Restore current batch to honey butter plan

This commit is contained in:
Shard
2026-07-24 21:44:22 +00:00
parent 9adaf5d1b1
commit 2b0937e7f3
14 changed files with 64 additions and 73 deletions
+7 -7
View File
@@ -1,8 +1,8 @@
# Apple Butter Mead — 3 Gallon First Batch
# Honey Butter Mead — 3 Gallon First Batch
A beginner-friendly project plan for making a **3 gallon apple-butter flavored mead**.
A beginner-friendly project plan for making a **3 gallon honey-butter flavored mead**.
> **Core idea:** make a clean traditional mead first, then create the apple-butter profile **after fermentation** using apple concentrate, honey, vanilla, cinnamon, and tiny warm-spice adjustments. Do **not** add apple products or spices during active fermentation.
> **Core idea:** make a clean traditional mead first, then create the honey-butter profile **after fermentation** using vanilla, honey backsweetening, tiny butter/butterscotch extract additions, optional caramelized honey, and a tiny salt/acid/tannin adjustment if needed. Do **not** ferment real butter.
## Quick recipe summary
@@ -10,7 +10,7 @@ A beginner-friendly project plan for making a **3 gallon apple-butter flavored m
|---|---|
| Batch size | 3 US gallons finished mead, fermented in a 6.5 gallon bucket |
| Style | Sweet / semi-sweet dessert mead |
| Flavor | Honey, cooked apple/apple-butter, vanilla, cinnamon, light warm spice |
| Flavor | Honey, vanilla, butterscotch, light toasted/caramel, butter-candy impression |
| Yeast | Lalvin 71B-1122 recommended for first batch |
| Starting gravity estimate | ~1.100–1.110 before optional extra backsweetening |
| Potential ABV if fermented dry | ~13–14% |
@@ -24,8 +24,8 @@ A beginner-friendly project plan for making a **3 gallon apple-butter flavored m
4. Track measurements in [`logs/fermentation-log.md`](logs/fermentation-log.md).
5. Use [`day-1-brew-day.md`](day-1-brew-day.md) on brew day.
6. Follow [`schedule.md`](schedule.md) for day-by-day reminders through aging/bottling.
7. Read [`apple-butter-flavor-plan.md`](apple-butter-flavor-plan.md) before post-fermentation flavoring.
8. Use [`bench-trial.md`](bench-trial.md) before adding apple concentrate, spices, extracts, acid, or tannin to the whole batch.
7. Use [`bench-trial.md`](bench-trial.md) before adding butter/butterscotch extract, vanilla, salt, acid, or tannin to the whole batch.
8. Keep the future apple-butter idea in [`next-batch-apple-butter-plan.md`](next-batch-apple-butter-plan.md).
9. If the airlock pulls liquid into the bucket, see [`airlock-backflow.md`](airlock-backflow.md).
10. If the day numbers vs nutrient timing are confusing, see [`nutrient-timing-clarification.md`](nutrient-timing-clarification.md).
@@ -34,7 +34,7 @@ A beginner-friendly project plan for making a **3 gallon apple-butter flavored m
- Sanitize anything that touches must or mead after the boil/cooling stage. Mead is not boiled like beer, so sanitation matters.
- Do **not** bottle until gravity is stable across multiple readings.
- If backsweetening, stabilize first with potassium metabisulfite + potassium sorbate, then wait before adding honey.
- Do **not** add apple products, spices, extracts, dairy, cream, oily ingredients, or flavorings during active fermentation.
- Do **not** use real butter, dairy, cream, oily ingredients, or flavorings during active fermentation.
- Never seal actively fermenting mead in bottles; pressure can build and create bottle bombs.
- Local alcohol laws vary; make sure home fermentation is legal where you are.
+13 -14
View File
@@ -4,43 +4,42 @@ Do this at least **24 hours after stabilization**.
## Goal
Find the apple-butter flavor profile in samples before changing the whole batch.
Find the honey-butter flavor profile in samples before changing the whole batch.
## Start with sweetness
Pull several 100 ml samples. Test honey + apple concentrate first before spices/extracts.
Pull several 100 ml samples. Test honey additions first before extracts.
