Files
aevolution/Cellular_mutation_draft.md
T
dingo 9adaf6515b
Foundation / checks (checks) (push) Successful in 5s
Foundation / checks (client) (push) Successful in 4s
Foundation / checks (ecs) (push) Successful in 5s
Foundation / checks (network) (push) Successful in 4s
Foundation / checks (postgres) (push) Successful in 5s
Foundation / checks (tsan) (push) Successful in 4s
Foundation / checks (deploy) (push) Successful in 4m22s
Foundation / postgres-tools (push) Successful in 5s
Foundation / server-image (push) Successful in 5s
Foundation / image (push) Successful in 4s
docs: add immediate division and prepared offspring mutation routes
2026-10-21 11:32:22 -04:00

695 lines
69 KiB
Markdown

# Cellular mutation draft
Status: discussion draft, 2026-10-21. No runtime rules, public contracts, schemas,
live regions, or implementation milestones are changed by this document.
## Purpose and authority
Design a cellular opening about reproduction, ecological consequences, and early
colonies. Solitary bubble collection must quickly lead to something new to do.
This catalog contains **150 candidate adaptations**, not 150 features required
for the first playable release. Every option needs a reason to choose it, a real
drawback, and understandable conditions for appearing.
The maintainer's pacing direction from the discussion is:
- First funded bud within about **three minutes of active, purposeful play**.
- Several births quickly establish visible life around the player.
- Around **five successful buds**, attachment/colony opportunities become much
more likely. Five is a proposed tuning point, not an accepted hard unlock.
- A player pursuing progression should have an opportunity to move beyond
solitary cellular play in about **30 minutes**, with roughly **one hour** as
the outer target rather than an enforced waiting period.
- Remaining unicellular can be viable. No mandatory species class, intelligence
endpoint, or fixed cell-to-animal ladder is introduced.
The catalog, numeric offer tuning, eligibility details, and bad-luck protection
below remain proposals. They must not silently become accepted game rules.
Read this draft alongside:
- [Project vision](docs/PROJECT_VISION.md).
- [Genome and development model](docs/biology/GENOME_MODEL.md).
- [Energy and matter accounting](docs/biology/ENERGY_MODEL.md).
- [Behavior-weighted evolution and colonies proposal](docs/adr/0135-behaviour-driven-evolution-and-colonies.md).
- [Structural inheritance and succession](docs/adr/0163-structural-inheritance-and-offspring-succession.md).
- [Retained offspring plans](docs/adr/0165-retained-cellular-offspring-plans.md).
- [Environmental ownership and compartments](docs/adr/0172-cellular-environment-ownership.md).
- [Photosynthesis producers](docs/adr/0175-photosynthesis-producers.md).
The existing colony proposal contains historical provisional rules and policy
choices. Linking it does not adopt its colony ownership, death, logout, or
coalescence details. Those need reconciliation with later accepted requirements.
## Mutation costs and expression
Recommended starting policy: **no separate resource fee to select a mutation**.
Earned opportunities create choices; actually building a changed organism spends
resources. This is consistent with the offspring-plan selection mode described
in ADR-0165, not a claim that every historical mutation mode already works so.
Separate four kinds of cost:
| Cost | Meaning |
| --- | --- |
| Construction | Energy, C, N, P, and Other Matter transferred into actual tissue at development/birth. |
| Operation | Energy and any substrates consumed while a capability operates. |
| Maintenance | Upkeep of tissue that actually exists; do not invent upkeep for an unexpressed plan. |
| Specialization | Physical capacity, performance, habitat access, or independence surrendered elsewhere. |
A drawback must arise from a specified mechanism. Do not charge every mutation
an arbitrary flat energy penalty. A resource-poor organism can select an expensive
offspring plan without being able to build it immediately; show the additional
requirements and permit revising the plan through subsequent earned choices.
Do not make the three-minute first bud depend on acquiring a particular mutation.
Structural changes affect future offspring, not the parent's existing anatomy.
Removing a structure avoids building it in future offspring; it does not refund
the parent's current body. Live physiological adjustment, damage, and ordinary
growth need separate expression classifications. Birth-time succession remains
one-way; nothing here grants possession of independent relatives or rescue after
death. New autonomous NPC mutations are outside this draft's authorization.
## Two mutation routes: evolve now or prepare offspring
Discussion addition, 2026-10-21: offer two ways to commit an earned adaptation.
The current-cell route gives immediate experience at the cost of dividing now;
the offspring route lets the player observe a genetic direction before committing
their controlled organism to it. This section records design intent and a proposed
resolution through offspring succession, not implemented reproduction rules.
| | Evolve now (current-cell experience) | Prepare offspring |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Trigger | Select the adaptation and perform a viable funded division now. | Select a heritable plan, then choose when to reproduce. |
| Player control | Continue immediately as the newly developed mutated offspring. | Keep playing the unchanged parent; a newborn can become the controlled organism at a later birth. |
| Main benefit | Immediate experience of the adaptation, with another organism added to the habitat. | Observe autonomous offspring and evaluate whether that genetic direction suits the habitat. |
| Main drawback | Commit to a smaller organism with fewer reserves and the adaptation's consequences immediately. | No immediate experience of the changed body; gather, reproduce, and evaluate before transferring control. |
| Body and reserves | Start from roughly half the dividing organism's mass and resources, subject to viable allocation and actual development costs. | Transfer the funded offspring investment when reproduction is initiated; retain the parent's remaining body and reserves. |
| Changing direction | Earn another suitable adaptation to shed, replace, or counter the trait; fund another viable development event. | Revise the future-offspring plan through subsequent earned choices; existing offspring retain their actual inherited forms. |
### Immediate division and identity
For the current-cell experience, the player continues as the **mutated half**;
the unchanged half becomes independent wildlife, or remains attached where supported.
"Unchanged" means retaining the established traits, not retaining full original
mass and reserves after those have been divided.
For structural changes, interpret this as **division plus immediate one-way
offspring succession**, rather than rebuilding the existing adult. The unchanged
organism retains the original permanent identity and expressed developmental basis;
the mutated offspring has a new identity and its actual inherited plan. The
relinquished organism keeps its established behavior and selected reproductive
plan, separately from its unchanged expressed traits, as required by ADR-0163.
No control can return to it after transfer or after the controlled offspring dies.
The roughly half-and-half allocation is a starting design target, not a rule that
every nutrient must be split blindly when that makes either body invalid. Specify
actual tissue partitioning, viable size, reserves, placement, and development costs
before implementation. This needs an explicit division contract; existing budding
semantics must not be silently reinterpreted as division.
The resources the player gives up remain in the other organism. They are not a
mutation fee or destroyed stock. Development work can consume E into heat, and
material changes must account for every channel. Two full-sized, fully stocked
cells cannot emerge from one without additional funded growth.
An adaptation that cannot currently fund a viable division may be prepared for
later; **Evolve now** must not create missing tissue or force an invalid split.
Show why it is unavailable, without hiding the adaptation from the planning route.
Immediate commitment is consequential: disliking a trait does not grant a free
undo, guaranteed shed offer, or free reconstruction. The player must survive,
gather what the replacement body needs, and earn a useful subsequent choice.
Reversal opportunities must nevertheless remain discoverable under the weighting
and preference-decay rules; a bad fit must not become a permanent hidden class lock.
### Testing a lineage through offspring
The prepared route is:
1. Earn and select an adaptation for the offspring plan without rebuilding the parent.
2. Gather the resources and choose a useful time/location to reproduce.
3. Keep control of the parent and watch the actual offspring feed, move, survive,
and interact under its inherited traits.
