the 11.9 playtests. No player/NPC labels Design; after M11.9
32 Anti-cheat Authoritative outcomes plus authenticated bounded intentions Security; M10
33 AI behavior Shared intention interface; bounded deterministic controller. M11 wildlife uses the same intentions as players, with no special biological rules (ADR-0098) Simulation; M2/M11
34 Evolvable behavior Undecided; intelligence not mandatory Biology/design; M12/R&D
35 Morphology limits Development graph validates material, attachment and capability Biology/design; M13
36 Procedural animation Isolated locomotion prototypes; no authored animation dependence Engine; M13
37 Retention Permanent genome ancestry; tiered replay/snapshots/backups Platform/design; M7/M8
38 DR objectives Dev/stage ratified (ADR-0075: worker loss RPO 0, RTO <= 60 s; host loss = explicit rewind to last verified bundle). World0 requires acknowledged outcomes durable in an independent failure domain before ACK; launch blocked until then Platform; before World0

Additional blockers: actual host inventory, domain/TLS, registry and Git provider, storage class/backup destination, resource budgets, project licensing and World0 promotion approvers. None blocks a local dependency-free simulation proof.