From a49ec7bf66e8ec65a5962061d6a2de9b6b8a0404 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Prime Date: Fri, 27 Mar 2026 12:24:45 +0000 Subject: [PATCH] Add remaining deck R1 conversion audits --- ...erthrone_fields_deck_grain_oath_concord.md | 315 +++++++++++++ ...e_frontier_deck_lattice_witness_compact.md | 422 ++++++++++++++++++ ...thallow_oaths_deck_white_truce_covenant.md | 331 ++++++++++++++ ...il_reckoning_deck_crownseed_remembrance.md | 291 ++++++++++++ ...car_caravans_deck_sun_ledger_procession.md | 283 ++++++++++++ ...ecrown_intrigue_deck_open_harbors_claim.md | 291 ++++++++++++ ...y_system_gaps_found_via_deck_conversion.md | 353 +++++++++++++++ 7 files changed, 2286 insertions(+) create mode 100644 decks-r1/amberthrone_fields_deck_grain_oath_concord.md create mode 100644 decks-r1/eclipse_frontier_deck_lattice_witness_compact.md create mode 100644 decks-r1/frosthallow_oaths_deck_white_truce_covenant.md create mode 100644 decks-r1/greenveil_reckoning_deck_crownseed_remembrance.md create mode 100644 decks-r1/sunscar_caravans_deck_sun_ledger_procession.md create mode 100644 decks-r1/tidecrown_intrigue_deck_open_harbors_claim.md create mode 100644 sor_ability_system_gaps_found_via_deck_conversion.md diff --git a/decks-r1/amberthrone_fields_deck_grain_oath_concord.md b/decks-r1/amberthrone_fields_deck_grain_oath_concord.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..eb4f3fb --- /dev/null +++ b/decks-r1/amberthrone_fields_deck_grain_oath_concord.md @@ -0,0 +1,315 @@ +# Amberthrone Fields Deck R1 Conversion Audit — Grain Oath Concord + +This document converts `amberthrone_fields_deck_grain_oath_concord.md` into an engine-facing R1 audit against the current SOR ability model. + +## Status labels +- **Implementable now** +- **Implementable with templating choice** +- **Not currently implementable cleanly** + +--- + +## 1. ArchSpirit line + +### Brakka, Ditchborn Mootspeaker + +#### Bread Before Blood +**Text:** Friendly units on Field, Hill, or Plains gain +1 Defense. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +#### Open the Granary +**Text:** Target friendly unit gains +1 Damage and `CanUseAbility = true` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +#### Public Witness +**Text:** When a friendly unit enters battlefield on Plains, gain +1 SP once per turn. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Why:** The trigger and resource gain are easy; the exact once-per-turn cap is not currently present on triggered abilities. + +**Best current R1:** implement without the cap, or add future trigger limit support. + +--- + +### Brakka, Shield of Blackfurrow + +#### Shared Stores, Shared Steel +**Text:** Friendly Spirits on Plains gain +1 Damage. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +#### Moot Order +**Text:** Target enemy loses `CanMove` until end of turn. If that enemy is on Plains, it also loses `CanAttack` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +#### Feed the Line +**Text:** The first time each turn another friendly unit enters this aura range, that unit gains +1 current defense. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Why:** Aura-entry trigger + `ModifyDefense(Current)` works. The once-per-turn cap does not. + +--- + +### Brakka, Mother of the Open Granary + +#### The Realm Eats Together +**Text:** Friendly units on Field, Hill, or Plains gain +1/+1. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +#### Declare Common Right +**Text:** Push Final Affinity: target tile becomes Plains. Then a friendly unit may move 1 tile. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1 wording:** +> Target tile becomes Plains. Then target friendly unit gains +1 MP this turn. + +#### No Village Abandoned +**Text:** The first time each turn a friendly unit on Plains would die, prevent that death and set it to 1 health. + +**Status:** Not currently implementable cleanly + +**Needed:** pre-death replacement / prevention support. + +--- + +## 2. Spirits + +### Barley Road Courier +**Text:** When this moves onto Plains, gain 1 SP. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Granary Lock Warden +**Text:** On channel, a friendly unit gains +1 Defense until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Orchard Salt-Pledge Pixie +**Text:** When this enters, draw 1 then discard 1. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Ridge Pennant Rider +**Text:** Another friendly unit may move 1 tile when this enters. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** another friendly unit gains +1 MP this turn. + +### Common Right Reeve +**Text:** Aura 1: friendly units on Plains gain +1 Defense. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Longview Orchard Elder +**Text:** expose target enemy; it loses `CanUseAbility` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Ditchline Militia Captain +**Text:** If this attacks from or into Plains, it gains +1 Damage. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** when this attacks while on Plains, it gains +1 Damage until end of turn. + +### March Witness Cavalier +**Text:** When this moves into Plains, it may move 1 additional tile. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** when this moves onto Plains, it gains +1 MP this turn. + +### Hearthcross Scale-Inspector +**Text:** On enter, target enemy loses +1 Damage and `CanMove` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now, with wording cleanup + +**Note:** `loses +1 Damage` should be normalized to `-1 Damage until end of turn` using `ModifyDamage(-1)`. + +### Ashen Hedge Packguide +**Text:** Friendly units entering this aura range gain +1 MP this turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Pilgrim Road Bellwarden +**Text:** When a friendly unit on Plains enters aura range, heal it 1. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Red Harvest Standard-Dead +**Text:** Enemies damaged by this lose `CanAttack` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Issue:** exact source-qualified damage trigger is not cleanly supported. + +**Recommended R1:** when this attacks a unit, that unit loses `CanAttack` until end of turn. + +### Grain Crown Testifier +**Text:** Draw 1 if this enters on Plains; if Brakka is in play, draw 2 then discard 1 instead. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**What works:** +- enter-on-Plains check +- draw/discard sequence +- checking for a specific card by broad battlefield conditions is only partly available + +**What is awkward:** exact named-card presence (`Brakka is in play`) and the “instead” branch. + +**Recommended R1 wording:** +> If this enters on Plains, draw 1. + +or +> If this enters on Plains, draw 2 then discard 1. + +**Needed for exact version:** named-card / card-ref battlefield condition plus branching. + +### Halcyon Seedvault Sentinel +**Text:** Adjacent enemies have -1 Damage. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Marek, Banner of Shared Roads +**Text:** Friendly Plains units in aura range gain `CanBeBlocked = false` while moving. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Gap:** movement-state-sensitive flag. + +**Recommended R1:** friendly Plains units in aura range gain `CanBeBlocked = false`. + +### Open Granary Colossus +**Text:** Friendly Plains units gain +1/+1. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +--- + +## 3. Repentance + +### Open the Storehouses +**Text:** Friendly unit gains `CanBeAttacked = false` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Moot of the High Road +**Text:** Target enemy loses `CanAttack` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Ledger of True Measure +**Text:** Draw 2 then discard 1. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Declare the Commons +**Text:** Push Final Affinity to Plains on one tile, then a friendly unit gains +1 Defense. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Famine Law Proclaimed +**Text:** Friendly units on Plains gain +1/+1 and `CanUseAbility = true` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +--- + +## 4. Ruin + +### Red Harvest Witness Mound +**Text:** If occupied by a friendly unit, choose one at random: gain 1 SP; draw 1 then discard 1; target enemy in aura range loses `CanMove` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +--- + +## 5. Instinct + +### Stand Before the Barn +**Text:** Prevent an attack by making target enemy lose `CanAttack` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** target enemy loses `CanAttack` until end of turn. + +### Hitch the Relief Team +**Text:** Move a friendly unit 1 tile or grant +2 MP this turn. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** grant +2 MP this turn. + +### Public Accusation +**Text:** Target unit loses `CanUseAbility` or `CanMove` until end of sequence. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Why:** either flag removal is easy; exact modal sequencing duration is not. + +**Recommended R1:** pick one mode and use until end of turn. + +--- + +## 6. Summary + +### Implementable now +- Bread Before Blood +- Open the Granary +- Shared Stores, Shared Steel +- Moot Order +- The Realm Eats Together +- Barley Road Courier +- Granary Lock Warden +- Orchard Salt-Pledge Pixie +- Common Right Reeve +- Longview Orchard Elder +- Hearthcross Scale-Inspector +- Ashen Hedge Packguide +- Pilgrim Road Bellwarden +- Halcyon Seedvault Sentinel +- Open Granary Colossus +- Open the Storehouses +- Moot of the High Road +- Ledger of True Measure +- Declare the Commons +- Famine Law Proclaimed +- Red Harvest Witness Mound + +### Implementable with templating choice +- Public Witness +- Feed the Line +- Declare Common Right +- Ridge Pennant Rider +- Ditchline Militia Captain +- March Witness Cavalier +- Red Harvest Standard-Dead +- Grain Crown Testifier +- Marek, Banner of Shared Roads +- Stand Before the Barn +- Hitch the Relief Team +- Public Accusation + +### Not currently implementable cleanly +- No Village Abandoned + +--- + +## 7. Engine gaps highlighted by this deck +- triggered once-per-turn caps +- arbitrary one-tile reposition as a first-class effect +- attack-event terrain context (`from` / `into` Plains) +- source-qualified damage triggers +- named-card-presence conditions +- movement-state-sensitive `CanBeBlocked` +- modal branch support / `ChooseOne` +- end-of-sequence duration +- pre-death replacement timing diff --git a/decks-r1/eclipse_frontier_deck_lattice_witness_compact.md b/decks-r1/eclipse_frontier_deck_lattice_witness_compact.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..dd42287 --- /dev/null +++ b/decks-r1/eclipse_frontier_deck_lattice_witness_compact.md @@ -0,0 +1,422 @@ +# Eclipse Frontier Deck R1 Conversion Audit — Lattice Witness Compact + +This document converts `eclipse_frontier_deck_lattice_witness_compact.md` into an engine-facing R1 audit against the current SOR ability system in: +- `SOR/Server/src/SOR.Game/Abilities/AbilitySystem.cs` +- `SOR/Server/src/SOR.Game/Abilities/Models/*` + +It focuses on **unique card/rules text**, not duplicate copies. + +## Status labels +- **Implementable now** — expressible in the current JSON ability/action/effect model +- **Implementable with templating choice** — feasible if wording is tightened to a specific engine-safe form +- **Not currently implementable cleanly** — needs new engine hooks, state history, targeting memory, or replacement timing + +--- + +## 1. ArchSpirit line + +### Serai of the Witness Paths + +#### Sanctuary Is a Promise +**Text:** Friendly units on Hill, Forest, or Fort gain +1 Defense. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +**Why:** Same pattern as other tri-terrain passives: three passive actions or three passive abilities using `IsOnTileWithAffinity`. + +#### Mark the Safe Route +**Text:** Target tile gets a temporary protective marker effect: the next friendly unit to move onto it gains `CanBeAttacked = false` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Not currently implementable cleanly + +**Why:** The engine can target a tile and can schedule `ApplyOnEvent`, but it does not have a clean way to bind a delayed trigger to **a specific chosen tile** and then apply an effect to **the first friendly unit entering that tile**. + +**Needed support:** +- deferred trigger payload that can remember a chosen tile coordinate +- trigger condition such as `EventData.DestinationTile == Action1.Target` +- one-shot consumption semantics bound to that tile marker + +#### Witness Entry +**Text:** When a friendly Spirit enters battlefield on Fort, gain +1 SP. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +**Why:** `OnChanneled` or `OnUnitEnterBattlefield` plus target/self-on-Fort check and `ModifySP +1`. + +--- + +### Serai, Covenant of Stone and Root + +#### Boundaries with Teeth +**Text:** Friendly Spirits on Fort gain +1 Damage and `CanBeBlocked = false` while moving. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**What works now:** Fort-conditioned passive damage buff. + +**What is awkward:** `SetCanBeBlocked = false while moving` needs a movement-state-sensitive condition the current system does not expose. + +**Recommended R1 wording:** +> Friendly Spirits on Fort gain +1 Damage. They also gain `CanBeBlocked = false` while on Fort. + +or simpler: +> Friendly Spirits on Fort gain +1 Damage and `CanBeBlocked = false`. + +#### Legal Interdiction +**Text:** Target enemy loses `CanMove` until end of turn. If it is on Fort, it also loses `CanAttack` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +**Why:** Straight active ability with two sequential actions; second action targets prior target and checks `IsOnTileWithAffinity(Fort)`. + +#### Tested Claim +**Text:** When an enemy enters aura range, if that enemy is not on Fort, deal 1 damage to it. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**What works now:** `OnEnterAuraRange`, enemy ownership, target enemy unit, then conditional damage. + +**Issue:** There is no direct NOT condition for “not on Fort.” + +**Recommended R1 wording:** +> When an enemy enters this aura range, if it is on Hill, Forest, Lake, Marsh, Plains, Steppe, Swamp, Grove, Mountain, Ocean, or Island, deal 1 damage to it. + +That is ugly and not recommended. Better: +> When an enemy enters this aura range, deal 1 damage to it unless it is on Fort. + +**Needed support for exact version:** negation / `NotCondition` wrapper. + +--- + +### Serai, Living Charter of Ilyra + +#### Refuge Cannot Be Taken, Only Kept +**Text:** Friendly units on Hill, Forest, or Fort gain +1/+1. Friendly units on Fort also gain `CanBeObstructed = false`. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +**Why:** Terrain-conditioned passive stats and Fort-only flag rider are all already supported. + +#### Rewrite the Boundary +**Text:** Push Final Affinity: target tile becomes Fort. Then a friendly unit may move 1 tile. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**What works now:** tile targeting and `PushFinalAffinity(Fort)`. + +**Gap:** “then a friendly unit may move 1 tile” still wants arbitrary one-tile repositioning. + +**Recommended R1 wording:** +> Target tile becomes Fort. Then target friendly unit gains +1 MP this turn. + +#### Witness-Covenant +**Text:** The first time each turn a friendly unit on Fort would die, prevent that death and set it to 1 health. + +**Status:** Not currently implementable cleanly + +**Why:** The engine has `OnUnitDeath`, but not a pre-death replacement window or death prevention hook. + +**Needed support:** +- `BeforeUnitDeath` / `WouldDie` trigger +- cancel-death or replace-death effect +- optional once-per-turn trigger cap on triggered abilities + +--- + +## 2. Spirits + +### Root-Bridge Pathfinder +**Text:** When this moves onto Fort, gain 1 SP. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +**Why:** `OnUnitMove` with `ExactSelf` + current tile is Fort. + +### Cliffline Warrant Scribe +**Text:** On channel, a friendly unit gains +1 Defense until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Eyrie Debt Courier +**Text:** When this enters, another friendly unit may move 1 tile. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1 wording:** +> When this enters, another friendly unit gains +1 MP this turn. + +### Canopy Oathkeeper +**Text:** Aura 1: friendly units gain +1 Defense. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Fortline Mediator +**Text:** When this enters on Fort, draw 1 then discard 1. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Storm-Pledge Lancer +**Text:** If this attacks from or into Fort, it gains +1 Damage. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Issue:** The trigger system does not expose both source-tile and target-tile affinity for an attack in a clean condition. + +**Recommended R1 wording:** +> When this attacks while on Fort, it gains +1 Damage until end of turn. + +**Needed for exact version:** attack event payload with attacker origin tile and attack destination/target tile affinity. + +### Memory-Root Bailiff +**Text:** Active: target enemy loses `CanAttack` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Bastion Verge Ranger +**Text:** When this moves into Fort, it may move 1 additional tile. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1 wording:** +> When this moves onto Fort, it gains +1 MP this turn. + +### Glassfire Deceiver-Advocate +**Text:** On channel, expose a target enemy: it loses `CanBeBlocked` or `CanUseAbility` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**What works:** Either branch individually. + +**Gap:** `ChooseOne` exists in models but is not part of `AbilityDefinition.Actions` execution path in the current engine. + +**Recommended R1:** pick one printed version, most likely `CanUseAbility = false`. + +**Needed for exact version:** branch execution support for `ChooseOne` in abilities/effects. + +### Stormtusk Claim-Breaker +**Text:** On attack, push target 1 tile. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Shrine-Canopy Witness +**Text:** When a friendly unit enters aura range, that unit gains +1 Defense or +1 Damage until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Gap:** same missing branch-selection support as above. + +**Recommended R1:** choose one stable mode, probably `+1 Defense until end of turn`. + +### Gate-Spire Intercessor +**Text:** Enemies adjacent to Fort units have -1 Damage. + +**Status:** Not currently implementable cleanly + +**Why:** The engine can target adjacent-to-source or units-on-Fort, but this text asks for a set defined as **enemies adjacent to any friendly Fort unit**, which is a relational scan across one unit set onto another. + +**Needed support:** +- filter/condition like `IsAdjacentToUnitMatching(Filter...)` +- or passive aura-like projection from all Fort units + +### Mnemosyne Leak-Slime +**Text:** On enter, draw 1. If on Fort, draw 2 then discard 1 instead. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Issue:** “instead” wants mutually exclusive branching. + +**Recommended R1 wording:** +> If this enters on Fort, draw 2 then discard 1. Otherwise, draw 1. + +This still wants branching; current safest version is to print one branch only. + +**Best current R1:** +> On enter, draw 1. If this is on Fort, discard 1. + +or +> On enter on Fort, draw 2 then discard 1. + +### Sky-Law Manta +**Text:** Friendly Fort units in aura range gain `CanBeObstructed = false`. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Sunken Tribunal Raykeeper +**Text:** Target enemy on Fort or adjacent to Fort loses `CanMove` and `CanAttack` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**What works:** enemy on Fort. + +**Gap:** “adjacent to Fort” is tile-relative targeting not currently expressible as a clean condition on a unit. + +**Recommended R1 wording:** +> Target enemy on Fort loses `CanMove` and `CanAttack` until end of turn. + +**Needed for exact version:** condition/filter for unit adjacent to tile matching affinity. + +### Tusk-Lord of the Audit Storm +**Text:** Enemies damaged by this lose `CanMove` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Issue:** `OnDamageDealt` does not appear to filter by exact source cleanly in current matching logic. + +**Recommended R1 wording:** +> When this attacks a unit, that unit loses `CanMove` until end of turn. + +**Needed for exact version:** source-filterable damage trigger or exact-self source match on `OnDamageDealt`. + +### Polyphonic Sanctuary Hydra +**Text:** Friendly Fort units gain +1/+1 and the first one to enter aura range each turn draws 1. + +**Status:** Partially implementable + +**Works now:** Fort-unit passive +1/+1. + +**Gaps:** triggered once-per-turn cap on aura entry. + +**Needed support:** triggered `UsesPerTurn` / `TriggerLimitPerTurn`. + +--- + +## 3. Repentance + +### Boundary Injunction +**Text:** Target friendly unit gains `CanBeAttacked = false` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Upland Evacuation Route +**Text:** Move a friendly unit 1-2 tiles by effect / grant +2 MP this turn. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** `+2 MP until end of turn`. + +### Root-Memory Appeal +**Text:** Draw 2 then discard 1, or return a low-cost supportive piece from discard to hand. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Why:** each branch is individually implementable; exact modal choice needs branch support. + +**Recommended R1:** fixed `Draw 2 then discard 1`. + +### Raise the Sanctuary Wall +**Text:** Push Final Affinity to Fort on one tile, then a friendly unit gains +1 Defense. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Charter of Shared Refuge +**Text:** Until end of turn, friendly units on Fort gain +1/+1 and `CanUseAbility = true`. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +**Caveat:** If design intent is “cannot later be suppressed this turn,” the engine lacks hard override priority semantics. + +--- + +## 4. Ruin + +### Witness Stone of Ashen Mere +**Text:** At ruin activation, if occupied by a friendly unit, choose one at random: gain 1 SP; draw 1 then discard 1; target enemy in aura range loses `CanAttack` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +**Why:** The ruin system already supports multiple `OnRuinActivation` abilities and randomly selecting one eligible trigger. + +--- + +## 5. Instinct + +### Objection Under Witness +**Text:** target unit loses `CanAttack` until end of turn / sequence. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** until end of turn. + +**Needed for exact version:** `UntilEndOfSequence` duration. + +### Canopy Ambuscade Clause +**Text:** Push or displace a unit 1 tile, preferably away from Fort. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**What works:** a fixed push or fixed directional displacement. + +**What does not:** “preferably away from Fort” is intent text, not a current targeting primitive. + +### Highwind Extraction +**Text:** Friendly unit gains `CanBeAttacked = false` or is moved 1 tile. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** choose one printed version, preferably `CanBeAttacked = false until end of turn`. + +### Unwritten Path +**Text:** Stronger displacement / movement denial interrupt. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Comment:** Stronger fixed push/pull/`CanMove=false` version is feasible; open-ended interrupt timing language is not. + +--- + +## 6. Summary + +### Implementable now +- Sanctuary Is a Promise +- Witness Entry +- Legal Interdiction +- Refuge Cannot Be Taken, Only Kept +- Root-Bridge Pathfinder +- Cliffline Warrant Scribe +- Canopy Oathkeeper +- Fortline Mediator +- Memory-Root Bailiff +- Stormtusk Claim-Breaker +- Sky-Law Manta +- Boundary Injunction +- Raise the Sanctuary Wall +- Charter of Shared Refuge +- Witness Stone of Ashen Mere + +### Implementable with templating choice +- Boundaries with Teeth +- Tested Claim +- Rewrite the Boundary +- Eyrie Debt Courier +- Storm-Pledge Lancer +- Bastion Verge Ranger +- Glassfire Deceiver-Advocate +- Shrine-Canopy Witness +- Mnemosyne Leak-Slime +- Sunken Tribunal Raykeeper +- Tusk-Lord of the Audit Storm +- Polyphonic Sanctuary Hydra (trigger rider) +- Upland Evacuation Route +- Root-Memory Appeal +- Objection Under Witness +- Canopy Ambuscade Clause +- Highwind Extraction +- Unwritten Path + +### Not currently implementable cleanly +- Mark the Safe Route +- Witness-Covenant +- Gate-Spire Intercessor + +--- + +## 7. Engine gaps highlighted by this deck +- tile-bound delayed markers and first-enter tracking +- negation / `NotCondition` +- arbitrary one-tile reposition effect +- movement-state-sensitive unblockable/blocking flags +- relational targeting like “adjacent to a Fort unit” +- trigger branch / `ChooseOne` execution support +- attack-event tile context (`from` / `into` terrain) +- trigger frequency caps for triggered abilities +- death-prevention / replacement timing diff --git a/decks-r1/frosthallow_oaths_deck_white_truce_covenant.md b/decks-r1/frosthallow_oaths_deck_white_truce_covenant.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..626b068 --- /dev/null +++ b/decks-r1/frosthallow_oaths_deck_white_truce_covenant.md @@ -0,0 +1,331 @@ +# Frosthallow Oaths Deck R1 Conversion Audit — White Truce Covenant + +This document converts `frosthallow_oaths_deck_white_truce_covenant.md` into an engine-facing R1 audit against the current SOR ability system. + +--- + +## 1. ArchSpirit line + +### Ulla, Keeper of the Distress Fires + +#### Shelter Is Sacred +**Text:** Friendly units on Lake, Forest, or Swamp gain +1 Defense. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +#### Drag Them to Safety +**Text:** Move a friendly unit 1 tile. If it ends on Swamp, heal it 1. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Issue:** exact arbitrary one-tile reposition is not a clean first-class effect. + +**Recommended R1:** +> Target friendly unit gains +1 MP this turn. If it is on Swamp after moving this turn, heal it 1. + +Closest simpler version: +> Target friendly unit gains +1 MP this turn. If it is currently on Swamp, heal it 1. + +#### Rescue Bell Answered +**Text:** When a friendly Spirit enters battlefield in this aura range, gain +1 current defense on that unit. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +--- + +### Ulla, Shelter in the Storm + +#### Mercy Holds the Line +**Text:** Friendly Spirits on Swamp gain `CanBeBlocked = false` while moving and +1 Damage. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Gap:** movement-state-sensitive unblockable. + +**Recommended R1:** friendly Spirits on Swamp gain +1 Damage and `CanBeBlocked = false`. + +#### White Truce +**Text:** Target enemy loses `CanAttack` until end of turn. If that enemy is on Swamp, it also loses `CanMove`. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +#### Shared Hearth +**Text:** The first time each turn a friendly unit enters aura range, heal it 1. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Why:** trigger works; once-per-turn cap does not. + +--- + +### Ulla, Hearth of Hollowglass + +#### No One Dies Alone in Snow +**Text:** Friendly units on Lake, Forest, or Swamp gain +1/+1. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +#### Mark the Winter Refuge +**Text:** Push Final Affinity: target tile becomes Swamp. Then a friendly unit may move 1 tile. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** target tile becomes Swamp; target friendly unit gains +1 MP this turn. + +#### Covenant of Survival +**Text:** The first time each turn a friendly unit on Swamp would die, prevent that death and set it to 1 health. + +**Status:** Not currently implementable cleanly + +--- + +## 2. Spirits + +### Fjord Oath Ferrier +**Text:** When this enters on Swamp, draw 1 then discard 1. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Snowpine Trackguard +**Text:** When this moves onto Swamp, gain 1 SP. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Bell Loft Witness +**Text:** On channel, target enemy loses `CanUseAbility` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Ice-Ring Tender +**Text:** Aura 1: friendly units gain +1 Defense. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Thawland Oathbound +**Text:** Enemies entering adjacent Swamp lose `CanAttack` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Not currently implementable cleanly + +**Why:** This wants a trigger based on a unit entering a tile that is both: +- adjacent to this source, and +- Swamp. + +Current triggers can see unit movement and aura entry, but not “entered a tile adjacent to source with specified affinity” as a single clean event/condition. + +**Needed support:** destination-tile-aware movement triggers with relation-to-source filtering. + +### Rimefjord Ledger Warden +**Text:** On enter, gain 1 SP if you control a Swamp tile. + +**Status:** Not currently implementable cleanly + +**Why:** There is no current battlefield/tile condition for “controller has at least one tile of affinity X.” + +**Needed support:** player-side tile-control condition, e.g. `ControlledTileCountWithAffinity`. + +### Whiteout Pack Mediator +**Text:** Active: target enemy loses `CanMove` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Selene Hollow Covenantor +**Text:** Friendly units on Swamp in aura range gain +1 Damage. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Avalanche Bell-Mother +**Text:** When another friendly unit enters aura range, heal it 1. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Blackwater Bargain-Keeper +**Text:** On attack, pull target 1 tile. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Circle of the Seventh Egg +**Text:** Friendly adjacent units have `CanBeAttacked = false` during your turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +**Why:** passive targeting adjacent friendlies using `IsAdjacentToSource` filter plus `IsOwnTurnCondition` and `SetCanBeAttacked(false)`. + +### Glacier Forgebinder +**Text:** If this attacks a unit on Swamp, that unit also loses `CanMove` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Issue:** exact attack target tile affinity is not cleanly exposed in trigger/condition flow. + +**Recommended R1:** when this attacks while on Swamp, target loses `CanMove` until end of turn. + +### Stormcrown Omen Reader +**Text:** On enter, reveal the top card; if it is a Repentance or Instinct, draw it. + +**Status:** Not currently implementable cleanly + +**Why:** `RevealCardsEffect` exists, but there is no robust follow-up branch on revealed card type with top-deck reference carried into subsequent action resolution. + +**Needed support:** reveal-result references and conditional action branching over revealed card metadata. + +### Red Snow Witness-Dead +**Text:** Enemies in aura range have -1 Damage. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Hask, Fang Against the Feud +**Text:** Friendly units entering Swamp gain `CanMove = true` this turn. + +**Status:** Not currently implementable cleanly + +**Why:** this wants a trigger keyed to entering Swamp specifically, then applying a flag to the entering unit. +Current movement triggers can inspect the unit after movement, but not all board movements will necessarily pass through a convenient source-owned trigger unless reworded. + +**Recommended R1:** +> When a friendly unit enters this aura range, it gains +1 MP this turn. + +**Needed for exact version:** destination-affinity movement trigger. + +### Long Night Covenant Whale +**Text:** Friendly Swamp units gain +1/+1 and the first one to enter aura range each turn heals 1. + +**Status:** Partially implementable + +**Works now:** Swamp-unit passive +1/+1. + +**Gap:** once-per-turn aura-entry heal. + +--- + +## 3. Repentance + +### Shelter Bell Toll +**Text:** Friendly unit gains `CanBeAttacked = false` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Blackwater Crossing +**Text:** Move a friendly unit 1-2 tiles. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** friendly unit gains +2 MP this turn. + +### Mercy Before Feud +**Text:** Target enemy loses `CanAttack` until end of turn; if on Swamp, also loses `CanUseAbility`. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Renew the Winter Covenant +**Text:** Push Final Affinity to Swamp on one tile, then heal a friendly unit 1. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### The Circle Holds +**Text:** Friendly units on Swamp gain +1/+1 and `CanBeBlocked = false` while moving until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** drop the “while moving” rider or make it unconditional while on Swamp. + +--- + +## 4. Ruin + +### Oathstone Beneath the Drift +**Text:** If occupied by a friendly unit, choose one at random: heal occupant 2; gain 1 SP; target enemy in aura range loses `CanAttack` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +--- + +## 5. Instinct + +### Turn Them from the Shelter +**Text:** Target unit loses `CanAttack` until end of sequence. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** until end of turn. + +### Whiteout Step +**Text:** Friendly unit gains `CanBeAttacked = false` or moves 1 tile. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** pick one mode; safest is `CanBeAttacked = false until end of turn`. + +### Icewake Undertow +**Text:** Push or pull a unit 1 tile. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Gap:** modal choice wants branch support. + +**Recommended R1:** pick push or pull as the printed card. + +### No Blood on the Oathground +**Text:** Prevent a death or heavy damage event on Swamp. + +**Status:** Not currently implementable cleanly + +**Needed:** damage prevention / death replacement framework with action-window timing. + +--- + +## 6. Summary + +### Implementable now +- Shelter Is Sacred +- Rescue Bell Answered +- White Truce +- No One Dies Alone in Snow +- Fjord Oath Ferrier +- Snowpine Trackguard +- Bell Loft Witness +- Ice-Ring Tender +- Whiteout Pack Mediator +- Selene Hollow Covenantor +- Avalanche Bell-Mother +- Blackwater Bargain-Keeper +- Circle of the Seventh Egg +- Red Snow Witness-Dead +- Shelter Bell Toll +- Mercy Before Feud +- Renew the Winter Covenant +- Oathstone Beneath the Drift + +### Implementable with templating choice +- Drag Them to Safety +- Mercy Holds the Line +- Shared Hearth +- Mark the Winter Refuge +- Glacier Forgebinder +- Long Night Covenant Whale (trigger rider) +- Blackwater Crossing +- The Circle Holds +- Turn Them from the Shelter +- Whiteout Step +- Icewake Undertow + +### Not currently implementable cleanly +- Covenant of Survival +- Thawland Oathbound +- Rimefjord Ledger Warden +- Stormcrown Omen Reader +- Hask, Fang Against the Feud +- No Blood on the Oathground + +--- + +## 7. Engine gaps highlighted by this deck +- arbitrary one-tile reposition +- triggered once-per-turn caps +- pre-death replacement timing +- destination-tile-aware movement triggers +- player tile-control conditions +- reveal-result references and reveal branching +- movement-state-sensitive `CanBeBlocked` +- modal branch support +- end-of-sequence duration +- damage prevention framework diff --git a/decks-r1/greenveil_reckoning_deck_crownseed_remembrance.md b/decks-r1/greenveil_reckoning_deck_crownseed_remembrance.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d32545e --- /dev/null +++ b/decks-r1/greenveil_reckoning_deck_crownseed_remembrance.md @@ -0,0 +1,291 @@ +# Greenveil Reckoning Deck R1 Conversion Audit — Crownseed Remembrance + +This document converts `greenveil_reckoning_deck_crownseed_remembrance.md` into an engine-facing R1 audit against the current SOR ability model. + +--- + +## 1. ArchSpirit line + +### Elowen, Archive Nestling + +#### Record What the Forest Knows +**Text:** Friendly units on Field, Forest, or Grove gain +1 Defense. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +#### Quiet Citation +**Text:** Target enemy loses `CanUseAbility` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +#### Recover the Name +**Text:** When a friendly Spirit enters battlefield on Grove, draw 1 then discard 1 once per turn. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Why:** trigger and looting effect are fine; once-per-turn cap is missing. + +--- + +### Elowen, Voice in the Silent Wood + +#### Accord Restored in Parts +**Text:** Friendly Spirits on Grove gain +1 Damage and `CanBeBlocked = false` while moving. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** friendly Spirits on Grove gain +1 Damage and `CanBeBlocked = false`. + +#### Sign-Lantern Verdict +**Text:** Target enemy loses `CanMove` until end of turn. If it is on Grove, it also loses `CanAttack`. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +#### Testimony Preserved +**Text:** The first time each turn a friendly unit enters aura range, heal it 1. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +--- + +### Elowen, First Scribe of Greenveil + +#### The Forest Remembers Everyone +**Text:** Friendly units on Field, Forest, or Grove gain +1/+1. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +#### Rewrite the Accord +**Text:** Push Final Affinity: target tile becomes Grove. Then a friendly unit may move 1 tile. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** target tile becomes Grove; target friendly unit gains +1 MP this turn. + +#### No Name Erased +**Text:** The first time each turn a friendly unit on Grove would die, prevent that death and set it to 1 health. + +**Status:** Not currently implementable cleanly + +--- + +## 2. Spirits + +### Root Archive Clerk +**Text:** On channel, draw 1 then discard 1. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Mosstrail Forager +**Text:** When this moves onto Grove, gain 1 SP. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Reedhorn Purifier +**Text:** On enter, heal a friendly unit 2. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Thornpath Magistrate +**Text:** Target enemy loses `CanUseAbility` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Canopy Stormling +**Text:** When this enters, another friendly unit may move 1 tile. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** another friendly unit gains +1 MP this turn. + +### Lunasyl Rememberer +**Text:** When this enters on Grove, draw 1. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Roothelm Claim-Warden +**Text:** Active: target enemy loses `CanMove` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Accord Glade Warden +**Text:** Aura 1: friendly units on Grove gain +1 Damage. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Witchwood Collar-Breaker +**Text:** On attack, target enemy loses `CanUseAbility` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +**Note:** This is simpler than source-qualified damage triggers because `OnUnitAttack` exists and can target the attacked unit. + +### Briarthorn Echo-Speaker +**Text:** Friendly units entering aura range heal 1. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Iron-Eater Totembeast +**Text:** Enemies adjacent to this have -1 Defense. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Crownseed Restorer +**Text:** The first time each turn a friendly unit would die in this aura range, heal it 1 before damage finalizes. + +**Status:** Not currently implementable cleanly + +**Why:** This is a damage/death prevention replacement effect with aura scoping and pre-finalization timing. + +**Needed support:** +- `WouldTakeLethalDamage` or `BeforeUnitDeath` +- replacement/prevention resolution window +- once-per-turn trigger cap + +### Skythorn Trial-Raptor +**Text:** Friendly Grove units in aura range gain `CanBeObstructed = false`. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Palegrove Chorus-Mother +**Text:** When this enters, return a 2-cost or less Spirit from discard to hand. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +**Why:** `TargetScope.Discard`, `TargetType.Spirit`, ownership owner, cost-range filter, `ReturnToHand`. + +### Serrat, Warden Below the New Accord +**Text:** On enter, convert an adjacent tile to Grove. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Crownseed Memory-Stag +**Text:** Friendly Grove units gain +1/+1 and the first one you channel each turn draws 1 then discards 1. + +**Status:** Partially implementable + +**Works now:** passive Grove-unit stat buff. + +**Gap:** once-per-turn channel trigger rider. + +--- + +## 3. Repentance + +### Quiet the Witchwood +**Text:** Target enemy loses `CanAttack` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Return the Name +**Text:** Draw 2 then discard 1, or recover a small support piece later in tuning. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** fix the card as `Draw 2 then discard 1` for now. + +### Lantern-Sign Inquiry +**Text:** Target enemy loses `CanUseAbility` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Replant the Accord +**Text:** Push Final Affinity to Grove on one tile, then heal a friendly unit 1. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### No Soul Excluded +**Text:** Friendly units on Grove gain +1/+1 and `CanUseAbility = true` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +--- + +## 4. Ruin + +### Hollow of the First Branch +**Text:** If occupied by a friendly unit, choose one at random: draw 1 then discard 1; heal occupant 2; gain 1 SP. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +--- + +## 5. Instinct + +### Branch Between Fangs +**Text:** Friendly unit gains `CanBeAttacked = false` for the sequence or target enemy loses `CanAttack`. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Gap:** modal choice plus end-of-sequence duration. + +**Recommended R1:** pick one mode and use until end of turn. + +### Phase-Slip Through Roots +**Text:** Move a friendly unit 1 tile. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** friendly unit gains +1 MP this turn. + +### Silent Verdict +**Text:** Target unit loses `CanUseAbility` or `CanMove` until end of sequence. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** choose one mode; until end of turn. + +--- + +## 6. Summary + +### Implementable now +- Record What the Forest Knows +- Quiet Citation +- Sign-Lantern Verdict +- The Forest Remembers Everyone +- Root Archive Clerk +- Mosstrail Forager +- Reedhorn Purifier +- Thornpath Magistrate +- Lunasyl Rememberer +- Roothelm Claim-Warden +- Accord Glade Warden +- Witchwood Collar-Breaker +- Briarthorn Echo-Speaker +- Iron-Eater Totembeast +- Skythorn Trial-Raptor +- Palegrove Chorus-Mother +- Serrat, Warden Below the New Accord +- Quiet the Witchwood +- Lantern-Sign Inquiry +- Replant the Accord +- No Soul Excluded +- Hollow of the First Branch + +### Implementable with templating choice +- Recover the Name +- Accord Restored in Parts +- Testimony Preserved +- Rewrite the Accord +- Canopy Stormling +- Crownseed Memory-Stag (trigger rider) +- Return the Name +- Branch Between Fangs +- Phase-Slip Through Roots +- Silent Verdict + +### Not currently implementable cleanly +- No Name Erased +- Crownseed Restorer + +--- + +## 7. Engine gaps highlighted by this deck +- triggered once-per-turn caps +- movement-state-sensitive `CanBeBlocked` +- arbitrary one-tile reposition +- pre-death replacement timing +- lethal-damage prevention before finalization +- modal branch support +- end-of-sequence duration diff --git a/decks-r1/sunscar_caravans_deck_sun_ledger_procession.md b/decks-r1/sunscar_caravans_deck_sun_ledger_procession.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..19a5c7f --- /dev/null +++ b/decks-r1/sunscar_caravans_deck_sun_ledger_procession.md @@ -0,0 +1,283 @@ +# Sunscar Caravans Deck R1 Conversion Audit — Sun Ledger Procession + +This document converts `sunscar_caravans_deck_sun_ledger_procession.md` into an engine-facing R1 audit against the current SOR ability model. + +--- + +## 1. ArchSpirit line + +### Sevra, Keeper of Measured Thirst + +#### Water Is Public Duty +**Text:** Friendly units on Field, Mountain, or Steppe gain +1 Defense. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +#### Audit the Route +**Text:** Target enemy loses `CanUseAbility` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +#### Caravan Counted +**Text:** When a friendly Spirit enters battlefield on Steppe, gain +1 SP once per turn. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +--- + +### Sevra, Breaker of the Hidden Seal + +#### Law Travels Faster Than Greed +**Text:** Friendly Spirits on Steppe gain +1 Damage and `CanBeBlocked = false` while moving. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** make `CanBeBlocked = false` unconditional while on Steppe. + +#### Mark the Public Road +**Text:** Target enemy loses `CanMove` until end of turn. If on Steppe, it also loses `CanAttack`. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +#### Proper Distribution +**Text:** The first time each turn another friendly unit enters aura range, draw 1 then discard 1. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +--- + +### Sevra, Mother of the Open Wells + +#### Shared Water, Shared Horizon +**Text:** Friendly units on Field, Mountain, or Steppe gain +1/+1. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +#### Reopen the Caravan Way +**Text:** Push Final Affinity: target tile becomes Steppe. Then a friendly unit may move 1 tile. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** target tile becomes Steppe; target friendly unit gains +1 MP this turn. + +#### No Caravan Seized +**Text:** The first time each turn a friendly unit on Steppe would die, prevent that death and set it to 1 health. + +**Status:** Not currently implementable cleanly + +--- + +## 2. Spirits + +### Sidepath Burrow Runner +**Text:** When this moves onto Steppe, draw 1 then discard 1. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Wellsquare Registrar +**Text:** On channel, a friendly unit gains +1 Defense until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Dustwind Sylph Courier +**Text:** When this enters, another friendly unit may move 1 tile. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** another friendly unit gains +1 MP this turn. + +### Oasis Lantern Steward +**Text:** Aura 1: friendly units gain +1 Defense. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Steppe Ledger Rider +**Text:** When this enters on Steppe, gain 1 SP. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Sunvault Mason +**Text:** Active: target enemy loses `CanMove` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Bazaar Mask Trickster +**Text:** On enter, target enemy loses `CanUseAbility` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Common Road Pathfinder +**Text:** When this moves into Steppe, it may move 1 additional tile. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** when this moves onto Steppe, it gains +1 MP this turn. + +### Saltwind Pack Spear +**Text:** On attack, push target 1 tile. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Veiled Spring Adjudicator +**Text:** Friendly Steppe units in aura range gain +1 Damage. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Brass Sepulcher Basilisk +**Text:** On enter, target enemy loses `CanAttack` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Canal-Heart Mechanist +**Text:** Start of your turn: if this is on Steppe, gain 1 SP. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Sun Ledger Processioner +**Text:** On enter, convert an adjacent tile to Steppe. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Canyon Gale Standard +**Text:** Friendly units in aura range gain `CanBeObstructed = false`. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Samir, Grace of Shared Water +**Text:** Enemies adjacent to Steppe tiles have -1 Damage. + +**Status:** Not currently implementable cleanly + +**Why:** This is a tile-relative global relation: enemy units adjacent to any Steppe tile. The current system lacks a unit filter keyed to adjacency-to-tile-with-affinity. + +**Needed support:** filter/condition like `IsAdjacentToTileMatching(Affinity=Steppe)`. + +### Open Wells Colossus +**Text:** Friendly Steppe units gain +1/+1 and the first one to move each turn gains +1 MP. + +**Status:** Partially implementable + +**Works now:** Steppe-unit passive +1/+1. + +**Gap:** once-per-turn first-move trigger. + +--- + +## 3. Repentance + +### Water for the Road +**Text:** Friendly unit gains `CanBeAttacked = false` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Expose the Toll Fraud +**Text:** Target enemy loses `CanUseAbility` until end of turn; draw 1. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Incomplete Map, Honest Path +**Text:** Move a friendly unit 1-2 tiles. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** friendly unit gains +2 MP this turn. + +### Reopen the Canyon Way +**Text:** Push Final Affinity to Steppe on one tile, then a friendly unit gains +1 Damage. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### The Ledger Speaks at Sunrise +**Text:** Friendly units on Steppe gain +1/+1 and `CanUseAbility = true` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +--- + +## 4. Ruin + +### Broken Cistern of Nahar +**Text:** If occupied by a friendly unit, choose one at random: gain 1 SP; draw 1 then discard 1; target enemy in aura range loses `CanMove` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +--- + +## 5. Instinct + +### Sand-Swerve Intercept +**Text:** Target unit loses `CanAttack` until end of sequence. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** until end of turn. + +### Mirage Detour +**Text:** Move or displace a unit 1 tile. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Why:** fixed displacement is possible; open modal “move or displace” is not clean without choosing a template. + +### Canyon Rebuke +**Text:** Target enemy loses `CanMove` or `CanUseAbility` until end of sequence. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** choose one mode; until end of turn. + +--- + +## 6. Summary + +### Implementable now +- Water Is Public Duty +- Audit the Route +- Mark the Public Road +- Shared Water, Shared Horizon +- Sidepath Burrow Runner +- Wellsquare Registrar +- Oasis Lantern Steward +- Steppe Ledger Rider +- Sunvault Mason +- Bazaar Mask Trickster +- Saltwind Pack Spear +- Veiled Spring Adjudicator +- Brass Sepulcher Basilisk +- Canal-Heart Mechanist +- Sun Ledger Processioner +- Canyon Gale Standard +- Water for the Road +- Expose the Toll Fraud +- Reopen the Canyon Way +- The Ledger Speaks at Sunrise +- Broken Cistern of Nahar + +### Implementable with templating choice +- Caravan Counted +- Law Travels Faster Than Greed +- Proper Distribution +- Reopen the Caravan Way +- Dustwind Sylph Courier +- Common Road Pathfinder +- Open Wells Colossus (trigger rider) +- Incomplete Map, Honest Path +- Sand-Swerve Intercept +- Mirage Detour +- Canyon Rebuke + +### Not currently implementable cleanly +- No Caravan Seized +- Samir, Grace of Shared Water + +--- + +## 7. Engine gaps highlighted by this deck +- triggered once-per-turn caps +- movement-state-sensitive `CanBeBlocked` +- arbitrary one-tile reposition +- pre-death replacement timing +- tile-relative unit filters like adjacency-to-Steppe +- first-move-per-turn trigger caps +- end-of-sequence duration +- modal branch support diff --git a/decks-r1/tidecrown_intrigue_deck_open_harbors_claim.md b/decks-r1/tidecrown_intrigue_deck_open_harbors_claim.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..6b167b4 --- /dev/null +++ b/decks-r1/tidecrown_intrigue_deck_open_harbors_claim.md @@ -0,0 +1,291 @@ +# Tidecrown Intrigue Deck R1 Conversion Audit — Open Harbors Claim + +This document converts `tidecrown_intrigue_deck_open_harbors_claim.md` into an engine-facing R1 audit against the current SOR ability model. + +--- + +## 1. ArchSpirit line + +### Ilyra, Exiled Daughter + +#### Steward of Tides, Not Owner +**Text:** Friendly units on Lake, Ocean, or Island gain +1 Defense. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +#### Recall the Convoy +**Text:** Target friendly unit may move 1 tile. If it ends on Island, draw 1 then discard 1. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Issue:** arbitrary one-tile reposition is not first-class. + +**Recommended R1:** target friendly unit gains +1 MP this turn. If it is currently on Island, draw 1 then discard 1. + +#### Harbor Testimony +**Text:** When a friendly Spirit enters battlefield on Island, gain +1 SP once per turn. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +--- + +### Ilyra, Tide-Law Restorer + +#### Open Harbor Doctrine +**Text:** Friendly Spirits on Island gain +1 Damage and `CanBeObstructed = false`. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +#### Seize the Registry +**Text:** Target enemy loses `CanMove` until end of turn. If that enemy is on Island, it also loses `CanAttack`. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +#### Safe Passage Recognized +**Text:** The first time each turn another friendly unit enters aura range, that unit gains +1 current defense. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +--- + +### Ilyra, Crown of Open Harbors + +#### Let the Hungry Through +**Text:** Friendly units on Lake, Ocean, or Island gain +1/+1. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +#### Reopen the Harbor Chain +**Text:** Push Final Affinity: target tile becomes Island. Then a friendly unit may move 1 tile. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** target tile becomes Island; target friendly unit gains +1 MP this turn. + +#### No Convoy Turned Away +**Text:** The first time each turn a friendly unit on Island would die, prevent that death and set it to 1 health. + +**Status:** Not currently implementable cleanly + +--- + +## 2. Spirits + +### Dock-Warren Listener +**Text:** On channel, draw 1 then discard 1. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Skywake Relay Squire +**Text:** When this moves onto Island, gain 1 SP. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Ballast Fault Reader +**Text:** On enter, target enemy loses `CanUseAbility` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Shrineback Currentbearer +**Text:** Aura 1: friendly units gain +1 Defense. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Island Registry Keeper +**Text:** When this enters on Island, draw 1. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Frostglass Winterguard +**Text:** Adjacent enemies have -1 Damage. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Galecrest Rescue Rider +**Text:** When this enters, another friendly unit may move 1 tile. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** another friendly unit gains +1 MP this turn. + +### Open Harbor Adjudicator +**Text:** Active: target enemy loses `CanAttack` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Mourning Tide Witness +**Text:** On enter, target enemy loses `CanMove` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Harbor Chain Marshal +**Text:** Friendly Island units in aura range gain +1 Damage. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Drowned Archive Diver +**Text:** Draw 1 then discard 1; if on Island, draw 2 then discard 1 instead. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Issue:** exact “instead” branch wants mutually exclusive branch support. + +**Recommended R1:** pick one branch, preferably `if this enters on Island, draw 2 then discard 1`. + +### Storm Coast Interceptor +**Text:** Friendly units moving into Island gain `CanBeBlocked = false` this turn. + +**Status:** Not currently implementable cleanly + +**Why:** This is destination-affinity movement triggering combined with a temporary flag on the entering unit. + +**Needed support:** movement trigger with destination tile affinity in event data. + +### Shellfather Convoyback +**Text:** The first time each turn a friendly unit enters aura range, heal it 1. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +### Wake-Choir Accuser +**Text:** Enemies in aura range lose `CanUseAbility`. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Joren, Last Writ Through the Gale +**Text:** On enter, another friendly unit may move 1 tile and gain `CanBeAttacked = false` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**What works:** the protection rider. + +**Gap:** arbitrary one-tile movement. + +**Recommended R1:** another friendly unit gains +1 MP and `CanBeAttacked = false` until end of turn. + +### Tidecrown Leviathan +**Text:** Friendly Island units gain +1/+1 and the first one to enter Island each turn draws 1 then discards 1. + +**Status:** Partially implementable + +**Works now:** passive Island-unit +1/+1. + +**Gaps:** first-enter-Island trigger with per-turn cap and destination affinity awareness. + +--- + +## 3. Repentance + +### Harbor Amnesty +**Text:** Friendly unit gains `CanBeAttacked = false` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Seize the Ballast Logs +**Text:** Draw 2 then discard 1. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Stormlane Reroute +**Text:** Move a friendly unit 1-2 tiles. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** friendly unit gains +2 MP this turn. + +### Restore the Harbor Chain +**Text:** Push Final Affinity to Island on one tile, then a friendly unit gains +1 Defense. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +### Maritime Justice Declared +**Text:** Friendly units on Island gain +1/+1 and `CanUseAbility = true` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +--- + +## 4. Ruin + +### Queen’s Lantern Reef +**Text:** If occupied by a friendly unit, choose one at random: gain 1 SP; draw 1 then discard 1; target enemy in aura range loses `CanAttack` until end of turn. + +**Status:** Implementable now + +--- + +## 5. Instinct + +### Cut the Smuggler’s Line +**Text:** Target enemy loses `CanMove` until end of sequence. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** until end of turn. + +### Breakwater Shelter +**Text:** Friendly unit gains `CanBeAttacked = false` or moves 1 tile. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** pick one printed version; safest is protection only. + +### The Dead Point and Speak +**Text:** Target enemy loses `CanUseAbility` or `CanAttack` until end of sequence. + +**Status:** Implementable with templating choice + +**Recommended R1:** choose one mode and use until end of turn. + +--- + +## 6. Summary + +### Implementable now +- Steward of Tides, Not Owner +- Open Harbor Doctrine +- Seize the Registry +- Let the Hungry Through +- Dock-Warren Listener +- Skywake Relay Squire +- Ballast Fault Reader +- Shrineback Currentbearer +- Island Registry Keeper +- Frostglass Winterguard +- Open Harbor Adjudicator +- Mourning Tide Witness +- Harbor Chain Marshal +- Wake-Choir Accuser +- Harbor Amnesty +- Seize the Ballast Logs +- Restore the Harbor Chain +- Maritime Justice Declared +- Queen’s Lantern Reef + +### Implementable with templating choice +- Recall the Convoy +- Harbor Testimony +- Safe Passage Recognized +- Reopen the Harbor Chain +- Galecrest Rescue Rider +- Drowned Archive Diver +- Shellfather Convoyback +- Joren, Last Writ Through the Gale +- Tidecrown Leviathan (trigger rider) +- Stormlane Reroute +- Cut the Smuggler’s Line +- Breakwater Shelter +- The Dead Point and Speak + +### Not currently implementable cleanly +- No Convoy Turned Away +- Storm Coast Interceptor + +--- + +## 7. Engine gaps highlighted by this deck +- arbitrary one-tile reposition +- triggered once-per-turn caps +- pre-death replacement timing +- destination-affinity movement triggers +- exact `instead` branching / modal branch support +- end-of-sequence duration diff --git a/sor_ability_system_gaps_found_via_deck_conversion.md b/sor_ability_system_gaps_found_via_deck_conversion.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..b38932c --- /dev/null +++ b/sor_ability_system_gaps_found_via_deck_conversion.md @@ -0,0 +1,353 @@ +# SOR Ability System Gaps Found via Deck Conversion + +This document summarizes the recurring engine gaps found while converting the R1 deck audits for: +- `red_shift_exodus_deck_orison_migration_covenant.md` +- `eclipse_frontier_deck_lattice_witness_compact.md` +- `amberthrone_fields_deck_grain_oath_concord.md` +- `frosthallow_oaths_deck_white_truce_covenant.md` +- `greenveil_reckoning_deck_crownseed_remembrance.md` +- `sunscar_caravans_deck_sun_ledger_procession.md` +- `tidecrown_intrigue_deck_open_harbors_claim.md` + +The current SOR ability system is already pretty capable for: +- terrain-conditioned passives +- straightforward actives with costs and ranges +- aura entry triggers +- stat buffs/debuffs +- flag changes like `CanMove`, `CanAttack`, `CanBeAttacked`, `CanUseAbility` +- tile affinity rewriting +- push/pull displacement +- random ruin activations +- zone actions like draw, discard, and simple return-to-hand + +The repeated pressure points are not about raw complexity so much as **state memory, relational targeting, and replacement timing**. + +--- + +## 1. Highest-value engine additions + +If only a few additions are made, these would unlock the most design space across all audited decks. + +### 1.1 Trigger frequency caps for triggered abilities +Repeated need: +- “once per turn” +- “the first time each turn” + +Examples: +- Brakka / Sevra / Ilyra / Elowen / Ulla tier-1 economy triggers +- aura-entry riders on multiple tier-2/tier-3 leaders and mythics +- Polyphonic Sanctuary Hydra / Long Night Covenant Whale / Open Wells Colossus / Tidecrown Leviathan + +**Current issue:** `UsesPerTurn` exists only for Active abilities. + +**Recommended addition:** +- `TriggerLimitPerTurn` or `UsesPerTurn` on `Triggered` abilities +- optional per-source vs per-card-definition semantics + +**Impact:** very high. This fixes a huge class of nearly-implementable text without touching targeting or combat rules. + +--- + +### 1.2 First-class reposition effect +Repeated need: +- “move a friendly unit 1 tile” +- “another friendly unit may move 1 tile” +- “move into or adjacent to target tile” + +Examples: +- multiple courier/escort cards across all decks +- many ArchSpirit tier-3 “target tile becomes X, then a friendly unit may move 1 tile” abilities +- many Repentance and Instinct cards using emergency repositioning + +**Current issue:** +The engine