4. Keep or revise the retained plan for subsequent births.
5. At a later birth, optionally continue as that newborn and relinquish the parent.
The later control choice concerns a **newborn at that birth**, not possession of an
older offspring observed earlier. Observing a successful sibling reduces uncertainty;
it does not guarantee that the next offspring will survive changed conditions.
Later plan revisions never rewrite an already born organism.
The parent does not keep the offspring's allocated material. The advantage is
retaining a familiar body and controlling the timing of investment, rather than
avoiding reproduction costs. A plan can also be selected solely to produce useful
autonomous descendants, with no obligation to transfer player control.
### Cost of divergence from the parent
Offspring may cost more when expressing a different body requires more construction,
reorganization, or provisioning. Price those requirements directly rather than
charging an arbitrary amount for each different trait:
| Difference | Proposed cost consequence |
| --- | --- |
| Small pigment or regulatory adjustment | Modest cost only where the actual recipe or developmental work changes. |
| New propulsion, shell, or other machinery | Fund the required material, assembly E, and relevant newborn operating reserves. |
| Changed body layout | Additional developmental work where supported, even if final mass is similar; quantify it rather than inventing a complexity tax. |
| Removal or simplification | May make offspring cheaper by avoiding tissue construction and upkeep. |
| Several interdependent changes | Account for the resulting integrated body once; do not charge for shared tissue repeatedly or count plan-edit history as anatomy. |
Division transfers existing material into resulting organisms; it must not also
charge the full cost of building that same transferred material from nothing.
Any breakdown/reassembly work and losses need an explicit funded model. Do not
automatically reuse the old budding bill for the proposed division route.
Preview both resulting organisms, E/C/N/P/O allocations, actual changed traits,
construction requirements, and which organism the player will control. Distinguish
estimated future operating budgets from guaranteed survival. Experimenting with a
divergent offspring must remain affordable enough to support the early pacing target.
### Ordinary reproduction and colony growth
Division remains possible **without a mutation**; random offers and declines must
not gate the first three-minute birth or the ability to populate the habitat.
Mutation selection also need not force an immediate split: the prepared route
exists for players gathering resources, travelling, or avoiding danger.
Proposed early default: ordinary division separates similar offspring; a selected
adaptation changes the new offspring; retained attachment keeps the resulting cells
together. Further adaptations support transport and specialized colony roles.
Budding can remain an alternative reproductive strategy rather than being removed
from every lineage.
The catalog's existing "bud/budding" wording is retained while the maintainer
reviews its 150 entries. Read the pacing targets here as **first funded birth**
(division in this proposed early default). Catalog adaptations that affect offspring
size, provisioning, or birth rate need explicit compatibility with division versus
budding; this note does not silently apply historical budding rules to division.
Avoid a mandatory regrow-to-full waiting period after each split, while retaining
minimum viable bodies and real material/energy requirements for further births.
## Resources and producer rules
Abbreviations: **E** = usable energy, **C** = carbon, **N** = nitrogen,
**P** = phosphorus, **O** = Other Matter. Here **O never means oxygen**.
Energy is not matter. Light-powered organisms may make nutrients accessible by
processing an environmental material source, not by turning sunlight into C/N/P/O.
For example, real photosynthesis uses light while drawing carbon from carbon
dioxide: [NASA carbon-cycle explanation](https://science.nasa.gov/earth/earth-observatory/the-carbon-cycle/).
The game can simplify chemistry without manufacturing conserved elements.
Every proposed producer must name its source, work cost, useful output, losses,
and environmental debit or recorded boundary import. A source does not exist
merely because an organism has the relevant mutation. Dissolved uptake, gases,
mineral extraction, and secretion require their own supported processes; existing
environmental compartments are not automatically edible. Other Matter is not a
wildcard that can be relabeled as C, N, or P.
Three different designs must remain distinct:
1. **Lower nutrient demand:** a different tissue recipe needs less of a channel.
2. **No need to collect that nutrient's bubbles:** obtain it through environmental
processing, recycling, prey, or a partner instead.
3. **No use of that nutrient at all:** an explicit alternative body chemistry with
fully specified replacement material and capability consequences. This larger
proposal is not approved by this catalog.
Recycling reduces replacement demand; it cannot supply the missing net material
for unlimited new offspring. Secretion transfers real resources out of the donor.
Giving nutrients to a neighbor does not duplicate either organism's inventory.
## When an offer is earned
**Offer timing is different from which options can appear.** The following is an
initial playtest proposal, not a timer the player should wait beside a pool:
- Aim for the first meaningful offer after roughly 45-60 seconds of active play,
then about one useful decision per 60-90 seconds of productive activity.
- Earn bounded activity credit through net useful food gathering, purposeful
travel with feeding/discovery, successful births, or relevant ecological
interactions. Contributions and thresholds need measurement before acceptance.
- Repeated failed budding, empty swimming loops, toggling inputs, and passing the
same empty location do not generate unlimited credit. Count outcomes, not clicks.
- Viable stationary producers can earn credit from actual capture, nutrient use,
births, and interactions. Moving is not the only legitimate activity.
- AFK camping, passive elapsed session time, and an offline player organism do
not earn progression. Defining engaged stationary play without intrusive input
requirements remains an open design/measurement question.
- Keep an earned offer available while the player navigates. No forced pause,
countdown dismissal, or need to inspect a menu during danger.
- Start by showing up to three distinct choices. A decline does not spend matter
and does not immediately reroll the offer. The next earned opportunity can draw
again. Exact cadence must avoid making a decline another long wait.
## Availability versus probability
### Hard availability checks
An option enters the eligible pool only when:
1. Its benefit, drawback, required resource processes, and presentation actually
work under the region's rules. An unimplemented thermal system means no thermal
offers, including supposedly beneficial shedding of unused tolerance.
2. Required anatomy is present in the offspring plan or supplied by the same
explicitly defined adaptation. A removal option requires something to remove.
3. The change is within the plan's supported bounds, has a nonzero effect, and
does not invalidate a dependent structure without a disclosed replacement.
4. Any required colony role, partner exchange, environmental source, or substrate
is supported and plausibly accessible. Use perceived/recorded context, not
hidden map knowledge. Row conditions referring to a habitat include a known,
reachable habitat, not only the precise spot occupied this tick.
5. There is an understandable survival strategy for the resulting offspring.
Do not offer shed-movement to an isolated feeder with no workable stationary
or carried role. This is a useful-context filter, not a promise of survival.
Resource affordability is shown separately from eligibility. Do not hide the
adaptation that solves a shortage because that same shortage makes it temporarily
unaffordable. Do not require injury, starvation, or five births to discover every
basic defensive, efficient, or colony adaptation. Those are weighting signals.
### Soft weighting proposal
For each eligible option, start with:
`weight = clamp(base * behavior * context * preference * direction, floor, cap)`
| Factor | Initial trial range | Purpose |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Base | 100 | A neutral eligible adaptation remains discoverable. |
| Behavior | 1-3x | Recent relevant outcomes increase related opportunities. |
| Context | 0.5-2x | Current scarcity, crowding, threats, and known habitats affect usefulness. |
| Preference | 0.5-1.5x | Recent accept/decline feedback nudges individual options, without permanent bans. |
| Direction | 1-3x | Sustained pursuit, especially early budding, supports a chosen direction. |
| Final floor/cap | 10 / 2000 | Keep alternatives possible and limit runaway preference loops. |
These are **relative sampling weights, not percentage probabilities**. Normalize
against the actual eligible pool; draw without replacement. Use at most the
strongest applicable signal inside each factor, rather than multiplying every
similar event. Repeatedly accepting a family must not create unbounded compounding.
