Close M11.9 for now and review the overhauled cellular UI
Foundation / checks (client) (push) Successful in 4s
Foundation / checks (checks) (push) Successful in 5s
Foundation / checks (ecs) (push) Successful in 4s
Foundation / checks (deploy) (push) Successful in 5s
Foundation / checks (network) (push) Successful in 4s
Foundation / checks (tsan) (push) Successful in 4s
Foundation / checks (postgres) (push) Successful in 4s
Foundation / postgres-tools (push) Successful in 5s
Foundation / server-image (push) Successful in 5s
Foundation / image (push) Successful in 4s

This commit is contained in:
dingo
2026-10-17 11:35:56 -04:00
parent fcc6c57320
commit 8b54e7447a
8 changed files with 125 additions and 8 deletions
@@ -0,0 +1,61 @@
# M11.9 scoped closure and current UI review - 2026-10-17
## Maintainer decision
The maintainer states: "We are going to close 11.9 for now. Please proceed."
Record M11.9 as closed for current M12 engineering continuation. The earlier solo
observations remain evidence and follow-up work; the three-participant sample,
fun/variety conclusions and all retests were not completed by this decision.
Do not continue treating a missing M11.9 acceptance as an engineering blocker.
## Current baseline inspected
Reviewed source at `fcc6c57` plus this scoped documentation/research work. The
implemented client is the microscope overhaul, not the earlier teal side panels.
Current cellular implementation is rules 8, owner format 6, habitat format 2,
genome schema/development 4, with percentage steps, skilled/twin budding, hunting
wildlife, finite pools/motes and contact feeding (ADR-0137 and ADR-0136 step A).
Behaviour weighting/colonies, nutrient infall and photosynthesis remain proposed.
The previous invisible-living-cell report is retained historically. Subsequent
commits add bounded wildlife steering, tick-stall diagnostics and DEV promotion;
this review does not independently claim a new live incident validation.
## Visual review
Built the actual production panel test with Clang 19 using the `client` preset in
`build/m12-ui-clang` with clang-tidy enabled. Ran `evo-client-panel-tests` under
Xvfb and generated current screenshots in `build/m12-ui-review`.
Inspected all three HUD renders (640/960/1280), the evolution window and the death
window. The fixtures intentionally combine legacy patch rendering and new deposit
rendering; their "Region 4" label is test data, not a claim about the deployed region.
- Rounded microscope eyepiece, dark ink/lavender palette, separate status pill,
Field notes, Vitals and the action dock are present.
- Wide layouts retain Field notes; narrow layouts prioritise Vitals and actions.
Resource details use the existing vertically scrolling Vitals window. Panel
tests check viewport bounds and no sideways scrolling at all three sizes.
- Mutation cards show before/after phenotype drawings, named tradeoffs, per-channel
costs, available choices and an explicit shortage on the unaffordable choice.
The window warns that the cell keeps moving while it is open.
- Death is central and names the cause. "Begin a new life" is prominent, with
descendant/history continuity explained. This is a new primitive life, not
resurrection of the old identity.
- Feedback includes specific engulf refusal wording. Nutrient colours, pools,
motes and cellular morphology share the production drawing path.
No UI redesign or interaction change is made here. Static fixture review does not
validate live feel, hover timing, glow animation, hardware/DPI behavior or product
fun. The native running-window capture timed out waiting for app approval; no
authentication or live gameplay was automated. A first GCC-14 client build hit an
existing `AuthGrant` maybe-uninitialized warning under warnings-as-errors; it was
left unchanged, and the separate Clang-19 build/panel test completed successfully.
## Validation and consequences
Executed production panel test: passed, with clang-tidy during its Clang build.
Inspected the five generated images above. Relative Markdown links and
`git diff --check` checked for the closure documents. No runtime, simulation,
protocol, persistent format, deployment or World0 change. Resume M12.2 using the
current cellular contracts, keeping aggregation and target-host evidence gates.
+11
View File
@@ -1,5 +1,16 @@
# M11.9: Run repeated-life playtests and close the loop
## Maintainer closure - 2026-10-17
The maintainer explicitly closes M11.9 **for now** and authorizes proceeding with
M12. This is the gate decision for continued engineering. The incomplete sample,
solo feedback and fun/variety questions remain recorded; this closure does not
invent completed sessions or empirical product validation. Retain the local
playtest backlog for later iteration rather than using it to block M12 work.