Suggested sample variables:
- Control: no addition
- Low honey + low apple concentrate
- Medium honey + medium apple concentrate
- Medium honey + higher apple concentrate
- Low honey
- Medium honey
- High honey
Once sweetness/apple balance is close, test vanilla, cinnamon, tiny nutmeg/allspice, acid, and tannin.
Once sweetness is close, test vanilla/butter/butterscotch.
## Apple/spice bench-trial rule
## Butter/butterscotch extract rule
Use tiny measured additions. Do **not** pour apple concentrate, spice tinctures, extracts, acid, or tannin directly into the full batch by instinct.
Use tiny measured additions. Do **not** pour extract directly into the full batch by instinct.
Use [`bench-trial.md`](bench-trial.md) for scaling.
For a 3 gallon batch:
```text
full batch amount = sample amount in 100 ml × 113.56
full batch extract ml = sample extract ml in 100 ml × 113.56
```
## Likely full-batch additions
Only after bench trial:
- Frozen apple juice concentrate, usually starting around 1 can and increasing by taste
- 0.5–1.5 lb honey, to taste
- 1–2 lb honey, to taste
- Vanilla bean/extract, to taste
- Cinnamon stick contact, tasting every few days
- Tiny nutmeg/allspice only if bench trials support it
- Optional pectic enzyme per label if using apple concentrate/juice
- Tiny butter extract, if needed
- Tiny butterscotch extract, if needed
- Optional microscopic salt solution
- Optional acid/tannin if sweetness tastes flat
## After adding
+10 -11
View File
@@ -1,10 +1,10 @@
# Bench Trial Guide — Apple Butter Flavoring
# Bench Trial Guide — Honey Butter Flavoring
Do not add extracts directly to the full 3 gallon batch by guesswork. Bench trial first.
## Why
Apple concentrate, cinnamon, vanilla, nutmeg, allspice, acid, and tannin need small-sample testing. Spices especially can move from warm and cozy to harsh very quickly.
Butter and butterscotch extracts are potent. A tiny amount can be pleasant; a little too much can taste fake, oily, or like movie-theater popcorn.
## Tools
@@ -27,9 +27,9 @@ Apple concentrate, cinnamon, vanilla, nutmeg, allspice, acid, and tannin need sm
3 US gallons is about 11,356 ml.
If a 100 ml sample tastes best with `X` amount of an addition:
If a 100 ml sample tastes best with `X ml` extract:
`full batch amount = X × 113.56`
`full batch extract ml = X × 113.56`
Examples:
@@ -39,7 +39,6 @@ Examples:
| 0.02 ml | 2.3 ml |
| 0.05 ml | 5.7 ml |
| 0.10 ml | 11.4 ml |
| 1 tsp | ~1.9 cups |
Start low. You can always add more; you cannot remove it.
@@ -47,13 +46,13 @@ Start low. You can always add more; you cannot remove it.
For each 100 ml sample:
| Sample | Honey | Apple concentrate | Vanilla | Cinnamon/warm spice | Acid/tannin |
| Sample | Honey sweetness | Vanilla | Butter extract | Butterscotch extract | Salt |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| A | control | none | none | none | none |
| B | low | low | none | none | none |
| C | medium | medium | tiny | none | none |
| D | medium | medium | tiny | tiny cinnamon | none |
| E | medium | high | tiny | tiny cinnamon + nutmeg/allspice | none |
| F | high | medium | tiny | tiny cinnamon | tiny acid/tannin |
| B | low | tiny | tiny | none | none |
| C | medium | tiny | tiny | tiny | none |
| D | medium | medium | tiny | tiny | microscopic |
| E | high | medium | tiny | medium | microscopic |
| F | medium | medium | none | tiny | microscopic |
Because household droppers vary wildly, measure by ml when possible.
+5 -6
View File
@@ -2,7 +2,7 @@
> **Applies to: 2026-07-16 (Brew day / pitch, T+0h)**
Created for the first active brew day of the 3 gallon apple-butter mead batch.
Created for the first active brew day of the 3 gallon honey-butter mead batch.