Use a bounded window of approximately 90 seconds of active context, plus a few
explicit retained milestones. Long-past behavior should not trap a lineage in
one strategy. Soft preference suppression decays toward neutral over about five
subsequent earned offers; reacquisition remains possible after shedding a trait.
All durations and ranges need playtesting. Inheritable adaptation is separate
from whether transient preferences/context should carry through succession.
The row's **increases chance** and **decreases chance** columns are proposals for
these signals. Neither overrides a hard prerequisite. No listed decrease sets an
otherwise useful eligible adaptation permanently to zero. Dangerous behavior is
not required to qualify, and deliberately taking damage must not be the fastest
way to farm defensive offers. Only actual observed deficits or interactions count.
Explain the main reason in the UI, for example: "More likely because your recent
births were limited by phosphorus." Do not expose a fake exact probability when
the eligible pool changes. A later implementation must retain bounded authoritative
context and deterministic recorded draws; reconnects/retries cannot reroll them.
### Budding and colony opportunity protection
- Attachment can appear before the fifth bud. It is not locked behind a badge.
- Proposed direction multipliers: after one successful active controlled birth,
1.5x; three, 2x; five, 3x for relevant eligible colony opportunities.
- Count actual funded births along the controlled succession path. Carry that
bounded milestone through one-way succession without duplicating it; never use
account age or all births from autonomous/offline relatives as earned credit.
- After five births, if two earned offers provide no colony entry option, reserve
one slot in the next earned offer for a useful eligible entry adaptation, such
as retained daughter attachment. This is proposed bad-luck protection, not an
automatic selection, free attached cell, or guaranteed survival.
- If no entry option is eligible because required mechanics are absent, explain
that limit in the playtest report. Probability tuning cannot fix missing colony
gameplay or justify claiming the 30-minute progression target is met.
- Independent-cell strategies remain available. Declining colony direction can
suppress its reserved slot temporarily through the same decaying preference
mechanism; it does not ban future colonies.
### Catalog reading guide
IDs **001-100 preserve the discussion's original ordering**; 101-150 extend it.
These are draft reference IDs, **not runtime mutation/operator IDs**.
Every row assumes the global hard checks above. "Available when" names its extra
prerequisites, not an assertion that the feature is implemented today. All rows
remain design candidates; especially currents, sensing, damage/repair, chemical
processing, colony transport, specialized tissues, dormancy, and environmental
hazards require supporting mechanics before their offers can ship.
The two chance columns describe observed recent activity/context, not mandatory
quests. A cost saving must correspond to actual tissue, work, or recipe changes.
If balancing cannot demonstrate both the benefit and drawback, revise or remove
the option rather than inventing a tooltip explanation.
## 001-010: Movement and navigation
| ID | Adaptation | Reason to want it | Drawback | Available when | Increases chance | Decreases chance |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 001 | Strong propulsion | Reach food and escape pursuit faster. | More E at high propulsion output. | Functional propulsion can be enlarged. | Long food trips; observed pursuits. | Feeding locally; propulsion seldom used. |
| 002 | Economical propulsion | Travel farther on limited E. | Lower maximum speed. | Propulsion has an economy/speed tradeoff. | Movement consumes much of acquired E. | Frequent chases require peak speed. |
| 003 | Burst propulsion | Briefly escape or intercept prey. | Depletes a limited burst reserve; weak sustained performance. | Propulsion and bounded burst storage work. | Short pursuits; repeated near interceptions. | Long uninterrupted travel. |
| 004 | Agile steering | Navigate dense bubbles and obstacles. | Less straight-line propulsion capacity. | Turning dynamics affect movement. | Productive routes require frequent turns. | Open, straight travel. |
| 005 | Straight swimmer | Cross open areas efficiently. | Wide turns hinder close maneuvering. | Body shape affects steering and drag. | Long straight feeding routes. | Dense obstacles; close turning. |
| 006 | Current sail | Travel using environmental flow. | Difficult upstream movement and precise positioning. | Perceivable currents and sail drag work. | Useful downstream foraging. | Still water; repeated upstream routes. |
| 007 | Surface anchor | Hold a productive location in flow. | Material investment; release needed before travel. | Suitable surfaces and anchoring work. | Productive local feeding disrupted by flow. | Frequent relocations; no useful surfaces. |
| 008 | Food-gradient sensing | Locate promising food before contact. | Sensory tissue consumes E and N. | Perceivable food gradients and sensing work. | Searches between discovered clusters. | Food is continuously within contact. |
| 009 | Shed independent propulsion | Cheaper stationary or carried offspring. | Cannot independently relocate or escape. | Propulsion exists; supported stationary/carried survival is plausible. | Producer surplus; reliable colony transport. | Independent travel; insufficient stationary intake. |
| 010 | Colony propulsion | Move several attached cells together. | Propulsion cells carry others and sacrifice feeding capacity. | Attached members and force transmission work. | Growing group struggles to move. | Solitary life; already ample group propulsion. |
## 011-020: Feeding and engulfing
| ID | Adaptation | Reason to want it | Drawback | Available when | Increases chance | Decreases chance |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 011 | Broad collection fringe | Touch more bubbles per pass. | More drag and exposed footprint. | Collection geometry affects contact. | Many nearby bubbles missed during passes. | Narrow gaps; frequent predator contact. |
| 012 | Concentrated intake | Drain rich clusters quickly. | Large machinery; little advantage between clusters. | Intake capacity has a tissue/work cost. | Contact feeding repeatedly hits its rate limit. | Deposits empty before intake capacity is used. |
| 013 | Generalist digestion | Use diverse food sources. | More machinery; lower specialist throughput. | At least two mechanically distinct food substrates exist. | Useful mixed diets. | One reliable substrate dominates feeding. |
| 014 | Selective intake | Collect a limiting nutrient without unwanted loading. | Reduced collection of other resources. | Resource-specific uptake and storage limits work. | One shortage despite other surpluses. | Several channels simultaneously scarce. |
| 015 | Detritus digestion | Use remains other cells process poorly. | Slow processing displaces fresh-food machinery. | Detritus differs meaningfully from fresh food. | Repeated successful scavenging. | Fresh food dominates; little detritus observed. |
| 016 | Expanding engulfment chamber | Capture larger prey relative to body size. | Reduced movement while occupied. | Engulfment volume and occupied-state costs work. | Suitable prey just beyond chamber capacity. | Feeding mostly on bubbles. |
| 017 | Armor digestion | Extract resources from protected prey. | Costly machinery; poor throughput on ordinary food. | Armor and substrate-specific digestion work. | Encounters with edible armored organisms. | Soft prey and bubbles dominate. |
| 018 | Prey retention | Keep captured prey from escaping. | Holding structures add mass and reduce feeding space. | Capture and escape are distinct supported outcomes. | Prey escapes during digestion. | Captures already reliably succeed. |
| 019 | Shed engulfment apparatus | Cheaper producer or bubble-feeding offspring. | No living prey intake. | Apparatus exists; nonprey feeding supports offspring. | Little prey intake; strong alternative feeding. | Prey supplies an important resource. |
| 020 | External digestion | Feed on remains too large to swallow. | Secretion costs material; rivals can steal released food. | Finite digestive secretion and released food are modeled. | Large remains; limited engulfment space. | Few remains; heavy theft of released material. |
## 021-030: Energy and photosynthesis
| ID | Adaptation | Reason to want it | Drawback | Available when | Increases chance | Decreases chance |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 021 | Acquire photosynthesis | Supplement E without energy bubbles. | Build and maintain light-capturing tissue. | Supported light capture; no photosynthesis in plan. | Lit feeding sites; E limits budding. | Persistently dark known habitat. |
