Foundation / checks (ecs) (push) Successful in 2m26s
Foundation / checks (deploy) (push) Successful in 4m6s
Foundation / postgres-tools (push) Canceled after 0s
Foundation / server-image (push) Canceled after 0s
Foundation / image (push) Canceled after 0s
Foundation / checks (client) (push) Canceled after 9m29s
Foundation / checks (tsan) (push) Canceled after 7m4s
Foundation / checks (network) (push) Canceled after 9m28s
Foundation / checks (postgres) (push) Canceled after 9m28s
Foundation / checks (checks) (push) Canceled after 9m34s
226 lines
17 KiB
Markdown
226 lines
17 KiB
Markdown
# M12 integration and evidence still required
|
||
|
||
This is the current completion audit following the maintainer's request to try
|
||
all of M12. M11.9 remains closed for now. M12.2 decisions are delegated and recorded
|
||
in ADR-0139; no additional product approval is inferred as a coding prerequisite.
|
||
Completed scoped commits do not mean their entire roadmap gates have passed.
|
||
|
||
The maintainer's 2026-10-19 [gameplay clarification](../adr/0163-structural-inheritance-and-offspring-succession.md)
|
||
accepts offspring structural expression, a one-way birth-time control choice and
|
||
NPC-parent behavior/reproductive continuity. Portable retained plans implement
|
||
part of that target; durable mutation/birth, behavior, control and census still
|
||
require coordinated versioned biology, authority, recovery and UI work. Earlier
|
||
exact-copy generation
|
||
evidence does not close that gap or establish the intended generational gameplay.
|
||
|
||
[ADR-0164](../adr/0164-distinct-genome-offspring-funding.md) now implements the
|
||
pure biological funding step with distinct parent/offspring genomes and exact
|
||
closure. [ADR-0165](../adr/0165-retained-cellular-offspring-plans.md) adds portable
|
||
retained plans and earned selections, unchanged expressed parents and repeated
|
||
funded births. Existing same-genome behavior remains. Durable plan/trace/bundle,
|
||
population/migration/census admission, the in-life expression catalog, authority
|
||
handoff and NPC/UI integration are still required.
|
||
|
||
## Persistence boundary resolved by 12.3b
|
||
|
||
ADR-0142 adds dedicated profile 5, population trace 1 and schema 44; raw profile 4
|
||
retains its meaning. Explicit no-tick migrations preserve the complete biology.
|
||
The publisher, replay verifier, immutable SQL evidence, recovery and owning host
|
||
now support exact population membership with entry disabled by default. Private
|
||
PostgreSQL tests cover ambiguity, fencing, profile races and publisher process
|
||
kills. [Scope and limits](M12_DURABLE_POPULATIONS.md) distinguish those tests from
|
||
executable/network fault drills and deployment-host qualification still required.
|
||
This resolves the architectural profile conflict. ADR-0143/schema 45 now adds
|
||
bounded durable interval admission and exact settlement/recovery, with fully
|
||
suspended controlled cells required for new work. It does not close all of M12.3
|
||
or authorize production enablement.
|
||
|
||
## Dependent ecological integration
|
||
|
||
| Gate | Existing useful basis | Work/evidence still required |
|
||
|---|---|---|
|
||
| 12.2 | Exact cellular model and paired matrix; local samples through 256 lives; bounded four-generation rules-9 predation/twin matrix | Deployment-host tail costs including publication; larger wildlife cohorts and fuller contention coverage; useful compression remains unimplemented. |
|
||
| 12.3 | Dedicated population profile/trace/store/owning host; exact recovery and private PostgreSQL fault tests | Population-specific executable/network fault drills and target-host publication/capacity qualification. |
|
||
| 12.4 | Owned intervals; exact transfer/accounting; durable atomic pair/recovery; independent loopback TLS path loss and owner expiry/replacement/heal; local object sync/read-failure matrix | Multi-host/kernel-network, storage-host and orchestrator drills, linked-boundary contracts and integrated ownership/stock audits at scale. |
|
||
| 12.5 | Finite cellular contact feeding/decay and separate M6 producer/consumer resource owner | One jointly owned cellular/environment budget, explicit effective depth and source entitlements, versioned water/atmosphere species mapping and producer coefficients, plus closed/open and nutrient-exhaustion comparisons. |
|
||
| 12.6 | Retained archive, regional census/lineage queries, replayed history, scoped multi-region queries and consistent database head snapshots (12.6a-d); registered coverage/history domains follow in 12.7a-b | Cross-domain clone provenance, retained historical coverage/other viable stores, target-host query/index qualification and client permission/presentation; no account power or invented precise statistical ancestry. |