## Goal for today
@@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ Water to 3 gallons total volume
Fermaid O starts tomorrow, not today
```
Do **not** add apple concentrate, apple butter, vanilla, spices, extracts, sorbate, metabisulfite/Campden, acid blend, tannin, or backsweetening honey today.
Do **not** add vanilla, butter extract, butterscotch extract, sorbate, metabisulfite/Campden, acid blend, tannin, salt, or backsweetening honey today.
---
@@ -283,7 +283,7 @@ Do **not** seal the bucket with no airlock. CO₂ needs to escape.
Put tape on the bucket:
```text
Apple Butter Mead
Honey Butter Mead
3 gal
Brew date:
Yeast: Lalvin 71B-1122
@@ -326,10 +326,9 @@ Signs fermentation has started:
Do not add:
- Apple concentrate
- Apple butter
- Butter extract
- Butterscotch extract
- Vanilla
- Cinnamon/spices
- Potassium sorbate
- Potassium metabisulfite / Campden
- Acid blend
+1 -1
View File
@@ -29,7 +29,7 @@ Continue staggered nutrient support while fermentation is active.
- Do not rack.
- Do not stabilize.
- Do not backsweeten.
- Do not add vanilla, apple concentrate, spices, or extracts.
- Do not add vanilla or butter/butterscotch extract.
## Log line template
+1 -1
View File
@@ -53,7 +53,7 @@ If fermentation is still clearly active and healthy, you can generally add the f
- Do not stabilize.
- Do not backsweeten.
- Do not add apple concentrate/spices/vanilla/extracts.
- Do not add butter/butterscotch/vanilla.
- Do not rack unless something unusual requires intervention.
## Log line template
+4 -6
View File
@@ -10,9 +10,8 @@ Assess:
- Sweetness
- Honey character
- Apple/apple-butter depth
- Vanilla
- Cinnamon/warm spice balance
- Butter/butterscotch impression
- Alcohol heat
- Acidity/brightness
- Body/tannin
@@ -25,10 +24,9 @@ Assess:
| Not sweet enough | More honey, after stabilization, in small measured additions |
| Too sweet/flabby | Tiny acid blend addition via bench trial |
| Thin | Tiny tannin addition via bench trial |
| Not enough apple | More apple concentrate via bench trial |
| Not enough apple-butter warmth | Tiny cinnamon/vanilla/nutmeg/allspice bench trial |
| Too spiced/extract-like | Age longer; consider blending with unflavored mead if available |
| Flat | Tiny acid, tannin, or salt bench trial |
| Not enough dessert note | Tiny butter/butterscotch extract via bench trial |
| Too extract-like | Age longer; consider blending with unflavored mead if available |
| Flat | Tiny acid or salt bench trial |
## Rule
+3 -4
View File
@@ -4,7 +4,7 @@
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Batch name | Apple Butter Mead |
| Batch name | Honey Butter Mead |
| Brew date | 2026-07-16 |
| Batch size | 3 gal, fermented in 6.5 gal bucket |
| Honey used | 9 lb raw honey primary + backsweetening TBD |
@@ -31,9 +31,8 @@
| | Stabilized | | |
| | Backsweetened with honey | | |
| | Vanilla | | |
| | Apple concentrate | | |
| | Pectic enzyme | | |
| | Cinnamon / warm spices | | |
| | Butter extract | | |
| | Butterscotch extract | | |
| | Acid/tannin/salt adjustment | | |
## Tasting notes
@@ -1,8 +1,8 @@
# Apple Butter Flavor Plan
This batch is now planned as a **post-fermentation apple-butter mead**.
This is a **future next-batch plan** for a post-fermentation apple-butter mead. Do not apply it to the current honey-butter batch unless Jason explicitly changes the current batch again.