| 022 | Expanded photosynthetic tissue | Produce more E in light. | More construction and tissue capacity occupied. | Photosynthesis exists and can expand. | Light capture useful but E still limiting. | Persistent E surplus; N/P construction shortage. |
| 023 | Mobile photosynthesis | Capture more light while travelling. | Lower peak stationary capture. | Mobile/stationary producer arrangements differ. | Productive movement by photosynthetic cells. | Successful stationary production. |
| 024 | Low-light pigments | Produce E in shade. | Lower maximum bright-light output. | Light intensity and pigment responses differ. | Shaded producer activity. | Consistently bright habitat. |
| 025 | Bright-light specialization | High output in exposed habitats. | Weak production in shade. | Distinct light intensity responses work. | Sustained strong light. | Frequent shade or variable illumination. |
| 026 | Shed photosynthesis | Remove unused producer costs. | Lose light-derived E. | Producer tissue exists; alternative E source works. | Dark habitat; feeding supplies E. | Light sustains maintenance or births. |
| 027 | Thorough energy extraction | Obtain more usable E per food unit. | Slower maximum processing rate. | Food-to-E yield and throughput trade off. | Food scarce; processing capacity underused. | E delivery rate limits abundant feeding. |
| 028 | Rapid energy extraction | Deliver E quickly during rich feeding. | Less E extracted per unit; more heat. | Actual yield/throughput tradeoff exists. | Abundant food; burst activity or rapid births. | Food scarcity; heat stress if modeled. |
| 029 | Expanded energy storage | Cross food-poor stretches. | Storage tissue and reserves add mass. | E capacity is bounded with physical storage costs. | Alternating abundance and shortages. | Continuous intake; mobility limited by carried mass. |
| 030 | Reduced energy storage | Lighter, cheaper offspring. | Shorter survival margin without intake. | E storage above a useful supported minimum exists. | Reliable local intake; costly carried reserves. | Long gaps between food or light. |
## 031-040: Nutrient demand, storage, and recycling
| ID | Adaptation | Reason to want it | Drawback | Available when | Increases chance | Decreases chance |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 031 | Carbon storage | Bank C for later growth and births. | Extra mass and storage space. | Bounded C storage has a tissue cost. | C-rich visits followed by C-limited births. | C always nearby; other capacity limiting. |
| 032 | Nitrogen storage | Carry scarce N between habitats. | More investment and less other storage. | Bounded N storage works. | Intermittent N abundance and shortages. | Constant N supply; N surplus rarely spent. |
| 033 | Phosphorus storage | Leave a rare P site without delaying births. | Carried mass without immediate survival benefit. | Bounded P storage works. | Births blocked by P after leaving deposits. | P consistently accessible. |
| 034 | Other Matter storage | Bank O for demanding structures. | Competes with other reserve capacity. | O has defined uses and bounded storage. | Intermittent O supply; O-limited construction. | Current body plans use little O. |
| 035 | Carbon-thrifty structure | Build offspring using less C. | Reduced mechanical strength. | Alternative structural recipe and strength effects work. | C-limited births. | High contact forces; structural damage. |
| 036 | Nitrogen-thrifty machinery | Reproduce in N-poor areas. | Lower peak machinery throughput. | A defined lower-N recipe changes actual capacity. | N shortages; machinery seldom at peak. | Peak feeding/propulsion repeatedly needed. |
| 037 | Phosphorus-thrifty development | Lower P cost per offspring. | Lower maximum assembly rate. | Lower-P development has an explicit recipe. | P-limited births. | Rapid assembly is useful; P abundant. |
| 038 | Reduced Other Matter dependence | Grow where O is scarce. | Lose performance of O-dependent structures. | Valid lower-O replacement recipe exists. | O blocks development. | O-based protection/support frequently useful. |
| 039 | Internal material recycling | Recover part of replaced tissue material. | Recovery machinery costs E; losses remain. | Tissue turnover and recovery transfers work. | Repeated repair/turnover under scarcity. | Little turnover; abundant raw nutrients. |
| 040 | Nutrient-retaining membrane | Reduce nutrient leakage. | Slower passive exchange. | Leakage and exchange both have consequences. | Losses worsen a limiting nutrient. | Intake throughput limits productive feeding. |
## 041-050: Size, shape, and construction
| ID | Adaptation | Reason to want it | Drawback | Available when | Increases chance | Decreases chance |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 041 | Larger adult size | Handle larger prey; resist some engulfers. | More upkeep and reproductive material. | Size changes both costs and interactions. | Useful prey outgrown; larger predators observed. | Reproduction repeatedly resource-limited. |
| 042 | Smaller adult size | Lower living and offspring costs. | Smaller reserves; more possible predators. | A smaller viable body is supported. | Scarce food; expensive births. | Large prey important; nearby size-based predation. |
| 043 | Elongated body | Spread contact along narrow feeding corridors. | Hard turning; exposed length. | Shape affects collision, feeding, and steering. | Long narrow food paths. | Tight turns; attacks along body. |
| 044 | Flattened body | More exposed feeding/light area. | Broad footprint harder to maneuver and protect. | Shape affects capture area and collision. | Surface feeding or light capture useful. | Crowded narrow routes; exposed-surface danger. |
| 045 | Rounded body | Compact geometry with less exposed surface. | Less capture/collection area per volume. | Geometry affects protection and exchange. | Surface damage; compact travel routes. | Uptake or light area limits growth. |
| 046 | Flexible body | Pass gaps and deform around obstacles. | Lower compression resistance. | Deformation and mechanical damage work. | Productive routes through tight gaps. | Compression or capture threats. |
| 047 | Rigid body | Resist deformation and transmit force. | Supporting material; cannot squeeze through gaps. | Rigidity affects mechanics. | Pushing, compression, or stable support useful. | Narrow passages; material-limited births. |
| 048 | Lightweight tissue | Move a broad footprint with less mass. | Less strength and contact force. | Density, mass, and strength differ by recipe. | Movement is costly; contact force seldom needed. | Forceful prey capture or collisions. |
| 049 | Dense tissue | Resist displacement and exert force. | Costly movement and construction. | Density affects force and material budgets. | Displacement disrupts feeding; force useful. | Long travel; frequent resource shortages. |
| 050 | Flexible adult size | Remain small in scarcity, grow in abundance. | Regulation costs; weaker peak specialization. | Bounded growth regulation and recipe costs work. | Repeated feast/famine transitions. | Stable conditions favor one size. |
## 051-060: Membranes and protection
| ID | Adaptation | Reason to want it | Drawback | Available when | Increases chance | Decreases chance |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 051 | Thick membrane | Resist puncture and applicable engulfment. | More material, upkeep, and mass. | Thickness provides actual protection. | Relevant predators or damage observed. | Safe habitat; membrane cost limits births. |
| 052 | Thin membrane | Cheaper, lighter offspring. | Lower protection. | Thinning changes both cost and protection. | Safe productive feeding; material shortage. | Repeated relevant attacks. |
| 053 | Protective shell | Survive attacks that soft cells cannot. | Heavy build; restricted expansion and intake openings. | Shell mechanics and feeding restrictions work. | Persistent protection-limited survival. | Fast travel/growth useful; few threats. |
| 054 | Stretchable membrane | Expand around food and changing shape. | Weaker against concentrated attacks. | Elasticity affects feeding and protection. | Engulfment/deformation regularly useful. | Puncture-like threats dominate. |
| 055 | Permeable membrane | Rapid dissolved nutrient exchange. | Leakage and harmful exposure. | Dissolved uptake and leakage are modeled. | Rich dissolved sources; low hazards. | Toxic exposure; costly nutrient losses. |
| 056 | Selective membrane | Retain nutrients and exclude hazards. | Active transport E and lower peak exchange. | Selective transport processes work. | Leakage or contamination limits feeding. | Clean, rich sources need throughput. |