|
||
| 12.7 | Viability/unknown policy; consistent cuts, registered coverage, history domains/restore forks and verified pending handoff evidence (12.7a-c/schema 52) | Cross-domain clone provenance, other viable-store coverage and durable accepted global evidence records/freshness. Missing/stale/unsupported owners must prevent terminal extinction. |
|
||
| 12.8 | Deterministic seed/regime drivers, separate-process exact continuation and bounded unscripted generations | Reproducible integrated worlds running for actual days, real restarts/clone comparisons and retained accounting/diversity/cost audits. Accelerated tests cannot supply elapsed days. |
|
||
| 12.9 | M11 feedback and current UI review retained | Returning-player samples on the integrated ecology and explicit product/3D readiness decision after soak evidence. No M12 product acceptance or World0 promotion is inferred. |
|
||
|
||
Do not couple the current cellular habitat to a copied M6 stock view: two owners
|
||
would then spend the same resources. M6 currently owns ten finite field channels
|
||
and exactly two configured actors; cellular lives own energy and C/N/P/other plus
|
||
finite deposits. Their geometry, ownership and chemical units need a versioned
|
||
mapping, not a renamed fixture. ADR-0136 step A is implemented; proposed infall
|
||
and photosynthesis steps B/C do not silently become accepted M12 mechanics.
|
||
|
||
The [ownership resolution proposal](M12_ENVIRONMENT_OWNERSHIP_RESOLUTION.md)
|
||
records the actual public-API conflict, a composite-owner/checkpoint direction,
|
||
typed compartment and source requirements, worked balances and delivery segments.
|
||
It is a concrete design for review, not an implemented adapter or completed 12.5.
|
||
|
||
The engineering constitution requires stopping expansion at this architectural
|
||
boundary and documenting the resolution. That does not prevent the independent
|
||
worker scheduling correction or the dedicated exact population adapter above.
|
||
Durable biological migration escrow is implemented through ADR-0147–0149 below;
|
||
none of the rows above is closed by adding a placeholder service or relabeling
|
||
the non-biological probe.
|
||
ADR-0144's [portable transfer candidates](M12_EXACT_BIOLOGICAL_TRANSFER.md) resolve
|
||
the closed-owner/foreign-identity conflict with explicit flows and nonresident
|
||
history. Those portable candidates alone grant no durable publication or
|
||
activation authority; the dedicated workflow below supplies that boundary.
|
||
Paired transfer trace 1 now supplies bounded, independently replayable input and
|
||
member/material evidence, including raw/cohort separate-process reproduction.
|
||
It does not grant ownership or close database escrow/retry/partition qualification.
|
||
Population batch 2 continues owner-7 biology and conversions with retained flows;
|
||
cross-version replay is refused and a new process reproduces a post-transfer
|
||
64-tick interval. Its durable admission/upgrade remains intentionally unsupported
|
||
by bundle 9 and schema 45.
|
||
ADR-0145 now defines the portable bundle-10 declaration and explicit same-profile,
|
||
no-tick source upgrade, with complete payload preservation and no new genesis.
|
||
ADR-0146/schema 46 supplies SQL admission through the existing immutable
|
||
version-upgrade evidence and complete replayed recovery. Both profile upgrades,
|
||
population batch 2 and bundle-preserving profile changes are explicit; no worker
|
||
upgrades automatically. This format admission does not publish a migration pair
|
||
or close source-freeze/destination-activation and escrow qualification.
|
||
ADR-0147/schema 47 now adds durable source preparation/freeze, retained replay
|
||
capsules, explicit abort and host pause/recovery. Source stock remains owned at
|
||
its exact head through worker replacement; no timeout or drain releases it.
|
||
ADR-0148/schema 48 now supplies destination-authorized staging at its exact
|
||
captured head, verified read-only ghost/capsule retention and full destination
|
||
recovery. Both endpoints stay paused; explicit source abort atomically releases
|
||
both pointers and races safely with staging. ADR-0149/schema 49 now commits both
|
||
exact results and an immutable common receipt under both current fences. Failed
|
||
second inserts roll back both heads; commit/abort races have one exclusive
|
||
outcome. Exact retries preserve both manifests under fresh authority. Hosts
|
||
replay and verify changed heads before readiness. Preparation remains an
|
||
optimistic destination observation; staging/publication recheck captured heads.