has `PushUnit`, `PullUnit`, `DisplaceUnit`, and `GrantMovementControl`, but not a clean “choose adjacent legal destination” effect. + +**Recommended addition:** +- `RepositionUnitEffect` +- destination constraints: + - adjacent legal tile + - adjacent to source + - into / adjacent to a previously targeted tile + - optional ownership/pathing restrictions + +**Impact:** very high. This would remove the single most common templating compromise in the audits. + +--- + +### 1.3 Replacement / prevention timing +Repeated need: +- “would die instead survive at 1” +- “prevent damage” +- “before damage finalizes” + +Examples: +- all tier-3 leader survival covenants +- Crownseed Restorer +- Night Dock Amnesty / No Blood on the Oathground style effects + +**Current issue:** +The engine has `OnUnitDeath` and `OnDamagePrevented`, but no clean **pre-resolution replacement window**. + +**Recommended addition:** +- new triggers like `BeforeUnitDeath`, `BeforeDamageApplied`, or `WouldTakeLethalDamage` +- effects such as: + - `PreventDeathEffect` + - `SetHealthMinimumEffect` + - `PreventNextDamageEffect` +- optional sequence-scoped durations + +**Impact:** very high. This unlocks the decks’ most iconic “mercy / rescue / covenant” mechanics. + +--- + +### 1.4 Destination-aware movement event data +Repeated need: +- “when this moves onto X” is fine if current tile check is enough +- but many cards need more: “moves into X,” “enters Island,” “crosses onto Marsh,” “entering adjacent Swamp,” “moving into Island gain unblockable,” etc. + +Examples: +- Pressure-Veil Djinn +- Thawland Oathbound +- Hask, Fang Against the Feud +- Storm Coast Interceptor +- Tidecrown Leviathan trigger rider +- attack / move riders involving “from or into” terrain + +**Current issue:** +Movement triggers do not expose previous tile, destination tile, or path-crossing info in a broadly usable condition model. + +**Recommended addition:** +- movement event payload fields: + - `SourceTile` + - `DestinationTile` + - `CrossedTiles` or at least destination +- conditions: + - `DestinationTileAffinityIs` + - `PreviousTileAffinityIs` + - `MovedFromOrIntoAffinity` + +**Impact:** high. + +--- + +## 2. Strongly recurring secondary gaps + +### 2.1 Movement-state-sensitive flag application +Repeated need: +- `CanBeBlocked = false while moving` +- sometimes similar “only during movement” text + +Examples across multiple decks: +- Serai tier-2 +- Brakka roads package +- Ulla tier-2 +- Elowen tier-2 +- Sevra tier-2 + +**Current issue:** +The engine can set `CanBeBlocked`, but not condition it on “currently resolving movement.” + +**Recommended addition:** +- movement-phase condition/state flag +- or support for scoped effect windows like `DuringMovement` + +**Impact:** medium-high. Very common rider text. + +--- + +### 2.2 Relational targeting / filtering beyond source adjacency +Repeated need: +- enemies adjacent to **Fort units** +- enemies adjacent to **Steppe tiles** +- unit on Fort **or adjacent to Fort** +- unit adjacent to a tile with affinity X + +Examples: +- Gate-Spire Intercessor +- Sunken Tribunal Raykeeper +- Samir, Grace of Shared Water +- several other adjacency-to-terrain ideas + +**Current issue:** +The engine has `IsAdjacentToSourceFilter` and some tile filters, but not richer relational filters from one arbitrary set to another. + +**Recommended addition:** +- `IsAdjacentToUnitMatching(Filter...)` +- `IsAdjacentToTileMatching(Filter...)` +- `UnitOnOrAdjacentToAffinityCondition` + +**Impact:** high for positional deck design. + +--- + +### 2.3 Negation / NOT conditions +Repeated need: +- “if that enemy is not on Fort” +- inverse terrain checks + +**Current issue:** +Conditions support `AND`, `OR`, `XOR` but no explicit `NOT`. + +**Recommended addition:** +- `NotCondition` + +**Impact:** medium. Small implementation, broad templating payoff. + +--- + +### 2.4 Modal branch support / ChooseOne execution +Repeated need: +- “choose one” modes +- “A or B” on enter or in Instinct/Repentance cards +- “instead” branches that want exclusive resolution + +Examples: +- Shrine-Canopy Witness +- Glassfire Deceiver-Advocate +- Root-Memory Appeal +- Return the Name variants +- many Instinct cards with protection-or-move / push-or-pull / one flag or another + +**Current issue:** +`ChooseOne` types exist in `Action.cs`, but `AbilityDefinition.Actions` is still `Action[]`, and `AbilitySystem.ExecuteActions` only processes `Action[]`. + +**Recommended addition:** +- lift `Actions` to support `Action | ChooseOne` nodes +- add resolver path and client choice plumbing + +**Impact:** high for card variety and cleaner templating. + +--- + +### 2.5 End-of-sequence / action-window duration +Repeated need: +- “until end of sequence” +- “this action” prevention +- interrupt-window-only safety effects + +Examples: +- many Instinct cards +- action-window damage prevention cards + +**Current issue:** +Current durations include `UntilEndOfTurn`, `UntilStartOfOwnerTurn`, `ForNTurns`, etc., but not a stack/sequence lifetime. + +**Recommended addition:** +- `UntilEndOfSequence` +- possibly `UntilCurrentActionResolves` + +**Impact:** medium-high for reactive card design. + +--- + +## 3. Niche but still valuable additions + +### 3.1 Named-card / card-ref presence conditions +Needed for text like: +- “if Brakka is in play” + +**Recommended addition:** +- battlefield condition by definition ID / ability source card name / card ref + +### 3.2 Player tile-control conditions +Needed for text like: +- “if you control a Swamp tile” + +**Recommended addition:** +- `ControlledTileCountWithAffinityCondition` +- or general tile-count query conditions + +### 3.3 Reveal-result references +Needed for text like: +- “reveal top card; if it is Repentance or Instinct, draw it” + +**Recommended addition:** +- revealed card references in action context +- card-type conditions on revealed cards + +### 3.4 Source-qualified damage triggers +Needed for text like: +- “enemies damaged by this” + +**Recommended addition:** +- `OnDamageDealt` filtering by exact source instance or source filter + +### 3.5 Tile-bound delayed markers +Needed for text like: +- “mark target tile; the next friendly unit to move onto it gains X” + +**Recommended addition:** +- deferred effects anchored to tile coordinates with one-shot consumption + +--- + +## 4. What the current system already does well + +These deck passes also confirm that the current engine is already strong in a lot of useful ways. + +### 4.1 Terrain-conditioned passives +Using: +- `IsOnTileWithAffinityCondition` +- passive actions +- `WhileSourceOnBattlefield` tracking + +This supports a lot of deck identity already. + +### 4.2 Basic tempo control +Very common card text already works: +- lose `CanMove` +- lose `CanAttack` +- lose `CanUseAbility` +- gain `CanBeAttacked = false` +- gain/lose stats until end of turn + +### 4.3 Aura entry triggers +`OnEnterAuraRange` is genuinely useful and already enables a lot of “escort / witness / support” gameplay. + +### 4.4 Random ruin activations +The ruin execution model is a great fit for “choose one at random from three triggered abilities.” + +### 4.5 Core zone actions +Draw, discard, simple return-to-hand, and some discard recursion already cover a lot of deck glue. + +--- + +## 5. Recommended implementation order + +If the goal is to improve deck conversion throughput quickly, this is the order I would implement. + +### Phase 1: highest deck-conversion payoff +1. Trigger frequency caps on triggered abilities +2. First-class `RepositionUnitEffect` +3. Replacement/prevention timing (`BeforeUnitDeath`, damage prevention) +4. Destination-aware movement event payload / conditions + +### Phase 2: make card text cleaner and less compromised +5. `NotCondition` +6. Relational adjacency filters (`adjacent to unit matching`, `adjacent to tile matching`) +7. Movement-state-sensitive flag windows +8. `UntilEndOfSequence` + +### Phase 3: expand expressive card design +9. Full `ChooseOne` / modal branch execution +10. Source-qualified damage triggers +11. Player tile-control conditions +12. Reveal-result references +13. Tile-bound delayed markers + +--- + +## 6. Bottom line + +The R1 audits show that the current SOR ability system is **already good enough for a large percentage of these decks**. + +Most failures are not because the decks are wildly overdesigned. They fail in a few repeated categories: +- **once-per-turn trigger control** +- **real reposition instead of push/pull approximations** +- **death/damage prevention timing** +- **movement destination/state memory** +- **relational targeting around terrain or other units** + +That is good news. + +It means the next tranche of engine work should not be a giant rewrite. A focused set of additions would convert a lot of currently “templating choice” or “not cleanly implementable” text into fully native card designs.