| 057 | Slippery surface | Escape adhesive capture. | Harder to maintain useful attachment. | Adhesion and detachment work. | Unwanted attachment or capture observed. | Stable colony junctions needed. |
| 058 | Adhesive surface | Hold food and establish contact. | Unwanted sticking; difficult detachment. | Surface adhesion has physical effects. | Useful surface feeding; neighboring buds. | Frequent escape/dispersal; debris fouling. |
| 059 | Active membrane repair | Recover from survivable damage. | Repair consumes E and materials. | Nonfatal damage and repair accounting work. | Damage interrupts otherwise viable feeding. | Little damage; nutrients needed for reproduction. |
| 060 | Shed protective shell | Restore mobility, growth, and intake access. | Lose shell protection. | Shell exists; viable unshelled strategy supported. | Shell hinders feeding/travel; threats absent. | Shell frequently prevents injury. |
## 061-070: Budding and offspring investment
| ID | Adaptation | Reason to want it | Drawback | Available when | Increases chance | Decreases chance |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 061 | Small buds | Produce offspring with less material per birth. | Smaller newborn reserves and protection. | A smaller viable newborn recipe exists. | Birth cost limits expansion. | Small newborns repeatedly fail to establish. |
| 062 | Large buds | Offspring feed and defend themselves sooner. | Fewer births from the same reserves. | Variable funded newborn size is supported. | Small newborns struggle in observed habitat. | Parent cannot fund frequent births. |
| 063 | Split brood | Spread one investment among several offspring. | Each begins smaller; total matter is unchanged. | Multi-birth placement and partitioning work. | Several nearby establishment opportunities. | Individual newborn size is critical. |
| 064 | Rapid bud assembly | Use brief food surpluses quickly. | High assembly power; worse construction efficiency. | Assembly rate and energy efficiency differ. | Surplus lost before ordinary assembly completes. | E scarcity; stable supply. |
| 065 | Energy-provisioned buds | Give newborns fuel for dispersal. | More parent E transferred per birth. | Provisioning is explicit and funded. | Newborns face gaps before first feeding. | Nearby food; parent E limits reproduction. |
| 066 | Nutrient-provisioned buds | Let newborns grow away from nutrient deposits. | Transfer scarce material; fewer siblings. | Per-channel provisioning works. | Newborns encounter nutrient-poor habitat. | Parent nutrient shortages; reliable local deposits. |
| 067 | Compact budding apparatus | Lower reproductive tissue upkeep. | Lower maximum birth frequency. | Reproductive tissue cost and rate are modeled. | Intermittent reproduction; scarce resources. | Continuous surplus supports fast expansion. |
| 068 | Brood chamber | Protect developing buds. | Carry developing mass; clustered loss risk. | Exposed development and chamber protection work. | Developing buds encounter hazards. | Travel burden; safe open development. |
| 069 | Dispersing offspring | Establish descendants beyond local depletion. | Dispersal investment; fewer nearby collaborators. | Newborn dispersal has physical machinery/costs. | Crowded, depleted birth sites. | Useful local partners and abundant local food. |
| 070 | Dormant offspring | Preserve descendants through bad conditions. | No feeding or reproductive contribution while dormant. | Finite dormancy and activation conditions work. | Observed recurring unsuitable periods. | Stable productive conditions. |
## 071-080: Colonies and cooperation
| ID | Adaptation | Reason to want it | Drawback | Available when | Increases chance | Decreases chance |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 071 | Retained daughter attachment | Keep buds together and form a colony. | Local competition and movement burden. | Funded attachment and viable attached feeding work. | Successful births; nearby descendants; five-bud direction. | Crowded depletion; recent attachment declines. |
| 072 | Loose attachment | Separate when trapped or locally starved. | Colony breaks apart under smaller stresses. | Attachment strength can vary. | Trapping; uneven local food. | Separation repeatedly harms members. |
| 073 | Flexible junctions | Bend around obstacles without separating. | Poorer force transfer. | Attached geometry and junction mechanics work. | Colony encounters narrow/curved routes. | Straight propulsion needs rigid force transfer. |
| 074 | Rigid junctions | Maintain shape and transmit pushing force. | Costly junctions; less maneuverable. | Junction stiffness affects movement. | Propulsive forces deform useful arrangements. | Gaps and turns impede travel. |
| 075 | Feeding channels | Supply food to interior members. | Fewer cells per footprint. | Colony geometry affects food access. | Interior feeding deficits; fed outer members. | Small groups with no sheltered interior. |
| 076 | Energy transfer junctions | Productive members support E-poor members. | Transfer losses and donor opportunity cost. | Paired E transfers and junction costs work. | Uneven E among connected members. | Members independently E-sufficient. |
| 077 | Nutrient transfer junctions | Supply growing or specialized cells. | Transport machinery; donor depletion risk. | Per-channel member transfers work. | Complementary nutrient surpluses/shortages. | Similar deficits across all members. |
| 078 | Coordinated polarity | Align feeding surfaces and propulsion. | Harder reversal/reorganization. | Shared orientation and force coordination work. | Members push against one another. | Frequently changing routes and food directions. |
| 079 | Branching colony growth | Expand exposed feeding surface in several directions. | Fragile connections; large defensive perimeter. | Controlled attachment geometry works. | Separated nearby food/light opportunities. | Strong shear; perimeter attacks. |
| 080 | Shed attachment | Leave a failing group and establish independently. | Lose collective transport and protection. | Attachment exists; independent offspring are viable. | Group depletion or trapping; independent resources nearby. | Strong dependence on transport or donors. |
## 081-090: Producers and resource exchange
| ID | Adaptation | Reason to want it | Drawback | Available when | Increases chance | Decreases chance |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 081 | Carbon fixation | Use inorganic environmental C instead of C bubbles. | Work E and processing machinery. | Defined accessible carbon source and conversion work. | C scarcity beside suitable source. | Cheap organic C; source inaccessible. |
| 082 | Nitrogen fixation | Access environmental N unavailable to ordinary feeders. | High processing E and specialized tissue. | Explicit suitable N source and balanced conversion exist. | N shortage; useful source and E surplus. | N-rich food; E shortage. |
| 083 | Phosphate mobilization | Access P in otherwise unusable deposits. | Contact/process costs; source dependence. | Defined P-bearing deposits can be processed. | Births P-limited beside deposits. | Readily edible P; frequent relocation. |
| 084 | Other Matter extraction | Obtain O from a specified environmental source. | Machinery useless away from that source. | An O-bearing source and extraction recipe exist. | O scarcity with source access. | Little O demand; cheap edible O. |
| 085 | Energy-rich secretion | Supply descendants or useful neighbors. | Export E and secretion material; theft possible. | Finite secretion and uptake by recipients work. | E surplus; useful nearby recipients. | E shortage; secretion mostly stolen or wasted. |
| 086 | Nitrogen secretion | Support N-poor partners supplying another need. | Lose acquired N; depend on useful neighbors. | Explicit N secretion and recipient uptake work. | N surplus and productive complementary partners. | N shortage; no useful recipients. |
| 087 | Phosphorus recovery | Recover P from specified waste/remains. | Recovery E; limited source stock. | Waste has tracked recoverable P. | P shortage with recoverable local waste. | Fresh P abundant; little recoverable material. |
| 088 | Controlled resource exchange | Trade surplus for a limiting resource. | Exchange structures; partner dependence. | Paired bounded exchanges and compatible interfaces work. | Complementary observed surpluses and deficits. | No compatible partner; similar shortages. |
| 089 | Specialized daughter cells | Divide feeding, producer, and movement roles. | Dependent specialists need transport and support. | Role-specific development and colony support work. | Complementary roles; supported growing colony. | Repeated separation; inadequate transport. |
| 090 | Self-sufficient daughter cells | Survive separation and disperse. | Duplicate machinery and higher per-cell cost. | Generalist offspring can be developed. | Fragmentation; variable partners. | Stable colony with useful specialization. |