The primary fermentation remains unchanged:
For a similar 3 gallon future batch, the primary fermentation can remain similar:
```text
3 gal batch
+2 -2
View File
@@ -62,7 +62,7 @@ When fermentation is done and gravity is stable:
3. Choose the best sweetness/flavor dosage.
4. Scale carefully to the full batch.
5. Add vanilla beans/extract first; wait/taste.
6. Add apple concentrate, vanilla, cinnamon/spices, acid, or tannin only after stabilization and bench trials.
6. Add butter/butterscotch extracts only after stabilization and bench trials.
7. Adjust acid/tannin/salt only if needed.
## Phase 7 — Aging
@@ -91,4 +91,4 @@ For still mead, use wine bottles/corks or beer bottles/caps. Store cool and dark
| Fermentation stopped early | temp, pH, nutrition, yeast alcohol limit | Warm gently, check gravity/pH, ask before drastic fixes |
| Too sweet | fermentation stalled or over-backsweetened | Balance with acid/tannin; do not bottle if unstable |
| Too hot/alcoholic | young mead | Age longer |
| Apple/spice flavor tastes harsh | too much spice/extract | Age longer; consider blending with unflavored mead if available |
| Butter flavor tastes fake | too much extract | Blend back with unflavored mead if possible |
+10 -11
View File
@@ -1,8 +1,8 @@
# Recipe — 3 Gallon Apple Butter Mead
# Recipe — 3 Gallon Honey Butter Mead
## Target profile
A sweet/semi-sweet dessert mead that starts as a clean traditional mead, then becomes apple-butter flavored after fermentation with apple concentrate, honey, vanilla, cinnamon, and tiny warm-spice adjustments.
A sweet/semi-sweet dessert mead that tastes like honey, vanilla, butterscotch, and warm honey butter without using actual butter.
## Batch targets
@@ -31,23 +31,22 @@ Do these after primary fermentation is complete and the mead has been racked/sta
Recommended starting point for the whole 3 gal batch **after bench trials**:
- Frozen apple juice concentrate: start with 1 can in bench trials, possibly 2–3 cans total if needed
- Backsweeten with 0.5–1.5 lb honey, to taste
- Vanilla bean/extract, to taste
- Cinnamon stick, short contact; taste often
- Tiny nutmeg/allspice additions only by bench trial
- Optional pectic enzyme per label if using apple concentrate/juice
- Optional acid blend/malic acid and/or wine tannin to balance sweetness
- 2–3 split vanilla beans, aged 1–2 weeks, tasting every few days
- Backsweeten with 1–2 lb honey, to taste
- Butter extract: only what the bench trial supports; often tiny amounts
- Butterscotch extract: only what the bench trial supports; often tiny amounts
- Optional tiny pinch of sea salt, dissolved first and added incrementally
- Optional acid blend/tannin to balance sweetness
## Optional caramelized honey note
For a warmer cooked-apple/caramel depth, caramelize 0.5–1 lb of backsweetening honey separately:
For a warmer “honey butter on toast” flavor, caramelize 1 lb of the honey separately:
1. Put 1 lb honey in a large pot with plenty of headspace.
2. Heat gently and stir; honey foams dramatically and can burn.
3. Cook until it darkens slightly and smells like caramel/toffee, not burnt.
4. Carefully dissolve with warm water.
5. Save it for backsweetening/flavoring after stabilization rather than adding it during active fermentation.
5. Add this as part of the 9 lb primary honey or save it for backsweetening.
For a first batch, keep caramelization light. A heavy bochet can take a long time to age.
+1 -1
View File
@@ -23,4 +23,4 @@ Useful outside reading for this batch.
## Flavoring guidance
- Bench trials are common in winemaking/meadmaking for post-fermentation additions. The included `bench-trial.md` gives a simple 100 ml sample method.
- For apple-butter flavor, use post-fermentation apple concentrate + honey + vanilla + cinnamon/warm spices, with pectic enzyme if using apple products. Bench trial before full-batch additions.
- For honey-butter flavor, use vanilla + butterscotch/butter extract + honey sweetness + tiny salt, not real butter. Future apple-butter batch notes live in `next-batch-apple-butter-plan.md`.
+1 -1
View File
@@ -6,7 +6,7 @@ This schedule starts from the recorded pitch time:
Day 0 / pitch: 2026-07-16 22:51 EDT
OG: 1.100
Must temp: 74.5°F
Batch: 3 gal apple-butter mead in 6.5 gal bucket
Batch: 3 gal honey-butter mead in 6.5 gal bucket
Honey: 9 lb raw honey
```
+4 -6
View File
@@ -1,4 +1,4 @@
# Shopping List — 3 Gallon Apple Butter Mead
# Shopping List — 3 Gallon Honey Butter Mead
Quantities are for one 3 gallon finished batch fermented in a 6.5 gallon bucket, with a little extra for mistakes, topping up, and backsweetening.