|
||
M12.4k now exercises actual loopback TCP/end-to-end TLS with independent request
|
||
and response loss, lost prepare/stage/abort receipts, either owner's actual lease
|
||
expiry, replacement and healed stale-owner fencing in both representations.
|
||
Independent database observation proves unchanged or atomically committed heads;
|
||
the healthy peer keeps its epoch and retained pause. See
|
||
[the transport scope](M12_MIGRATION_TRANSPORT_FAULTS.md). Multi-host/kernel-network
|
||
partitions, object-store/orchestrator failures and linked ecology remain open.
|
||
M12.4l adds local object directory-sync failures before publication and actual
|
||
read-permission denial after commit. Current-result I/O failure pauses complete
|
||
recovery for retry; unavailable counterpart replay evidence quarantines until
|
||
explicit replacement. Both preserve the original receipt and heads. See
|
||
[storage scope](M12_MIGRATION_STORAGE_FAULTS.md). This does not qualify a remote
|
||
storage-host outage or physical media/power failure.
|
||
The transfer tests also expose the current rules-8 maturation gap: buds retain
|
||
their subadult realization while reproduction requires a fully realized parent.
|
||
Finite extra food alone does not close repeated wildlife generations. A versioned
|
||
growth contract and real multi-generation evidence remain necessary; transfer
|
||
tests must not fabricate adult wildlife or silently change the rules to pass.
|
||
The existing metabolic construction budget already derives a channelwise
|
||
affordable growth transition with explicit intake/release, but cellular ticks do
|
||
not apply it. It is a concrete basis for a separately versioned funded maturation
|
||
contract that also resolves expanded-body collision, tick ordering and offline
|
||
freeze. Its existence alone does not admit a new growth rule.
|
||
|
||
[ADR-0157](../adr/0157-funded-cellular-maturation.md) now implements that **portable
|
||
opt-in rules-9** prerequisite, preserving rules 8 and all default/live admission.
|
||
The exact construction transfer, bounded rate, spatial refusal, offline exclusion
|
||
and saved-choice funding are explicit. A real finite-food founder/bud reaches
|
||
funded adulthood and produces another bud, with paid sibling movement; raw/cohort
|
||
growth, conversion, recorded replay and separate-process continuation agree.
|
||
This is scripted biological evidence, not autonomous multi-generation ecological
|
||
qualification. Small juveniles can receive zero phosphorus per tick from a pool
|
||
because the existing quarter-yield rounds down; finite nutrient motes/contact and
|
||
space still matter. Durable rules-9 publication/migration/census, linked resources,
|
||
automatic wildlife robustness, balance and actual-days qualification remain open.
|
||
|
||
ADR-0158/schema 53 now adds explicit durable bundle-10 -> 11 maturation admission,
|
||
using the existing immutable version journal and exact same-profile recovery.
|
||
Raw/cohort publication and representation changes preserve the retained rule.
|
||
This does not enable rules-9 biological migration, autonomous sustainability,
|
||
joint environmental budgets or actual-days qualification.
|
||
|
||
ADR-0159 now qualifies rules-9/owner-7 census projection 1 through the existing
|
||
committed history and registered snapshot readers. Exact retained body/reserve,
|
||
real funded growth, same-tick version/profile cuts and concurrent capture are
|
||
checked. Mixed rules 8/9, unavailable objects/builds and stale grants refuse the
|
||
complete query. No new SQL schema, redundant census journal or biological rule.
|
||
This does not close viable-store reconciliation, extinction or M12 ecology gates.
|
||
|
||
ADR-0160 qualifies portable transfer between equal rules-9/owner-7 cuts and
|
||
separately identified migration trace 2. No transfer tick, growth reset or stock
|
||
re-derivation is introduced; real pre/post-transfer growth, exact raw/cohort
|
||
biology, replay/process continuation and refusal matrices are checked. Trace 1
|
||
retains rules 8. The durable adapter still rejects trace 2/bundle 11: explicit
|
||
freeze/stage/paired publication/recovery and registered pending-handoff census
|
||
qualification are required before rules-9 durable migration is supported.
|
||
|
||
ADR-0161/schema 54 now supplies that explicit durable admission through the
|
||
existing journals, pending pointers and two-head transaction. Exact bundle-10/
|
||
trace-1 and bundle-11/trace-2 pairs retain their respective biology. Mixed bundles
|
||
and cross-rule traces fail. Both representations retain complete freeze/stage/
|
||
publication/recovery and registered census verification. Multi-host network and
|
||
storage drills, linked resources, sustainable generations and actual-days/product
|
||
qualification remain open; no live/default upgrade or M12 completion is inferred.