## 091-100: Environmental adaptation
| ID | Adaptation | Reason to want it | Drawback | Available when | Increases chance | Decreases chance |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 091 | Heat specialization | Feed and reproduce in hot habitat. | Worse cool performance; protective costs. | Temperature changes actual survival/performance. | Useful hot feeding areas observed. | Cool habitat; little thermal variation. |
| 092 | Cold specialization | Remain productive in cold habitat. | Worse warm performance. | Functional temperature response exists. | Useful cold feeding areas observed. | Warm habitat dominates. |
| 093 | Broad thermal tolerance | Cross boundaries and survive fluctuations. | More machinery; lower specialist peak efficiency. | Thermal protection has real costs and benefits. | Repeated temperature changes on useful routes. | Stable narrow temperature band. |
| 094 | Narrow thermal specialization | Efficient operation in one stable band. | Vulnerability outside that band. | Defined specialist recipe saves actual costs. | Stable productive temperature. | Frequent thermal transitions. |
| 095 | Thermal acclimation | Adjust to gradual temperature change. | Adjustment time/E; abrupt shifts still dangerous. | Bounded acclimation and thermal effects work. | Gradual recurrent temperature changes. | Constant conditions or very abrupt shifts. |
| 096 | Toxin exclusion | Use contaminated food-rich areas. | Slower useful uptake; barrier costs. | Specific contaminants and exclusion work. | Valuable resources behind contamination. | Clean habitat; intake throughput limiting. |
| 097 | Shed unused thermal protection | Cheaper offspring in a safe band. | Lose the former protected range. | Costly protection exists and temperature gameplay works. | Stable safe habitat; protection rarely used. | Thermal transitions or exposed migration. |
| 098 | Protective resting state | Survive temporary environmental crisis. | Stop feeding, travel, and reproduction while protected. | Funded resting state and finite survival rules work. | Recurring short hazards. | Stable productive habitat. |
| 099 | Flow-resistant attachment | Stay at useful sites in strong currents. | Heavy attachment and costly relocation. | Flow and surface attachment work. | Current repeatedly dislodges feeding organisms. | Weak flow; frequent travel. |
| 100 | Light-direction sensing | Seek useful illumination or avoid excess. | Sensory and corrective-movement costs. | Spatial light differences and sensing work. | Productive routes between light zones. | Uniform illumination; light irrelevant to strategy. |
## 101-110: Additional sensing and communication
| ID | Adaptation | Reason to want it | Drawback | Available when | Increases chance | Decreases chance |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 101 | Predator-cue sensing | Detect nearby biological danger earlier. | Sensory upkeep; imperfect cues can divert feeding. | Biological cues and readable detection limits work. | Nearby predators observed, without requiring injury. | Few threats; expensive unnecessary detours. |
| 102 | Chemical compatibility recognition | Attach or exchange with compatible cells more reliably. | Recognition machinery; rejects some usable unfamiliar partners. | Actual chemical interfaces exist; no account/owner labels. | Useful compatible contacts; failed incompatible contacts. | Solitary life; diverse beneficial partners. |
| 103 | Resource composition sensing | Choose deposits containing the limiting nutrient. | Sensor cost; cannot collect resources itself. | Deposits differ in composition and can be sensed. | Repeated one-channel shortages amid mixed deposits. | All nearby food has similar composition. |
| 104 | Flow sensing | Choose favorable currents and safer attachment sites. | Sensory E/N investment. | Spatial currents and limited local sensing work. | Flow strongly changes productive travel. | Still habitat; no benefit from route adjustment. |
| 105 | Contact feelers | Navigate obstacles without exposing the whole body. | Extra drag and vulnerable projections. | Contact geometry and obstacle feedback work. | Obstacle-rich productive routes. | Open routes; projections frequently damaged. |
| 106 | Prey-size sensing | Avoid costly futile engulfment attempts. | Sensory tissue instead of feeding capacity. | Prey geometry can be sensed within limits. | Encounters near engulfment thresholds. | Prey absent or uniformly easy to take. |
| 107 | Compact short-range sensing | Cheaper close-quarters sensing. | Less warning and discovery range. | Existing sensing can trade range for tissue cost. | Dense local food and short routes. | Widely separated targets; distant threats. |
| 108 | Shed food sensing | Cheaper feeders supplied locally or through a colony. | Cannot independently locate distant food. | Food sensor exists; local feeding strategy viable. | Reliable contact supply; colony guidance. | Independent foraging; patchy food. |
| 109 | Colony signal relay | Coordinate distant members without every cell sensing everything. | Signal production and relay costs; delay. | Bounded biological signaling and connected roles work. | Group coordination fails across distance. | Small group; little coordination need. |
| 110 | Shed signal relay | Remove unnecessary communication machinery. | Lose distant coordination. | Relay exists; independent/local behavior remains viable. | Solitary dispersal; tiny groups. | Distant members depend on relay. |
## 111-120: Metabolic allocation and physiological regulation
| ID | Adaptation | Reason to want it | Drawback | Available when | Increases chance | Decreases chance |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 111 | Low idle metabolism | Spend less E between productive activities. | Slower return to full output. | Physiological activity and wake-up work are modeled. | Frequent short inactive intervals between useful actions. | Continuous pursuit or feeding. |
| 112 | High-output metabolism | Sustain intense feeding, propulsion, or assembly. | Higher basal upkeep of supporting machinery. | Tissue-backed metabolic throughput has a real limit. | Useful actions repeatedly hit delivery limits. | Low utilization; food scarcity. |
| 113 | Demand-responsive intake | Avoid spending transport E on already-full reserves. | Regulation costs and delayed response to new food. | Active uptake costs E and reserves have limits. | Frequent excess uptake effort. | Rapidly changing food; few full reserves. |
| 114 | Reserve rationing | Preserve maintenance E through short shortages. | Lower available movement and assembly output. | Explicit reserve allocation affects actual actions. | Brief predictable feeding gaps. | Peak escape power often needed. |
| 115 | Surplus storage synthesis | Package temporary E surplus into usable stored reserves. | Processing E/material costs and storage delay. | Reserve packaging has specified inputs and capacity. | Bursty capture exceeds immediate use. | Persistent scarcity; little surplus. |
| 116 | Reversible machinery shutdown | Reduce upkeep of temporarily unused functions. | Restart consumes time/E; regulation tissue costs. | Physiological suppression works without deleting anatomy. | Alternating use of expensive capabilities. | All functions continuously needed. |
| 117 | Emergency movement reserve | Keep escape fuel from ordinary growth spending. | Less reserve freely available for births and feeding. | Explicit bounded reserve partitioning works. | Encounters occur just after heavy construction. | Safe habitat; reserved fuel rarely used. |
| 118 | Flexible nutrient allocation | Redirect available material to the most useful ongoing tissue task. | Regulation overhead; slower peak assembly. | Competing growth/repair tasks and allocation work. | Alternating repair and growth shortages. | One stable construction task dominates. |
| 119 | Conservative reproductive provisioning | Avoid leaving the parent without basic survival reserves. | Smaller or less frequent births during marginal conditions. | Heritable provisioning policy and actual reserve bounds work. | Births followed by parent shortages. | Reliable immediate refilling after birth. |
| 120 | Shed broad digestive machinery | Cheap specialist offspring using a reliable substrate. | Lose access to other food types. | Generalist machinery exists; retained food source viable. | One substrate consistently supplies needs. | Mixed/variable diet important. |
## 121-130: Colony architecture and tissue precursors
| ID | Adaptation | Reason to want it | Drawback | Available when | Increases chance | Decreases chance |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 121 | Junction scaffolding | Support larger attachments and future force-bearing tissue. | C/O construction and extra mass. | Explicit scaffold recipe and structural loads work. | Junction stresses limit useful group growth. | Small flexible groups; O scarcity. |