@@ -66,7 +66,7 @@ These are practical starter choices rather than luxury picks. Amazon is listed f
| Corker | Double-lever hand corker for occasional use; floor corker if you expect many batches | [Amazon search](https://www.amazon.com/s?k=double+lever+wine+corker), [Northern Brewer search](https://www.northernbrewer.com/search?q=wine%20corker), [MoreBeer search](https://www.morebeer.com/search?search=wine%20corker) | Hand corker is fine for ~15 bottles. Floor corker is nicer but costs more. |
| Temperature strip | Stick-on fermometer strip | [Amazon search](https://www.amazon.com/s?k=fermentation+temperature+strip), [Northern Brewer search](https://www.northernbrewer.com/search?q=fermometer) | Cheap and helpful for keeping 71B in range. |
| Brewing thermometer | Digital instant-read thermometer | [Amazon search](https://www.amazon.com/s?k=digital+instant+read+thermometer), local kitchen store | Useful for yeast rehydration and must temperature. |
| Bench-trial pipettes/syringes | 1 ml / 3 ml oral syringes or disposable pipettes | [Amazon search](https://www.amazon.com/s?k=1ml+oral+syringe+graduated), [Amazon pipette search](https://www.amazon.com/s?k=disposable+pipettes+1ml) | Important for not overdosing apple concentrate, spice tinctures, extracts, acid, or tannin. |
| Bench-trial pipettes/syringes | 1 ml / 3 ml oral syringes or disposable pipettes | [Amazon search](https://www.amazon.com/s?k=1ml+oral+syringe+graduated), [Amazon pipette search](https://www.amazon.com/s?k=disposable+pipettes+1ml) | Important for not overdosing butter/butterscotch extract. |
| Graduated cylinder/beaker | 100 ml graduated cylinder or small beaker set | [Amazon search](https://www.amazon.com/s?k=100ml+graduated+cylinder), [Amazon beaker search](https://www.amazon.com/s?k=small+plastic+beaker+set+graduated) | Helps with bench trials and hydrometer samples. |
| Labels/tape/marker | Painter’s tape + Sharpie | [Amazon search](https://www.amazon.com/s?k=painters+tape+sharpie), local store | Date everything. |
| Optional pH meter | Apera PH20 or similar beginner pH meter; strips if budget | [Amazon Apera search](https://www.amazon.com/s?k=Apera+PH20+pH+meter), [Amazon pH strips search](https://www.amazon.com/s?k=wine+ph+strips) | Optional for first batch, but useful if fermentation stalls. |
@@ -89,10 +89,8 @@ If you want fewer separate purchases, a wine/mead starter equipment kit can be c
| Potassium metabisulfite, or Campden tablets | 1 pack | per package dose | Stabilizing and oxidation protection. |
| Potassium sorbate | 1 pack | per package dose | Stabilizing before backsweetening. Use with sulfite. |
| Vanilla beans | 3–5 beans | Start with 2–3 | Split and add in secondary; extract also works. |
| Frozen apple juice concentrate | 1–3 cans | bench trial after stabilization | Apple flavor and sweetness for apple-butter profile. |
| Pectic enzyme | 1 small pack | per label if using apple products | Helps reduce apple haze. Check label for timing/dose. |
| Nutmeg | small amount | bench trial only | Very strong; use tiny amounts. |
| Allspice | small amount | bench trial only | Very strong; use tiny amounts. |
| Butterscotch extract | 1 bottle | bench trial only | Add after fermentation. Very easy to overdo. |
| Butter extract | 1 bottle | bench trial only | Add after fermentation. Do not use real butter. |
| Sea salt or kosher salt | small container | tiny pinch / bench trial | Makes dessert flavors pop; too much ruins it. |
| Wine tannin | 1 small pack | optional, tiny additions | Helps balance sweetness. |
| Acid blend | 1 small pack | optional, after fermentation | Add only to taste. |