|
||
|
||
M12.6a's [regional census projection](../../schemas/ecology/regional-cellular-census-v1.md)
|
||
independently implements local current-genome and descendant-closure queries.
|
||
It keeps suspended stock and retained zero-carrier ancestry, separates exact cohort
|
||
tags from additional ownership, and excludes nonresident history from living stock.
|
||
The local projection itself has no commit/branch/epoch binding or complete world
|
||
coverage. M12.6b's [committed history reader](../../schemas/ecology/committed-cellular-history-v1.md)
|
||
now derives it from the existing immutable atomic biological journal, with full
|
||
historical replay, exact manifest binding and a fixed regional upper cut. No
|
||
redundant census write or separate publication window is added. That regional cut
|
||
is not an external branch identity or complete world watermark. World-level
|
||
history context/queries, client presentation and M12.7 reconciliation remain open;
|
||
neither primitive accepts terminal extinction.
|
||
|
||
M12.6c adds [scoped multi-region queries](../../schemas/ecology/scoped-cellular-census-set-v1.md)
|
||
over 1..64 explicitly declared regions. Exact coverage and simulation boundaries,
|
||
complete shared-genome identity and disjoint resident organism IDs are checked
|
||
before querying. Nonresident historical records add no living stock. A required
|
||
list supplied by a caller is still not durable world coverage; equal ticks alone
|
||
cannot prove a consistent migration cut or branch. This does not close M12.7.
|
||
|
||
M12.6d's [consistent scoped snapshot](../../schemas/ecology/consistent-cellular-census-snapshot-v1.md)
|
||
now captures all declared heads in one database read snapshot before exact replay.
|
||
An atomic pair cannot straddle that selected set when both endpoints are declared.
|
||
The short metadata transaction ends before object I/O and fenced recovery; failed
|
||
evidence still returns no partial census. Durable world/branch identity, required
|
||
owner coverage, outside transfers and viable-store reconciliation remain open.
|
||
|
||
M12.7a/schema 50's [registered coverage](../../schemas/ecology/registered-world-census-coverage-v1.md)
|
||
now reads the existing durable authority registry before head selection in that
|
||
same database snapshot. Every registered region is required, including inactive,
|
||
expired, unsupported and unavailable owners. Unknown worlds and a 65th region
|
||
fail rather than becoming zero or a truncated complete set. Concurrent later
|
||
enrollment belongs to a later cut. No duplicate catalog/enrollment write is added.
|
||
That registered-coverage primitive alone does not identify external history or
|
||
authorize terminal extinction.
|
||
|
||
M12.7b/schema 51's [history domain](../../schemas/ecology/database-history-domain-v1.md)
|
||
now binds registered results to a database namespace in the same metadata view.
|
||
Supported restores fork before verification/readmission and retain parent/request
|
||
and exact restored cuts. Initial adoption and legacy backups cannot recover
|
||
unknown original context; direct privileged database copies can bypass the
|
||
workflow. Cross-domain clone provenance, other viable/in-flight stores and durable
|
||
accepted reconciliation remain open. This still does not close M12.7.
|
||
|
||
M12.7c/schema 52's [pending handoff evidence](../../schemas/ecology/census-pending-migrations-v1.md)
|
||
now captures active source/destination pointers with domain/registry/heads, binds
|
||
them to the selected cuts and fully verifies retained source capsules and staged
|
||
ghost biology after capture. Source-owned life is already in the census; ghosts
|
||
add none. Prepare/stage/abort/commit races preserve the selected view. Unavailable
|
||
or false evidence fails the whole query. Other viable stores, external clone
|
||
provenance and accepted durable global reconciliation/freshness remain open.
|
||
|
||
ADR-0162's [bounded unscripted generations](M12_UNSCRIPTED_GENERATIONS.md)
|
||
qualify unchanged-controller rules-9 reproduction through four wildlife generations
|
||
in the declared finite rich four-founder matrix, with raw/cohort equality,
|
||
conservation, actual predation/twins and periodic exact restores. Scarce and rules-8
|
||
controls retain their different outcomes. These are 4,000 simulated seconds per
|
||
case, not sustainable producer ecology or actual elapsed days.
|
||
|
||
Current expansion readiness: **no-go for M13 integration or World0 promotion**
|
||
while these M12 integration/evidence gates remain open. This records the present
|
||
engineering evidence, not a substitute for the later maintainer product review.
|