| 122 | Contractile specialist cells | Generate coordinated force for a group. | High N/E demand; reduced independent feeding. | Specialized force generation and support transport work. | A supported group lacks propulsion/force. | Nutrient transport absent; low force demand. |
| 123 | Support specialist cells | Protect soft members and maintain body shape. | Nonfeeding mass must be supported. | Role differentiation and physical support work. | Soft group deformation causes problems. | Small independent groups; scarce food. |
| 124 | Producer surface sorting | Place light-capturing cells where light reaches them. | Repositioning/junction cost; exposes producers. | Colony rearrangement and self-shading work. | Producers are shaded by other members. | Uniform exposure; little photosynthesis. |
| 125 | Peripheral feeding layer | Collect food around a group and transport it inward. | Outer feeders vulnerable; inner cells become dependent. | Spatial roles and member transport work. | Interior shortage despite exterior abundance. | Small group; transport bottlenecks. |
| 126 | Protected reproductive cells | Keep developing offspring inside a supported group. | Other cells must feed and protect a nonfeeding role. | Differentiation, brood development, and protection work. | Exposed births fail near viable colonies. | Low group surplus; dispersal priority. |
| 127 | Modular growth units | Limit damage spread between colony regions. | Duplicate junction/support machinery; slower integration. | Mechanical modules and localized damage work. | Local damage propagates through a group. | Small stable group; costs dominate. |
| 128 | Detachable dispersal lobe | Release a funded multicell fragment to establish elsewhere. | Lose group tissue and reserve investment. | Viable fragment development/separation work. | Local crowding; reachable new habitat. | Small group; strong mutual dependence. |
| 129 | Hollow colony arrangement | Expose inner surfaces to food flow. | Larger footprint and weaker compact support. | Food movement through explicit colony geometry works. | Interior access limits a growing group. | Crushing/shear threats; little interior shortage. |
| 130 | Radial colony arrangement | Feed and respond in several directions. | Poorer forward specialization and pursuit. | Attachment geometry affects feeding/propulsion. | Resources arrive from changing directions. | Long directional travel or hunting. |
Modules/fragments never restore a dead controlled organism. Autonomous survivors
keep their own identities; player control still follows accepted succession and
permadeath rules. Tissue-like precursors do not themselves authorize the separate
multicellular or 3D transition.
## 131-140: Loss, simplification, and alternative material use
| ID | Adaptation | Reason to want it | Drawback | Available when | Increases chance | Decreases chance |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 131 | Shed expanded nitrogen storage | Lighter offspring with less storage tissue. | Cannot bank as much N between deposits. | Expanded N storage exists; baseline storage remains viable. | Continuous N supply; unused capacity. | Intermittent N; shortages between visits. |
| 132 | Shed expanded phosphorus storage | Lower storage construction and carried mass. | Shorter independence from P sources. | Expanded P storage exists. | Reliable P supply; capacity seldom used. | Rare P sites fund later births. |
| 133 | Shed expanded carbon storage | Free body capacity for active machinery. | Less C available for growth after leaving food. | Expanded C storage exists. | Constant C access; crowded tissue capacity. | Large intermittent growth demands. |
| 134 | Shed expanded Other Matter storage | Reduce investment in seldom-used O reserves. | Lose preparation for O-heavy construction. | Expanded O storage exists. | Low O use; reliable O access. | Planned O-dependent support/protection. |
| 135 | Shed nutrient exchange junctions | Cheaper independently feeding offspring. | Lose nutrient support and trade. | Nutrient junctions exist; independent feeding viable. | Members self-sufficient; transfers rarely used. | Specialized members need imported nutrients. |
| 136 | Shed energy exchange junctions | Reduce transport losses and junction upkeep. | Cannot support or receive E from neighbors. | E junctions exist; independent E budget viable. | Little beneficial transfer. | Producers support shaded/nonfeeding cells. |
| 137 | Shed nitrogen fixation | Remove costly unused processing tissue. | Depend again on food/partners for N. | Fixation exists; alternative N accessible. | N-rich food; processing E scarce. | Environmental processing supplies most N. |
| 138 | Shed carbon fixation | Remove unused carbon-processing machinery. | Lose access to inorganic C. | Fixation exists; organic C source viable. | Reliable organic food; little fixation output. | Inorganic source supports most construction. |
| 139 | Shed selective intake machinery | Restore broad intake and reduce sorting costs. | More unwanted loading; less targeted collection. | Selective uptake exists; broad feeding viable. | Several channels needed; little excess loading. | One persistent shortage amid other surpluses. |
| 140 | Carbon-rich protective covering | Replace an O-dependent covering where O is scarce. | More C and lower rigidity/protection. | Explicit replacement recipe conserves each channel. | O-limited covering development; C surplus. | C scarcity; rigid protection essential. |
These losses need actual savings. Merely deleting a parameter is not a benefit.
Replacing O with a C-rich structure changes the recipe; it does not convert O to C.
## 141-150: Further habitat and energy specializations
| ID | Adaptation | Reason to want it | Drawback | Available when | Increases chance | Decreases chance |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 141 | Osmotic buffering | Survive changes in external dissolved concentration. | Buffer material and regulation E. | Water exchange and osmotic stress work. | Useful routes cross concentration boundaries. | Stable concentration; buffer seldom used. |
| 142 | Salt specialization | Operate efficiently in a stable salty habitat. | Poor performance in dilute habitat. | Explicit salinity and supported response exist. | Productive saline sites. | Dilute sites or frequent salinity changes. |
| 143 | Acid specialization | Use acidic resource-rich habitat. | Poor neutral/alkaline performance; protection cost. | Acidity has actual supported effects. | Useful acidic sites observed. | Neutral/alkaline foraging dominates. |
| 144 | Alkaline specialization | Use alkaline resource-rich habitat. | Poor acidic performance; protection cost. | Alkalinity has actual supported effects. | Useful alkaline sites observed. | Acidic sites or frequent transitions. |
| 145 | Broad chemical buffering | Cross variable pH/salinity boundaries. | More machinery; lower specialist efficiency. | Each buffered hazard and its material cost work. | Recurrent chemical transitions on useful routes. | One stable chemical habitat. |
| 146 | Excess-light shielding | Remain productive under damaging illumination. | Shield blocks some useful light and costs material. | Excess light causes real damage or capture impairment. | Useful high-light sites cause overexposure. | Shade; weak illumination. |
| 147 | Oxygen-assisted energy extraction | Extract more E from food where oxygen is available. | Requires environmental oxygen and respiratory tissue. | Explicit oxygen compartment, reactants, and energy balance exist. | Food and oxygen coexist; yield limits survival. | Low oxygen; machinery rarely useful. |
| 148 | Oxygen-independent energy extraction | Remain active without environmental oxygen. | Lower food-to-usable-E yield and/or output. | Defined balanced oxygen-independent pathway exists. | Productive oxygen-poor habitat. | Stable oxygen-rich conditions favor another pathway. |
| 149 | Chemical energy capture | Gain usable E from a defined environmental chemical reaction. | Source dependence and processing machinery. | Finite reactants/potential, products, and conversion are modeled. | Useful chemical source; light/food E scarce. | No accessible reactants; ample ordinary E. |
| 150 | Shed chemical energy capture | Remove unused processing tissue. | Lose that environmental E source. | Capture machinery exists; another E source supports offspring. | Relocation away from reactants; unused machinery. | Chemical reaction sustains the current strategy. |
Oxygen in 147-148 is a separately modeled environmental species, never the O
inventory abbreviation. Neither pathway creates food energy from nothing;
conversion must debit the appropriate finite chemical energy and material inputs.