Review the current microscope UI and rules-8 contracts before further integration.
The [closure and UI review](M11_9_CLOSURE_AND_UI_REVIEW.md) records the actual
production-panel screenshots inspected and the scope of this decision.
The playtests themselves are human work for the maintainer and participants. This
plan tracks what engineering provides for them: the predeclared plan
([M11_9_REPEATED_LIFE_PLAYTEST](../playtests/M11_9_REPEATED_LIFE_PLAYTEST.md)),
+9 -8
View File
@@ -4,7 +4,7 @@ Requested scope: ecological identity, population qualification, durable automati
tier transitions, unattended scheduling/migration and environmental coupling.
Commit and push each validated scoped segment separately.
## Gate status (2026-10-16)
## Gate status (2026-10-17)
| Subset | State | Evidence or condition for completion |
|---|---|---|
@@ -14,12 +14,13 @@ Commit and push each validated scoped segment separately.
| 12.4 | Blocked on 12.2-12.3 | Existing cellular worker pauses without sessions/lingering players; bounded unattended recovery and biological migration escrow remain unimplemented. |
| 12.5 | Blocked on 12.2-12.4 | Finite M6 process fixtures do not qualify coupled persistent cellular/cohort atmosphere/water budgets. |
M12's roadmap entry also requires the M11 playable-loop product review. The
[M11.9 plan](M11_9_DELIVERY_PLAN.md) now links the maintainer's
[solo feedback](../playtests/2026-10-16_M11_9_SOLO_FEEDBACK.md), including the
living-cell reconnect blocker and repetitive-loop concerns. Full sample/retests
and product acceptance remain incomplete. Beginning policy work or synthetic
population experiments does not fabricate that acceptance.
The maintainer explicitly closes M11.9 for now on 2026-10-17 and authorizes M12
continuation; see the [closure decision](M11_9_DELIVERY_PLAN.md). The recorded
solo sample and fun/variety questions remain incomplete empirical evidence and a
follow-up backlog. They no longer block M12 engineering under that decision.
Current work must use the overhauled microscope UI and implemented rules 8
(ADR-0136 step A, ADR-0137), not the older square-patch/rules-6 baseline. Proposed
colony, infall and photosynthesis mechanics remain outside this implementation.
Executed 12.2a results and remaining limits:
[M12_POPULATION_QUALIFICATION](M12_POPULATION_QUALIFICATION.md). Release CTest
@@ -50,7 +51,7 @@ cannot by itself establish useful aggregation or acceptable target-host cost.
Measure bin/interval sensitivity, conversion and full-region costs on the Linux
target host, including active fallback capacity and backpressure. Passing the M4
synthetic envelope alone is insufficient. Record M11's product review separately.
synthetic envelope alone is insufficient. Preserve the scoped M11 closure above.
Only then accept the model/tier ADR and proceed to 12.3, followed by owned durable
intervals/escrow in 12.4 and versioned finite resource coupling in 12.5. No World0
deployment or promotion follows from these gates.
+17
View File
@@ -1,5 +1,22 @@
# Validation report
## 2026-10-17 - M11.9 scoped closure and UI review
Recorded the maintainer's explicit closure for now and authorization for M12.
The earlier solo feedback/sample limitations remain historical follow-ups.
Rendered and inspected production-panel HUD screenshots at 640/960/1280 plus
evolution and central death/restart windows in `build/m12-ui-review`.
Executed `client` preset with Clang 19 and clang-tidy in `build/m12-ui-clang`,
built `evo-client-panel-tests`, then ran it under Xvfb with the output directory;
passed. The initial GCC-14 client build failed on the pre-existing AuthGrant
maybe-uninitialized warning; no suppression or unrelated source change was made.
Native running-window capture timed out waiting for app approval. Fixture renders
do not establish live DEV behavior, animations, hardware/DPI or product acceptance.
See [review](M11_9_CLOSURE_AND_UI_REVIEW.md) for exact scope. No UI/runtime,
deployment or world-state changes. Documentation links and `git diff --check`
checked. M12.2's cellular/model and target-host evidence remain required.
## 2026-10-16 - M11.9 maintainer feedback and reconnect triage
Recorded the maintainer's eight playtest answers and clarification that the