## Future evolutionary consequences
Consequences should follow anatomy, material recipes, and support relationships.
They are not permanent hidden class locks. Reacquisition/replacement is possible
through future eligible adaptations, with real construction costs.
| Earlier choices | Potential later consequence | Route to adapt again |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 036 nitrogen-thrifty machinery | High-output contractile tissue/limbs exceed the supported N recipe or throughput. | Improve N acquisition/transport and build a richer recipe, or use lower-output structures. |
| 037 phosphorus-thrifty development | Low-P construction cannot assemble a large new organ at specialist speed. | Restore faster assembly with more P, or retain thrift and build gradually. |
| 038 reduced O dependence | An O-requiring support or protective structure cannot be built from the current recipe. | Reintroduce O use or select an explicit alternative construction. |
| 009 shed propulsion | Independent mobile descendants lack a force-producing structure. | Reacquire propulsion or develop supported contractile tissue. |
| 021-025 photosynthetic specialization | Light-facing surface and nutrient supply constrain thicker bodies. | Rearrange producer surfaces, develop transport, mix feeding strategies. |
| 076-077 resource transfer | Support for internal specialists becomes possible, but separation is harder. | Retain transfer or produce self-sufficient dispersing descendants. |
| 089 specialized daughters | A detached specialist may not survive independently. | Provide viable generalist development or retain support until establishment. |
| 090 self-sufficient daughters | Duplicated machinery makes dense specialized tissue expensive. | Specialize some roles while establishing replacement support. |
| 053 shell or 074 rigid junctions | Flexible limbs/growth openings need an explicit mechanical arrangement. | Local joints/openings, flexible replacements, or shedding in future offspring. |
| 052 thin membrane | Exposed organs and transport paths may need reinforcement. | Add local protective tissue rather than forcing whole-body thickening. |
| 061 small buds | Small founders face limited reserves for large-organ construction. | Larger/provisioned offspring or staged funded growth. |
| 069 dispersal and 080 detachment | Local cooperating population is harder to retain. | Reacquire attachment or develop a mixture of retained and dispersing offspring. |
| 078 polarity and 130 radial arrangement | Different body layouts favor different directions of feeding and force. | Rearrange attachment/development rather than applying a universal speed penalty. |
| 093 broad tolerance versus 094 narrow specialization | Migration range and local efficiency diverge. | Rebuild broader protection or remain a habitat specialist. |
| 121-129 structural precursors | Make some integrated body plans feasible but increase support/transport demands. | Fund missing tissues and transport; no automatic free multicellular conversion. |
Example player-facing card:
> **Nitrogen-thrifty machinery**
>
> Your offspring need less nitrogen, making births easier in this habitat. Their
> maximum feeding and propulsion output will be lower.
>
> **Why offered:** recent births were limited by nitrogen while food was available.
>
> **Future consequence:** high-output organs need more nitrogen or a different
> construction strategy. This choice does not permanently forbid limbs.
>
> **Expression:** future offspring. Your existing body stays as it is.
## Initial subset and balancing work
Pick roughly 20-30 adaptations for an initial coherent experiment. Start with
movement, contact feeding, meaningful energy yield/throughput, small/large buds,
photosynthesis, and attachment. A suggested evaluation set is:
001, 002, 011, 012, 014, 016, 019, 021, 022, 026, 027, 028, 029, 030, 031,
032, 033, 041, 042, 061, 062, 063, 065, 066, 067, 071, 072, 073, 080.
This is **29 candidates to evaluate**, not a claim that 29 can ship now. For
example, 014 needs real selective uptake, 027-028 need a real yield/throughput
tradeoff, storage needs capacity costs, and colony options need working colony
behavior. Exclude an option until both its advantage and drawback are supported.
Prefer a smaller useful set over filling offers with inert possibilities.
Do not offer plain decreased energy conversion, unsupported thermal changes,
isolated shed-movement, or cosmetic numerical mutations with no changed decisions.
Inverse adaptations must each earn their place; no requirement says every trait
needs four automatically generated increase/decrease/acquire/shed buttons.
Measure the following in controlled playtests before accepting numeric rules:
| Question | Evidence needed |
| --- | --- |
| Can an ordinary active founder bud within three minutes? | Distributions across seeds and novice routes; energy and every material bottleneck. |
| Does active foraging beat camping? | Net useful intake after movement/maintenance, time spent stationary by reason, and actual birth times. |
| Does each choice change play? | Subsequent routes, food use, offspring investment, and observed downsides, not acceptance alone. |
| Are colony seekers progressing? | Successful birth count, eligible offers, misses, first attachment, and supported group survival. |
| Does bad luck respect the intended duration? | Median and tail times to useful attachment/progression, not only average draws. |
| Are other strategies still discoverable? | Eligible family diversity, observed choice diversity, and recovery after declines/shedding. |
| Does growth produce an ecosystem? | Offspring establishment, local depletion, interactions, recycling, and lineage persistence. |
| Are future consequences readable? | Players can explain a choice's present cost and later dependency before accepting it. |
Activity and draw records must be bounded, authoritative, reproducible, and
account-free in aggregate reports where possible. Player observations remain
consented playtest notes rather than silently expanded behavioral surveillance.
## Decisions still open
- Which trial timings/weights actually meet the three-minute and 30-60-minute
targets across ordinary players, seeds, and resource channels?
- Which exact adaptations form the first coherent set, and what physical recipe
and measured drawback does each use?
- What earns engaged stationary-play credit without rewarding unattended camping
or requiring meaningless input?
- Which bounded context/preferences carry through succession, and how quickly
should a player be able to change evolutionary direction?
- Should stronger bad-luck protection be opt-in through an expressed direction,
rather than inferred only from behavior?
- How are useful multi-change adaptations represented without hiding dependent
losses or turning the catalog into fixed classes?
- What exact tissue/reserve partition and viable-size rules support immediate
division, and which reproductive adaptations apply to division versus budding?
- How does the UI preview Evolve now versus Prepare offspring, including both
resulting organisms and the irreversible control choice?
- Which real developmental work makes a divergent offspring more expensive,
without double-charging transferred tissue or making experimentation too slow?
- Which traits can change physiologically during life, and which only develop in
offspring? Classify each operator explicitly before implementation.
- How do colony membership, resource ownership, control, death, and logout work
under the current accepted inheritance requirements?
- What separates an attached colony from funded integrated multicellular tissue,
and what additional qualification precedes entry to the 3D habitat?
- Is truly nutrient-free alternative chemistry desirable, or are lower demand and
different acquisition paths sufficient? No total C/N/P/O removal is accepted here.
- Are heritable mutation-frequency/replication traits desirable? Do not add them
merely to make a 150-option catalog: faster mutation opportunities need a useful
tradeoff and must not gate basic budding or create another waiting-time economy.
## Draft completion checks
This documentation segment should verify exactly 150 unique sequential draft IDs,
seven populated fields per catalog row, resolvable local source links, and no
trailing whitespace. These checks validate document structure only. They do not
validate ecological balance, implementation availability, or the pacing targets.